Regular blog readers know my philosophy. Fully to appreciate Poul Anderson, we compare or contrast him with many diverse authors, including other cosmically-themed hard sf writers. Anderson, Larry Niven and Gregory Benford have all written major sf series and have interacted in different ways. For a comment by Gregory Benford on one of my posts about his Anderson-related short story, see here. For comments on Anderson's contributions to Niven's Man-Kzin Wars subseries, see here.
Benford's and Niven's Bowl Of Heaven (TOR, New York, 2013) is like getting Niven's Ringworld back. I mean an artifact bigger than planets. Ringworld initiated a tetralogy and a co-written trilogy which, like the Man-Kzin Wars, are subseries of Niven's Known Space future history. Bowl... launches a new series. The authors think big and their alien characters build big.
On the title page of Part II, the authors quote Lord Dunsany:
"Man is a small thing, and the night is large and full of wonder." (p. 79)
I think that I can improve that:
"Man is small; night is wide and wondrous."
(Scottish English gives us "Man is wee..." but that sounds twee.)
We can also compare all these series with Star Trek:
"They left a skeleton crew aboard SunSeeker, with [Captain] Redwing plainly sorry that proper ship command protocols demanded that he stay aboard." (p. 81)
Captain Kirk, take note.
Showing posts with label Ringworld. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ringworld. Show all posts
Thursday, 19 May 2016
Friday, 25 March 2016
Overlapping Trilogies II
See here.
The Correct Reading Order?
"The Children's Hour"
"The Asteroid Queen" (FTL introduced)
"Iron"
"In The Hall Of The Mountain King" (Tyra's father referenced)
"Inconstant Star" (Tyra's father rescued)
"Pele"
My only uncertainty is whether "Iron" belongs before or after "In The Hall..." If the latter, then the reading order can be summarized as:
the Pournelle-Stirling trilogy
the Anderson trilogy
Further rereading and other readers' comments should clarify this point.
Man-Kzin Wars X: The Wunder War, a tetralogy by Hal Colebatch, is also relevant. These ten works could be re-presented in three volumes. But there are many more Man-Kzin Wars installments. Meanwhile, Ringworld has become a tetralogy and the Fleet of Worlds has become a trilogy. Known Space is vast indeed.
The Correct Reading Order?
"The Children's Hour"
"The Asteroid Queen" (FTL introduced)
"Iron"
"In The Hall Of The Mountain King" (Tyra's father referenced)
"Inconstant Star" (Tyra's father rescued)
"Pele"
My only uncertainty is whether "Iron" belongs before or after "In The Hall..." If the latter, then the reading order can be summarized as:
the Pournelle-Stirling trilogy
the Anderson trilogy
Further rereading and other readers' comments should clarify this point.
Man-Kzin Wars X: The Wunder War, a tetralogy by Hal Colebatch, is also relevant. These ten works could be re-presented in three volumes. But there are many more Man-Kzin Wars installments. Meanwhile, Ringworld has become a tetralogy and the Fleet of Worlds has become a trilogy. Known Space is vast indeed.
Sunday, 25 October 2015
Road Reflections... II
See here.
Retcons (i)
Of course, some of those "earlier" stories may be written later:
Heinlein's "Requiem" described old Harriman dying on the Moon, then his "The Man Who Sold The Moon" described how Harriman had put mankind on the Moon;
Heinlein described the heroic death of Space Patrolman John Dahlquist after he had shown the Patrol honoring this hero;
James Blish wrote a novel about the young Adolph Haertel after he had described the older Haertel conferring with the pilot who had successfully test flown the Haertel overdrive;
Anderson wrote a series of stories about Dominic Flandry, then the "Young Flandry" trilogy about the start of Flandry's career;
the story introducing Adzel as a student on Earth was written after the "later" story about Adzel joining the trader team - in fact the introductory story expands on a short dialogue in the "later" story;
and there are other examples.
Retcons (ii)
Also, a later work can present new information about earlier events. The peak of the pyramid can shine a spotlight on its base. For example, Methuselah's Children reveals that:
the Howard Families, bred for longevity, had existed secretly since the late nineteenth century;
thus, they had existed throughout the entire Future History to date;
in fact, one of their number had lived since the early twentieth century;
Andrew Libby was a Howard.
The History would have been better constructed if the reader had been able to recognize an earlier spear-carrying character as an alias of Lazarus Long.
Poul Anderson's The Game Of Empire reveals:
the existence of the Dakotian and Zacharian communities;
an old Merseian conspiracy involving Aycharaych, at last coming to fruition.
A future history is a work in progress. The author can always add and reassess. Larry Niven shows us that we really knew nothing about the Puppeteer Fleet of Worlds or the Ringworld.
Retcons (i)
Of course, some of those "earlier" stories may be written later:
Heinlein's "Requiem" described old Harriman dying on the Moon, then his "The Man Who Sold The Moon" described how Harriman had put mankind on the Moon;
Heinlein described the heroic death of Space Patrolman John Dahlquist after he had shown the Patrol honoring this hero;
James Blish wrote a novel about the young Adolph Haertel after he had described the older Haertel conferring with the pilot who had successfully test flown the Haertel overdrive;
Anderson wrote a series of stories about Dominic Flandry, then the "Young Flandry" trilogy about the start of Flandry's career;
the story introducing Adzel as a student on Earth was written after the "later" story about Adzel joining the trader team - in fact the introductory story expands on a short dialogue in the "later" story;
and there are other examples.
Retcons (ii)
Also, a later work can present new information about earlier events. The peak of the pyramid can shine a spotlight on its base. For example, Methuselah's Children reveals that:
the Howard Families, bred for longevity, had existed secretly since the late nineteenth century;
thus, they had existed throughout the entire Future History to date;
in fact, one of their number had lived since the early twentieth century;
Andrew Libby was a Howard.
The History would have been better constructed if the reader had been able to recognize an earlier spear-carrying character as an alias of Lazarus Long.
Poul Anderson's The Game Of Empire reveals:
the existence of the Dakotian and Zacharian communities;
an old Merseian conspiracy involving Aycharaych, at last coming to fruition.
A future history is a work in progress. The author can always add and reassess. Larry Niven shows us that we really knew nothing about the Puppeteer Fleet of Worlds or the Ringworld.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


