Monday 19 July 2021

Genres And The Cosmic Context

An ordinary novel shows individuals as part of human society whereas sf shows us "...as an organic part of the universe." (See the quotation from Brian Aldiss in More Mainstream-SF Interaction.) However, human society is part of the universe. It must be possible to place society in its cosmic context by linking works of different genres without compromising their distinctive genres. Thus, I have begun to read Penmarric by Susan Howatch, a 706-page family saga with five successive narrators covering the period 1890-1945. First, the arrival of an extraterrestrial spacecraft in Cornwall during that period would transform the novel into sf and, secondly, that is the very last thing that any reader wants to happen! However, the Cornish cliff mansion of Penmarric exists in a universe - or in a multiverse - where events like the arrivals of spacecraft can happen elsewhere/when.

Historical, contemporary and futuristic novels could be linked by time travel, provided that the time travelers did not declare their extratemporal status in the non-sf works. Thus, readers might recognize a Time Patrolman blending into a historical period or into contemporary society. Poul Anderson's Old Phoenix Inn is an excellent venue for meetings between characters from different kinds of works. Authors can link genres in other ways. Common characters connect Dornford Yates's social comedies, thrillers and one fantasy novel. Literature and fiction are one and can be seen as such.

4 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

If I understand you correctly, Susan Howatch could have had one of her characters in PENMARRIC casually mentioning how he sometimes met Manse Everard at a pub. With nothing being said about time traveling, just the bare, en passant, mention of Manse.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

That would be an example.

Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I thought so!

Ad astra! Sean

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Another thought I had was that I would very much like to see an ordinary novel, something written by a writer who did not write SF, to mention Poul Anderson and one of his books. Or just about any other SF author.

The late Jerry Pournelle mentioned Poul Anderson in his posthumous novel MAMELUKES. But that doesn't count because the author was also an SF writer.

Ad astra! Sean