Friday, 11 April 2025

The Line Between Life And Death In Fiction

Sometimes, near the end of a volume or of a series, we think that a character is about to die but he is rescued after all. We think that Hanno will die at sea near the end of Poul Anderson's The Boat Of A Million Years but he doesn't. We think that Dominic Flandry and Chives will die in space near the end of Anderson's A Stone In Heaven but they don't. We think that Lazarus Long will die on a World War I battlefield near the end of what I regard as an inauthentic Future History sequel, Time Enough For Love by Robert Heinlein, but he doesn't.

I don't think that Anderson ever makes us think that a character really has died only to show us that he didn't? For what I regard as good examples of this maneuver in comics and films, see:

Dead, Not Really

This is "Relevant Other Reading" time of the evening. In Stieg Larsson's The Girl Who Played With Fire (London, 2009):

SPOILER ALERT, I SUPPOSE!

on p. 550, Lisbeth Salander is shot in the head and loses consciousness;

on p. 551, she is buried;

on pp. 551-556, we read about other characters and even about a fox that knows that something is buried there;

on p. 556, something else happens...

Masterful and worthy of Poul Anderson. 

Characters live on in the imagination and often also in their texts. Holmes came back from Reichenbach but you all know all that...

7 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I too tried to remember if Anderson ever attempted something like A. Conan Doyle's Reichenbach maneuver, but I can't think of any, from his stories.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

BTW, this brings up a point -- if you intend to kill someone, if it's possible at all -make sure they're dead-. Having them show up later can spoil your whole day.

This is why dead bodies from medieval battles usually have a wound taken in battle, and then a flurry of blows to the head.

That's someone making sure.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

Ha, having an enemy showing up later determined to kill you would spoil your day!

Besides what you said about making sure your enemy was dead, people in Medieval times were also keen on collecting fat ransoms from VIPs who were captured alive.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Some of Larsson's characters are killed instantaneously by a large bullet that blows a hole through their skulls. Lizbeth was shot with a very low caliber pistol. It small bullet penetrated the back of her skull, then stopped and turned sideways just inside the brain, requiring surgical extraction.

S.M. Stirling said...

Paul: yeah, that can happen.

Which is why the Mossad (which uses small-caliber pistols when doing 'hits') trains its operatives to shoot the target in the head at least 3 times. They use small-caliber bullets because they're much easier to silence.

Being found at the bottom of a stairwell with three or more small-caliber bullets in the head is a 'signature' that says 'Mossad was here'.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

It's good to know that Larsson got this part right.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul and Mr. Stirling!

Paul: And that reminded me of how Lenin's Cheka goons executed "counter-revolutionaries" with a bullet to the back of the head.

Mr. Stirling: Good for MOSSAD! I also loved how they decimated the Hezbullah criminals last year with those boobytrapped cell phones and pagers.

Ad astra! Sean