Verne and Wells began writing long before it was known that there were other galaxies, let alone that galaxies recede.
In the 1960s, when Poul Anderson wrote Tau Zero, there were two main rival theories:
Big Bang, either oscillating or expanding forever;
steady state, with "continuous creation" counteracting the effect of cosmic expansion and also with the possible addition of a theory of electron-proton imbalance that would counteract gravity and thus explain the cosmic expansion.
Now the consensus is Big Bang expanding indefinitely but with the addition of much previously unanticipated data. Continuous creation of hydrogen atoms does not sound so implausible when there is continuous creation and mutual annihilation of virtual particles.
Sf paralleled and reflected twentieth century cosmology. Poul Anderson contributed continually for over half a century.
6 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
So the current consensus in cosmology is the Big Bang and an indefinitely expanding universe, along with a continuous creation of hydrogen atoms. And that in the distant future the galaxies will recede so far from each other that observers in them will no longer be able to see or detect other galaxies. Meaning each galaxy will become island universes.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
Not quite. The continuous creation of hydrogen atoms was part of the discredited steady state theory but quantum mechanics involves constant creation and annihilation of virtual particles, my point being that quantum mechanics makes that aspect of steady state theory seem not so far fetched, after all.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
That clarifies matters. I should have remembered about quantum mechanics allowing for the continuing creation/annihilation pf virtual particles.
Ad astra! Sean
Cosmology is currently in a profound crisis, with new data coming in all the time. Eg., just recently there’s been powerful evidence that the universe is “closed”, and in fact we may be in a bubble universe which interacts with other bubbles. Exciting times!
And PA got those bubble universes into THE AVATAR.
Kaor, Mr. Stirling and Paul!
Mr. Stirling: I'm seeing some of those cosmological ideas in Michaud's CONTACT WITH ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS (pub. 10 years ago).
Paul: And we see cosmological ideas in Anderson's sTARFARERS as well.
Ad astra! Sean
Post a Comment