Poul Anderson's Merseians, like Dan Dare's Treens, are bald, green, humanoid conquerors whereas William Dexter's Vulcanids, like HG Wells' Martians and Doctor Who's Daleks, are evil, non-humanoid monsters. These five archetypes are not equally known to the public. In fact, the public thinks that "Vulcans" are not giant adaptable anemones but pointed-eared logicians inter-fertile with Terrestrials and Star Trek adds the humanoid Klingons to the list of aliens-as-threats.
In some sf, e.g., Quatermass, all aliens are threats whereas Anderson presents every kind of alien from Merseians and Chereionites to Cynthians and Wodenites - those are just four of many in one series - and CS Lewis deliberated reversed the archetype, presenting aliens as threatened.
(Couldn't sleep so got up to write this short post.)
1 comment:
Kaor, Paul!
That's a some what unusual way of thinking about C.S. Lewis' "Space Trilogy," but it made sense once I thought about it. The inhabitants of Mars and Venus in Lewis' "Trilogy" were being threatened by men from Earth.
Sean
Post a Comment