Sunday, 16 June 2019

Fiction And Time

Fiction reflects life. Therefore, serious fiction reflects the passage of time. An unserious fictional series can show its hero as always in the prime of life even though years or even decades should have elapsed since the series began.

Authors who do acknowledge the passage of time can do this in completely different ways. Thus, to summarize in a single sentence, Dornford Yates, whom I am currently reading, regrets the passing of the Edwardian Age whereas Poul Anderson, whom I always reread, looks with interest towards possible futures - continuing the project of HG Wells' Victorian Time Traveler.

Readers can appreciate both perspectives although I do not share Yates' idea that life would have been better if times had not changed. (That phrase deserves to be capitalized: "...that Life would have been Better if Times had not Changed.")

In his Time Patrol series, Poul Anderson uses time travel to look not at the future but at the past and with different results. Whereas Charles Whitcomb contentedly leaves the Patrol to settle down in Victorian London, Manse Everard has learned better than to return to the Midwest of his boyhood. (Scroll down.)

Jack Finney's time travel is nostalgic whereas Wells' is futuristic. Anderson, of course, gives us both.

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I think some of the mores of the Edwardian age would be good to still have, as we see them reflected in Stirling's character Sir Nigel Loring, raised as he had been by his Edwardian grandmother.

I think we see mention of Manse Everard making occasional visits to Charles Whitcomb after "Time Patrol."

Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,
Yes, in "Delenda Est."
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I thought so! Also, it must have been very strange for Whitcomb to possibly sometimes meet or see his great grandparents and grandparents. Assuming they too lived in the London area.

I have sometimes wondered what it might be like if * I * was somehow transported sixty or seventy years back into the past. But not, I hope, permanently so!

Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Many people might find the time of their grandparents' youth more alien than more remote eras, because there would be enough similarities to make the differences stand out more.

Also, of course, we're still in reaction to/for/against our grandparents' time; but Augustus Caesar's time would just be alien.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

"The (recent) past is another country" - whereas the ancient past might be like another planet, alien indeed. Anderson captures this in "Brave To Be A King."