Thursday, 15 August 2019

"Truth Is One"

Hinduism thrives, and begins to absorb Christianity, in SM Stirling's The Peshawar Lancers (see Religious Diversity II) and should also find fertile ground among the many planetary polytheisms and alternative monotheisms of Poul Anderson's Terran Empire. The Hindu approach, as in ancient India, would be to incorporate all local cults, however diverse or apparently contradictory, as aspects of a single infinite truth. After all, we can walk on water, the source of life, when it is solid, consume it and immerse ourselves in it when it is liquid and see it above us in the sky when it is gaseous and formless. Fr Axor's quest for evidence of the Universal Incarnation resembles Hindu recognition of many avatars while his acceptance that the Foredwellers might have gone beyond sounds Buddhist.

There was recent combox discussion of Hinduism which I now cannot find. The point was made that modern Hinduism is very different from the earliest Vedic religion. Similarly, modern Judaism and Christianity are very different from the epic sources of the Pentateuch. (Apparently, one such source celebrated the Davidic monarchy as the fulfillment of God's activity on Earth.) However, the aphorism:

"Truth is one; sages call it by various names,"

- is definitely quoted from the Rig Veda. See here.

"To what is one, sages give many a title: they call it Agni, Yama, Matarisvan."
Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan and Charles A. Moore (Eds.), A Source Book In Indian Philosophy (Princeton, New Jersey, 1973), CHAPTER I, THE VEDAS, p. 21.
(The Rig Vedic reference given for this verse is I. 164. 46)

The insight that a single reality has many aspects and appears in many forms is not limited to Hinduism and resonates in the Terran Empire. See "The Divine Is With Us."

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I'm sorry, but I absolutely oppose and disagree with the kind of syncretism seen in THE PESHAWAR LANCERS, where the Anglicans of India were debating whether to accept some Hindu ideas as true. Recall, as well, how the French crown prince, then in incognito, firmly shook his head in refusal at such ideas. Which is exactly what any convinced Catholic HAS to do. The Catholic Church has a long history of determinedly refusing to conform to the world when it comes to matters of faith and principle.

Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

Of course. But you are apologizing for disagreeing again!

I should have added that, although I am a monist and an impersonalist, i.e., I believe that reality is one and not a person, "just sitting" meditation can be practiced by people of any belief: pluralists; dualists; theists etc.

A Christian woman came to the Zen monastery to learn about meditation. The monks' task was not to disagree with her beliefs but to instruct her in meditation. If appropriate, in another context, I would debate her beliefs with her but that would not have been appropriate at the monastery. So there can be some clearly defined oneness of practice.

Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Many thanks! I just didn't want to cause you any offense.

I'm not a monist or "impersonalist." I believe God to be real and a Person. And that He revealed Himself to mankind thru the Jews, in a process culminating with the Incarnation, Passion, and Resurrection of Christ. Which means no other gods exist or can exist.

I have nothing against anything in Zen which is not contrary to Christianity. But, Christianity, or at least the Catholics and Orthodox, has its own tradition of contemplative meditation. So, I'm a bit surprised this lady came to a Zen monastery to learn about meditation.

Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,
I do not know what kind of Christian she was and it doesn't matter but not all Christians are in touch with their contemplative tradition.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I agree, not all Christians are even aware of the existence of a Christian tradition of monasticism and contemplation. As represented by such works as the RULE of St. Benedict, THE CLOUD OF UNKNOWING, REVELATIONS OF DIVINE LOVE by Dame Julian, THE SPIRITUAL EXERCISES of St. Ignatius Loyola, etc.

Sean