I believe neither that there is a hereafter nor that, if there were one, writers would simply continue their careers as if still alive! As CS Lewis would have said, Heaven (if it exists, of course) is experience of reality, not continued writing, or other artistic representation, about reality.
Decades ago, the travel writer, Peter Fleming, was contacted by a man whose young daughter practiced automatic writing and had purportedly produced a new James Blond novel really written by Peter's deceased brother, Ian. Peter Fleming concluded that the man and his daughter were honest and that she really did write books automatically but that this text could not possibly have been authored by his brother unless the hereafter had a very bad effect on an author's style and creativity.
If there are to be any further Technic History or James Bond novels, then they are going to have to be written by authors who are still alive but can any one writer satisfactorily reproduce the style of another?
According to Michael Ward in Planet Narnia, there are seven and only seven Chronicles of Narnia, because CS Lewis based each book on one of the seven planets of medieval astrology/astronomy. Someone might add intermediate volumes about, e.g., what Peter was doing back in Narnia while the others were in Calormen, but it would have to be someone who either shared or at least fully empathized with Lewis' distinctive brand of Platonic Christianity. Difficult.
We compare Anderson favourably with Fleming and Lewis, different though those two are from each other - to say the least! Imagine an encounter between Axor and Aslan.
5 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
I would have loved it if Anderson had 1,2, or even 3 more Technic stories. I also believe Anderson was mostly right, it was time (or almost time) to move on to other ideas/themes.
The best Andersonian pastiche I've read was Stirling's "A Slip in Time," set in the Time Patrol series. The other stories in MULTIVERSE were mostly disappointing. Stirling did say he would love trying his hand with a Flandry pastiche--in a second MULTIVERSE?
You have suggested that the Jerusalem Catholic Church is the Catholic Church after the Papacy moved to or near Jerusalem (what happened to
Rome to necessitate that?). The Christians mentioned in "Outpost of Empire"
had bishops--so the standard three degrees of the clergy still existed: bishops, priests, and deacons. With the Pope as their supreme leader.
Almost the only time Protestants seem to be alluded to were the "Christian variants of Nyanza in "The Game of Glory."
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
My idea is that Rome was nuked or as good as during the Chaos but we don't really know, of course.
Paul.
Sean: "Almost the only time Protestants seem to be alluded to were the "Christian variants of Nyanza in "The Game of Glory." "
Peter Berg in 'The Problem of Pain' seems to believe in some Protestant variant of Christianity.
Berg is from Aeneas which has Bible and blaster backwoodsmen.
Kaor, Paul and Jim!
Paul: I agree, something HAPPENED to Rome during the Chaos forcing the Papacy to abandon its ancient home.
Jim: Dang! I forgot about Peter Berg. He belonged to a "Christian variant" which had a formalized clergy who were called priests, so maybe they were Lutherans or Methodists? I also recall Peter saying his church denied non-humans could be baptized and become Christians.
Paul: A pity we're not told more about those "Bible and blaster backwoodsmen" of Aeneas.
Your blog piece also reminded me of what Paradise is like, from page 195 of OPERATION CHAOS (Doubleday: 1971): "Of course, I couldn't share his [Lobachevski's] afterlife, nor the holiness thereof. My mortal brain and grimy soul didn't reach to it. At most, there sang at the edge of perception a peace and joy which were not static but a high eternal adventure."
Ad astra! Sean
Post a Comment