Saturday 9 February 2019

Introducing Egalitarianism II

Poul Anderson, Shield, XIII.

See Introducing Egalitarianism.

Quarles:

Egalitarianism, like Christianity and democracy, is a label;

the contents of a bottle may change although at the same time people continue "'...to identify the label with the bottle...'" (p. 102);

(I could not possibly agree more. This might be the biggest single source of misunderstanding.)

democracy has been identified with freedom although a democratically elected government can impose controls on individuals;

democracies, unlike aristocracies or monarchies, have "blue laws" (p. 103);

(Do they?)

moral liberalism stems from declining democracy;

although legislators and principal executives are still elected, decreasing numbers of people vote;

the reasons are poverty, poor education and a realization that, "'...given the requirements of world empire...'" (ibid.), government is by bureaus controlled by a few strong and clever men;

to get anything done, it is necessary to approach not legislators but agencies that interpret and administer existing laws.

To be continued.

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I'm suspicious of the very word "egalitarianism" and movements advocating what they call "egalitarianism." My view is that any attempt to impose an impossible and leveling "equality" ends up becoming tyranny because that is the only way to force humans who are UN-equal in character, abilities, talents, etc., to even pretend to be the same as everyone else in all things. We saw truly grotesque examples of that during the misrule of Mao Tse-tung in China!

Sean

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I forgot to add, in my own "democratic" state of Massachusetts we still had some remnants of "blue laws" up to about 1970. So, yes, democracies can have blue laws.

Sean

Jim Baerg said...

When I read that I thought Paul was questioning the non-existence of blue laws in aristocracies or monarchies. I don't know whether that is the case. I do know there have been such laws in democracies.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Jim!

Many different kinds of societies and states can or will have sumptuary laws. Human vanity is immortal!

Ad astra! Sean

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Jim!

I am not sure you are right. Blue/sumptuary laws at least seem to belong to the same types of legislation.

Ad astra! Sean