Poul Anderson Appreciation
Sunday, 4 October 2026
Last Sights Of The Sun
Space And Time Wars
Some Andersonian wars are fought not in space but through time. See Three Wars Through Time.
And, like a prescient Hegelian synthesis, a space battle had been combined with time travel in Anderson's earlier "Flight to Forever." See Time Wars and Space-Time Battle.
As several times before, there is a sense of completeness, of an author who explores every possible answer to several major questions. Can time travellers change the past? Yes, in Time Patrol. No, in There Will Be Time. Etc.
All The Gods
The alien general, Hunda:
"'By the gods, if we had decent weapons!'" (p. 217)
Saunders:
"...thought how beautiful [Taury] was - by all the gods, how beautiful!" (p. 218)
Does a new polytheism seem appropriate for a multi-species, interstellar civilization? It does to me but, in any case, we have already addressed this question in more detail than I would have felt able to do at present. See here.
James Blish's phrase, "gods of all stars," common to his Okie and pantropy series, seems especially pertinent.
See also The National Anthem.
Saturday, 3 October 2026
More Ultrawave
Although James Blish's fictional futures feature an ultrawave/ultraphone, this is clearly different from the one in the Andersonian futures.
Sf jargon like "hyperdrive," "warp drive," "Terra," "Terran" etc can generate a spurious sense of continuity between diverse narratives. My father, having heard "warp drive" mentioned in Star Trek, remarked to me that it was also referenced in Lost In Space whereas to me, of course, this was just familiar sf terminology. We need sf that breaks out of genre cliches. The future will be different from anything that has been imagined so let's imagine something that has not yet been imagined. I started this post just with the word, "ultrawave," and did not know where I was going with it. Now I must watch some TV news and get back to rereading Stieg Larsson.
We have not yet exhausted the temporal epic, "Flight to Forever."
Imperial Claim
Hunda says that:
Maurco the Doomer was the last properly anointed Galactic Emperor even though he held only three planetary systems five thousand years ago;
Taury is his direct descendant;
therefore, she, and not any of the 100+ human or nonhuman barbarian pretenders, has the only real Imperial claim even though she is now holed up in a single fortress in the galactic periphery.
How strong a case is that? In 50,000 AD, on a Galactic scale and across five millennia, formal anointment and hereditary rule? Someone with superior firepower could sweep it aside and then a new de facto would become a new de jure as happened here: British monarchs are "...since the Conquest." (My emphasis.)
In any case, the two time travellers will secure Taury's claim. The Empire will be restored - and Saunders will be compelled to leave it behind in his "Flight Without End." The narrative is both temporal and cosmic.
Dialogue Between Martin Saunders And Vargor Alfri
The Second Empire II
The Dreamer, a member of the Vro-Hi species:
"'...was working further on the philosophical basis which the Second Empire must have.'" (pp. 211-212)
In our history, no one worked out the philosophical basis for a civilization, then built the civilization! Plato and Hegel understandably but mistakenly thought that ideas preceded realities. In reality, people worked to survive, then produced a surplus which supported more complex societies in which a minority had the leisure to philosophize. Thales and the other pre-Socratics theorized about the constituents of matter and nature but Socrates preferred to analyze concepts and his disciple, Plato, made the mistake of thinking that concepts or "Ideas" were primary whereas the manual labour of slaves which fed Greek aristocrats and philosophers was secondary.
Later theorists analyzed, rationalized and criticized the material/economic basis of their society, e.g., Adam Smith and Karl Marx. Maybe a Vro-Hi philosopher can conceptualize in advance of the building of a new society but, if so, he can do this only on the basis of all that has gone before on Earth and elsewhere.
The Time Traveller And Martin Saunders
Poul Anderson's Martin Saunders spends time with Taury the Red and the Galactic Empire in 50,000 AD, then is sent on the Flight without End before returning to the twentieth century.
The two narratives have structural similarities. Anderson is a Wellsian sf writer and acknowledges Wells in There Will Be Time.
This was a last minute thought before setting off for routine Saturday afternoon city centre activities.
Ad futurum.
Self Mastery
In 4300 AD, Martin Saunders contemplates:
"...the far suns that man had conquered without mastering himself." (p. 189)
"...without mastering himself..." reads like an unexamined cliche. Is it just a given that man can master his environment but not himself? In Anderson's own Psychotechnic History, methods of self-knowledge and self-control are developed. In his Brain Wave, intelligence gains control of instinct. Moves in this direction have already been made in Saunders' timeline. In 4100 AD:
"'...the Council will probably order your temporal deportation as unintegrated individuals. The sanity of Sol will be in danger otherwise.'" (p. 186)
"They even pleaded Belgotai's case to the Solar Council, via telescreen. But the answer was inexorable: the Galaxy already had too many barbarians. The travelers would have to go." (p. 187)
In 50,000 AD, the Dreamer offers to remove the time travellers' neuroses but Belgotai declines.
Self mastery is possible.
3100-50,000 AD
In several periods, Saunders and Belgotai do not pause long enough to have any adventure.