Sunday 12 November 2023

Different Planets

How much that happens in Poul Anderson's works hangs on the physical details of different planetary environments? It is completely inadequate for an sf writer to state that the galaxy is full of Earth-like planets where his human characters, having emerged from a spaceship, can walk on grass between trees, breathe the air, eat the food without any dietary supplements etc. Look at the differences between Starkad, Ramnu, Imhotep, Daedalus, Diomedes, Aeneas, Dido, Nike and many others. Some Andersonian planets, like Hermes, Dennitza and Avalon, do come across as conventionally Earth-like but most don't. Falkayn, born on Hermes, settles on Avalon. Flandry, born on Terra, would have settled on Dennitza if...

The Terran Empire, harking back to the Roman Empire, adopts the Latin name for Earth, "Terra," whereas characters in the later stories set after the Empire use the phrase, "Old Earth" - and question whether that planet still exists. Anderson could have written another story to answer that question and how much would the Terrestrial environment have changed after all that time? I like to imagine something rural with hidden high tech. (A Larry Niven character returns to the Solar System after a sub-light-speed trip to the galactic centre and has trouble finding Earth, eventually locating it in orbit around Jupiter. Given enough time, technology might make big differences.)

1 comment:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I think it might be possible for some extra-Solar planets, if any are terrestroid, to be so like Earth that only slight modifications would be necessary. Not all that many, just some.

I fear, however, going by the postulates of Anderson's Technic stories, all that we are likely to see on Terra, during and after the Long Night, is an impoverished, depopulated world covered with ruins. Recall Flandry's anxious reflections in HUNTERS OF THE SKY CAVE about the future of Admiralty Center, expecting howling barbarians to be sacking Terra.

See as well the first paragraphs of Chapter 22 of FOUNDATION AND EMPIRE, on the Great Sack of Trantor. One of the few times Asimov wrote evocative prose!

Ad astra! Sean