Monday 23 December 2019

Why Aycharaych Talks To Erannath

Classic fictional scenario:

villain captures hero;
villain talks freely;
hero escapes...

Archetypal example:

Donovan Grant, chief executioner for SMERSH, has James Bond at gunpoint on the Orient Express and will shoot him in the heart when the train enters a tunnel;

Grant tells Bond where and when he, Grant, is scheduled to meet Rosa Klebb, Head of Operations for SMERSH;

during their conversation, Bond lights a cigarette and slips his cigarette case over his heart...

In Poul Anderson's The Day Of Their Return:

Aycharaych confines Erannath underground;
he talks freely;
Erannath relays information to Ivar Frederiksen who comes to rescue him...

Anderson gives Aycharaych two plausible motives for talking to Erannath:

he is lonely;
by talking, he brings associations into Erannath's conscious mind where he can read them.

Sf has a wider range of possible explanations.

2 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

And of course we see Dominic Flandry using HIS cigarette case in an interesting way in A KNIGHT OF GHOSTS AND SHADOWS.

Ad astra and Happy New Year! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

That "villain monologues his evil plan to the prisoner" is an old one -- though it really does happen, sometimes.