Friday 10 March 2023

Racial Madness

Genesis, PART ONE, V.

Terra Central addresses the interface, Laurinda:

"'It appears to me that your race is mad - not you, dear, nor most people by themselves, but your race - torn between instinct and intellect, the animal and something beyond the animal. Is this a misinterpretation? If not, then most likely, without guidance, humanity will put an end to itself long before the cosmos would. I cannot as I am understanding it well enough to know, or to provide that guidance.'" (p. 55)

Use of commas is one of the ways that we differ most while writing English. If I had written the above paragraph, then there would have been another comma in line 4 and none in line 7. However, I am having trouble with the concluding sentence. Is it wrongly phrased? Should it have read:

"I cannot, as I am, understand it well enough to know or to provide that guidance."?

Terra Central is surely correct that humanity will most likely put an end to itself. Some people have written texts that others accept as divine guidance but we have no consensus on such matters. The cosmos that produced us can easily end us. Astronomers were not even sure of the existence of the nebula that the Solar System approaches. However:

"'Our interstellar outposts have the baselines to map this shoal with certainty. They have sent us their findings. In about nine thousand years, Sol will enter the region.'" (p. 48)

Thus, the post-organics begin to guide humanity toward survival and the long perspective.

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

The text you quoted does seem a bit garbled. Possible misprints in your copy of GENESIS?

Exactly! The problem being discussed here is how imperfect, flawed, and prone to strife and violence mankind is. MY preference is to leave the human race alone, to let people go where they want to go. Preferably, some would leave Earth to settle other planets, by STL generation ships if that was the only way to do it.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Note also that you're assuming that the AI's are beneficent and mean humanity well.

Why should they be?

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

And I would NOT be so confident of the benevolence of the AIs!

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Or as the saying goes, if someone comes to your house with the fixed intent of doing you good... shoot him immediately.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

Ha!!! Esp. if such a "do-gooder" comes uninvited to your house.

Ad astra! Sean