Sunday 15 September 2024

The Mule And Molitor

In Isaac Asimov's Second Foundation, Bail Channis has an audience with the First Citizen of the Union of Worlds, the Mule, who sends Channis on an expedition to locate the Second Foundation. The Mule has not "Converted," i.e., mentally modified, Channis who therefore will not be instantly recognized as a Mule's man by the mentally powerful Second Foundationers.

In Poul Anderson's A Knight Of Ghosts And Shadows, Dominic Flandry has an audience with Terran Emperor Hans Molitor who gives Flandry a roving commission to investigate possible rebellion on the Taurian Sector capital planet, Dennitza. Flandry has so far refused promotion because clandestine missions are easier for a captain than for an admiral.

Despite the superficially similar interstellar imperialist settings of these two works, Anderson's account reads more like a historical novel, albeit future, not past. The Mule is a physically unprepossessing but mentally powerful mutant, thus an sf cliche, like a Martian or a telepath, whereas Hans is a credible human character, blunt, pragmatic, uncultured, unashamed, unintelligent but shrewd, scornful of biocosmetics, with the eyes of a wild boar.

Flandry's audience is embedded in the Technic History amidst detailed descriptions of the Coral Palace. First, Flandry meets the current Duke of Mars who had inherited that title from his nephew, a peripheral character in an earlier instalment. Hans mentions Diomedes and Avalon, each the setting of an earlier novel. Flandry refers to Hans' granddaughter whom he had rescued in the previous instalment. Subsequently, Chunderban Desai, conversing with Flandry, mentions the events of two previous novels and also Flandry's recurrent adversary, Aycharaych. A solid future history series.

6 comments:

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

From Sean M. Brooks:

Kaor, Paul!

I hesitate at calling Hans Molitor "unintelligent" and also shrewd at the same time. I don't think a stupid man could have achieved as much and risen as far as he had done!

It was sheer accident Hans became a reluctant usurper--because he was already elderly when Emperor Josip died childless and his heir presumptive was unable to retain the crown. I've speculated Hans was actually preparing to retire by then.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

I was paraphrasing. The phrase used by Anderson is "...shrewd rather than intelligent..." which does have a different connotation.

Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Thanks for "resurrecting" my first comment!

I might still have argued with Anderson about that "...shrewd rather than intelligent." Because, how can you make use of shrewdness without also being intelligent?

Ad astra! Sean

Jim Baerg said...

People sometimes make a distinction between 'street smarts' and 'book smarts'. That might have been the sort of thing meant.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Jim!

That is true, and I can see Hans Molitor belonging more to the "street smarts" category.

But we do see mention in several of the stories* that Imperial Navy officers got a thorough scientific education as part of their training. As would be necessary for them in a high tech, FTL, interstellar setting.

Ad astra! Sean


*ENSIGN FLANDRY, THE REBEL WORLDS, and "A Tragedy of Errors."

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Jim,

Anderson obviously meant what you say. I expressed it badly by writing "unintelligent."

Paul.