Monday, 13 April 2020

Counterrevolution

In Poul Anderson's "Cold Victory," the anti-Humanist counterrevolutionary forces control Earth apart from a score of fortresses sheltering Dictator Carnarvon and his loyalists. However, the orbiting Terrestrial space navy, comprising commandeered Solar Guard units, remains pro-Humanist and Admiral K'ung threatens nuclear bombardment which would kill maybe a hundred million civilians, destroy factories and poison sea ranches.

I find it unbelievable first that an interplanetary war like this could happen after the years of peace under the UN, then the Solar Union, secondly that a man trying to save Earth from psychotechnic rule could threaten such a bombardment of Earth and thirdly that anyone would obey his orders.

In Asimov's future history, a single Admiral who suggested deliberately causing nuclear explosions as an act of war was immediately killed by his own men.

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

But, remember how Anderson described Admiral K'ung as a man resolutely loyal to his oath of allegiance and the strong moral HOLD he had over his men. Habit, training, loyalty to the "chain of command," and deep respect for a commander, etc., explains why Admiral K'ung's men would obey him.

So, I don't find the scenario in "Cold Victory" that hard to believe.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

If there's one thing that can happen at any moment, it's lethal conflict. That's the default human method; anything else is artificial, hence unstable, however desirable.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

Again, you said in a brief, pithy way why I cannot agree with Paul's hopes.

Ad astra! Sean