Monday 16 September 2019

Quarrel

she had left home after a spectacular quarrel with her parents. That was soon repaired—it had only been a declaration of independence—but she had kept her own job and her own apartment since then.
-copied from 4, here.

I am not really commenting on the novel, just reflecting on particular passages. I have been a son, of course, and then a parent. Based on that experience, I suggest that any permanent rift between a mother and father and their son or daughter is entirely the responsibility of the parents. (I avoid the word "fault," precisely because it played such a big part in my upbringing.) The parents have been children and adolescents and should remember what it was like and understand that their offspring will get through it. If my daughter had been brought up by people with the attitudes of the generation before mine, then she would have irretrievably quarreled with them long ago. According to a scripture that we recite in our meditation group, "...the Buddha had great wisdom at birth..." Why can all of us not have that? Because the universe was not designed for our convenience. 

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

But I don't think it is always the case that the fault/responsibility for why some children and their parents are permanently estranged lies mainly with the latter. There are times when children can behave so badly and foolishly that the responsibility for any such estrangement lies with them.

Btw, I wish we knew more about Dominic Flandry's parents and family! We get only a few hints in ENSIGN FLANDRY, such as them being conscientious about raising him.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,
We do not even know whether they are still alive.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Meaning Flandry's parents? That is true, we never see any further mention of them after ENSIGN FLANDRY. It's one of those mysteries and lacunae in the works of Anderson or Tolkien that fanboys like us obsessively geek over! (Smiles)

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

We're not designed to be happy and wise; we're "designed" by evolution to have (on average) the maximum possible chance of producing surviving offspring... in the environment we evolved in, which may be and these days usually is, something else entirely.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

I like the fact that evolution loses interest in us as soon as we are old enough to procreate - whether we do or not. We have all these years and hopefully decades in which to do our own thing which can be celibacy, promiscuity, just earning a living, creative activities etc.