Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Pete Pinto. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Pete Pinto. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, 28 February 2013

Judgement And Doomsday II

Having compared titles, let us also compare opening sentences.

"The fall of God put Theron Ware in a peculiarly unenviable position, though he was hardly alone." (James Blish, Black Easter and The Day After Judgement, London, 1981, p. 119)

" 'Earth is dead. They murdered our Earth!' " (Poul Anderson, After Doomsday, Frogmore, St Albans, Herts, 1975, p. 7)

The Day After Judgement is a sequel so it can begin with a casual reference to the death of God which had been announced by a demon at the end of Black Easter. The real existence of supernatural beings, God, angels and demons, makes these works fantasies.

After Doomsday is a single novel with a dramatic opening sentence. If "...our Earth..." is dead, then how can one of its inhabitants know this? He is in a spaceship that has just returned from outside the Solar System so this is a work of science fiction (sf).

A friend who borrowed my copy of After Doomsday thought it was bad but I cannot help agreeing with James Blish and the Lancaster sf bookseller Pete Pinto both of whom said effectively that something about it makes it a complete novel. Pete used the phrase "complete novel" and Jim Blish said much the same. I will elaborate in later posts. Like two other Anderson novels, Tau Zero and World Without Stars, After Doomsday starts with a very basic sf premise and derives what reads like a comprehensive set of consequences from that premise. Like many of Anderson's works, it could have initiated a series. I will shortly reread After Doomsday and comment further.

Sunday, 29 October 2023

Unanswered Questions

A Technic History instalment could be written to show that much that we thought we knew was false.

Flandry:

"In those days [Aycharych] had claimed that the enigmatic ruins found upon many worlds of that sort were relics of his own people, who ranged and ruled among the stars in an era geologically remote. He claimed.... He's as big a liar as I am, when either of us wants to be. If they did build and then withdraw, why? Where to? What are they upon this night?"
-Poul Anderson, A Knight of Ghosts and Shadows IN Anderson, Sir Dominic Flandry: The Last Knight of Terra (Riverdale, NY, March 2012), pp. 339-606 AT IX, p. 462.

Tachwyr:

"But Aycharaych died when the Dennitzans bombarded his planet. At least, he vanished, you could never be altogether sure of anything about the Chereionite."
-Poul Anderson, The Game of Empire IN Flandry's Legacy (Riverdale, NY, June 2012), pp. 189-453 AT CHAPTER SIX, p. 267.

Is Flandry's question: where are the Chereionites? answered at the end of A Knight... when he finds that Chereion is occupied only by computers, holograms and Aycharaych himself? Is the rest of the race extinct? That answer serves in the absence of any information to the contrary. But such information could have been provided. And the same observation applies to Aycharaych's own disappearance. As the British sf bookseller, Pete Pinto, suggested to Anderson: Aycharaych should return but in an Aycharaych novel, not in a Flandry novel.

Sunday, 12 March 2017

After Twilight

Pete Pinto once remarked that, if the Commonalty came out of the Long Night, then the people of the Commonalty would not call that post-Imperial period "the Long Night." But we do look back at a period that we call "the Dark Ages."

The theme of this post is how bad periods are perceived in retrospect. We will quote James Blish, Poul Anderson and SM Stirling.

"'If an Englishman of around 1600 had found out about the American Revolution, he probably would have thought it a tragedy; an Englishman of 1950 would have had a very different view of it. We're in the same spot. The messages we get from the really far future have no contexts yet.'"
-James Blish, The Quincunx Of Time (New York, 1983), Epilogue, pp. 109-110.

"'The trend of events must ever seem toward the best, since it is toward the one observing the trend.'"
-Poul Anderson, Twilight World (London, 1983), Epilogue, p. 179.

"'I'd undo the Change if I could, of course, but otherwise...I like this better. It's more the way human beings were meant to live.'"
-SM Stirling, The Protector's War (New York, 2006), Chapter Thirteen, p. 348.

They are not all saying the same thing but they are all reflecting on time and change.

Tempora mutantur nos et mutamur in illis. (Times change and we change with them.)

Monday, 3 November 2025

Names From Long Ago

In my teens, the sf authors that mattered most to me were:

Heinlein
Asimov
Blish
Simak

I knew of Anderson but did not yet rate him as highly as I do now and have done for a long time. It took quite a while for me to realize that Anderson's Technic History was more than just his van Rijn series and his Flandry series strung together. The Lancaster sf bookseller, Pete Pinto, rightly said that Anderson was "the most under-rated sf writer." Someone else said that he was a thud and blunder man with literary pretensions but I think that it is the other way around. He was a literary writer who still liked his action scenes even when he had stopped writing for pulp magazines.

There are other names that I remember from back then but know little or nothing about but can now google, e.g.:



Patrick Moore (better known as an astronomer and TV personality)

Today = funeral this morning + meeting this evening + heavy rain.

So it goes.

Monday, 29 June 2026

Aycharaych Before Or After

Years ago, second-hand bookseller Pete Pinto suggested to Poul Anderson that Dominic Flandry's main adversary, the universal telepath and last surviving Chereionite, Aycharaych, should return but in an Aycharaych novel, not in a Flandry novel. I agreed. Such a novel could have been about Aycharaych's earlier life and, in that case, would not have needed to tell us whether he had survived the Flandry-ordered bombardment of Chereion. But suppose he did survive. What would have happened then? Although he would no longer be motivated to work for Merseia, I accept the combox argument that the bombardment of his home planet would have demotivated him from offering his services instead to Merseia's enemy, the Terran Empire.

Aycharaych's subsequent life would have had to involve some reflection on his earlier career and on the history of Chereion. I still think that a meeting with that student of Ancient artefacts, Axor, would be one possibility although not through the agency of Terran Intelligence.

I cannot imagine sequels. My brain conjures only absurdities, e.g., Aycharaych fleeing outside known space and finding Nicholas van Rijn in suspended animation, which Anderson definitely would not have written. Poul Anderson combined creative imagination with historical plausibility. Although he never showed us the death of any major character, it is a given that such characters are long dead in later periods when others come forward:

van Rijn and Falkayn
Argos
Christopher Holm and Philippe Rochefort
Flandry and Aycharaych
Roan Tom
Daven Laure

(Not a complete list.)

I have stopped writing about Aycharaych because inspiration has dried up.

Wednesday, 10 June 2026

Perspectives

Homer, expressing the Greek perspective, describes Odysseus as crafty and wise whereas Virgil, expressing the antagonistic Trojan perspective, describes Ulysses (the same character) as cruel and deceitful.

In Poul Anderson's Technic History, the Fall of the Terran Empire is followed by a period of chaos called the Long Night. Pete Pinto, the second-hand bookseller, made the point that later civilizations which had grown out of that period would not refer to it as "the Long Night."

Poul Anderson imagines an sf writer in Augustan Rome who considered three possible futures:

the Empire will conquer the whole world;

in accordance with Augustan policy, the Imperial borders will remain unchanged;

the Empire will fall as barbarians move in, leaving - 

"...nothing...but ruins and wilderness."
-Poul Anderson "The Discovery of the Past" IN Anderson, Past Times (New York, 1984), pp. 182-206 AT p. 190.

Instead, Anderson tells us that:

"A heretical offshoot of the religion of a subjugated people, afar in a corner of the Mediterranean ambit, took over Romans and barbarians alike, completely transforming them and breeding new, utterly different civilizations." (ibid.)

Augustus himself, in a fictional account, tells Lycius the dwarf that the prophetic volumes foretold that either the Romans would:

"...last a few hundred years and then [be] gone - - eaten from outside by barbarians, from inside by strange gods."
-Neil Gaiman, August IN Gaiman, Fables And Reflections (New York, 1993), pp. 98-122 AT p. 113, panel 5 -

- or that they would conquer the whole world.

And here is my point about perspectives: what Anderson describes as transformation by a foreign heresy, Augustus describes as being eaten by strange gods!

Sunday, 6 August 2017

Series Villains

We have discussed series villains before. An iconic image in twentieth century cinema is the cat-stroking James Bond villain whose face is not seen and whose name is not uttered until Bond comes face to face with him in the fifth film. We commend CS Lewis and SM Stirling for creating truly evil and literally diabolical villains.

Either a series villain returns like a recurring decimal or, more interestingly, the author progressively reveals more about him until at last we are given his "origin story." Aspects of the second process can be seen in Poul Anderson's Dominic Flandry and Time Patrol series and in Ian Fleming's James Bond series.

Flandry
(i) Aycharaych, a Chereionite and universal telepath, is the spearhead of Merseian Intelligence.
(ii) A prequel reveals that the Chereionites were the Ancients whose interstellar civilization ended ages ago.
(iii) Flandry, learning that Aycharaych is the last Chereionite and has served Merseia only to preserve the Chereionite heritage, bombards Chereion, probably killing Aycharaych.
(iv) A long term plan of Aycharaych's comes to fruition and nearly succeeds. Tachwyr wonders whether Aycharaych will return.
(v) Pete Pinto suggested to Anderson that Aycharaych should return but in an Aycharaych novel, not in a Flandry novel. However, Anderson went on to write a different series and also more seriously speculative fiction.

Tuesday, 3 October 2023

Three Aliens

The Day Of Their Return.

Although Aeneas is a human-colonized planet, three xenosophonts appear in The Day Of Their Return: a Merseian, a Chereionite and an Ythrian. If we are reading Poul Anderson's Technic History in chronological order of fictitious events, then we have encountered Ythrians and Merseians before. If we are reading the History in its original order of publication, then we have encountered the Chereionite, Aycharaych, in the Captain Flandry series. 

The three extra-solar species in question are different from humanity and also from each other. The fact that all three of them are developed in so many instalments greatly enriches this future history series. It is good to be reminded what the Ythrians and the Merseians are like and also to see Aycharaych before his first encounter with Flandry. As the sf bookseller, Pete Pinto, told Anderson, Aycharaych deserved to return after A Knight of Ghosts and Shadows but preferably in an Aycharaych novel, not in another Flandry novel. Even if Aycharaych died on Chereion, his entire earlier life and career could have been a spin-off series. In the Platonic Ideal realm, the Technic History is endless.

Monday, 14 March 2022

Little Masterpieces By Wells, Lewis, Blish And Anderson

"'THE TIME MACHINE...THAT LITTLE MASTERPIECE' J. B. Priestly
-quoted on the back cover of HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973).
 
I agree and apply the same description to CS Lewis' The Great Divorce. These two works address Time and Eternity respectively and raise the same philosophical problem because they treat consciousness as detachable from bodies.
 
To qualify as a little masterpiece, a novel must first be short. Poul Anderson's The Avatar, The Boat Of A Million Years and The Shield Of Time are masterpieces but not short. Secondly, the novel must present a sense of completeness. When I first read James Blish's "Beep," I thought that it should be novelized and it was as The Quincunx Of Time. It also addresses Time and presents consciousness as detachable.

Candidate "Little Masterpieces" By Poul Anderson
There Will Be Time
Tau Zero
Genesis
World Without Stars
After Doomsday
 
Pete Pinto, the former Lancaster sf bookseller, said that there was something about After Doomsday that made it a complete novel. James Blish said that Lewis' That Hideous Strength contained every kind of character and was a complete novel but it is not short. Lewis' The Great Divorce, Anderson's Operation Chaos and SM Stirling's Emberverse series present some feeling of what a Heavenly realm might be like.

Tuesday, 16 September 2014

All The Details

(The failing laptop still works if it is plugged in and in the same room as the router. Ad astra per aspera!)

I really do think that this dwelling on the details is the only way to do full justice to Poul Anderson's texts. The History of Technic Civilization exists on at least two levels. An sf fan might read some of its installments quickly, not in their proper order, enjoy the action-adventure fiction, then move on to something else, probably missing or soon forgetting all the ingenious background details. Every planetary environment has been imaginatively built from its molecules upwards. The more it is studied, the more can be found in it.

The Lancaster sf seller, Pete Pinto, once described Anderson as "the most under-rated serious sf writer." This is tragically true. Anderson's fiction combines bright surface with deep substance. How many see the surface but do not discern the substance? - a word that has been over-used on this blog, but I try to convey the substance by quoting and summarizing complicated plots and background information.

Meanwhile, in our pensioners' Latin class, we are reading about Boudica, St Paul at Ephesus and Orpheus: Tacitus, the Vulgate and Virgil. All worthwhile and all relevant to Anderson.  

Friday, 20 April 2012

The Long Night

Poul Anderson over-uses the term "Long Night" which refers to the immediate post-Imperial period in his Technic History. The Imperialist Flandry continually anticipates the Long Night with apprehension. Four millennia later, Daven Laure says:

"Sir, the League, the troubles, the Empire, its fall, the Long Night...every such thing - behind us. In space and time alike. The people of the Commonalty don't get into wars." (1)

The Lancaster sf book seller, Pete Pinto, commented that, if the Commonalty has arisen from the "Long Night," then Commonalters should not call it that. Of course, the author is mainly signalling to the reader through a character that the latter exists in the same timeline as van Rijn and Falkayn of the Polesotechnic League and Flandry of the Terran Empire. Laure can hardly be speaking League Latin or Imperial Anglic so we might regard the phrase "Long Night" in his dialogue as translating whatever phrase he does use into terms familiar to us. 

Anderson made this point in relation to his earlier future history:

"...a story laid some centuries hence must be thought of as a translation, not merely of language but of personalities and concepts corresponding only approximately to anything we know." (2)

The League and its successor the Empire occupied only a small part of one spiral arm of the galaxy whereas, by 7100, the Commonalty operates in one of several divergent human civilizations thinly occupying two or three spiral arms. There is mention of human diversity but not of any interaction with other rational species. This implicitly contradicts the earlier series but only implicitly. Anderson could have extended the series even further by recounting what the Long Night had done to Merseians, Ythrians, Cynthians, Wodenites etc. However, he regarded the History as already having made its point about the periodic, though not inevitable, rise and fall of civilizations so why belabor the point?
 
"Better to seek new themes." (3)

...which he did in future histories about human-AI interaction and post-human AI without ET's or FTL (i. e., without extra-terrestrials or faster than light interstellar travel): a different though less implausible scenario. 

If "the Long Night" means not just "later than the Empire" but, more specifically, the period of chaos and barbarism immediately following and resulting from the Fall of the Empire, then "Starfog," about the Commonalty, is set well after the Long Night. Only three works are set between the last Empire novel, The Game of Empire, and "Starfog." The first of these, "A Tragedy of Errors," is definitely set during the Long Night. It begins:

"Later ages wove a myth about Roan Tom. He became their archetype of those star rovers who fared forth while the Long Night prevailed." (4)

Again, the phrase is used to clarify not only which series this story belongs to but also which period of the series it is set in. 
 
"A Tragedy of Errors" is deceptively simple, on the surface a conventional action-adventure story but with informed scientific speculation throughout. The planet Nike has been colonized not only by human beings but also by "...the more efficient, highly developed species that man commonly brought with him...": oak; birch; primroses; grass overwhelming "...a pseudo-moss that apparently had a competitive advantage only in shade..." although, in one place, the dense vegetation is "...principally native Nikean, dominated by primitive but tree-sized 'ferns.'" (4) (5)

This theme continues in the next short story, "The Sharing of Flesh," set, according to Sandra Miesel, four centuries later. On another planet, a plant descended from clover is "...scattered low among the reddish native pseudo-grasses." (6) The view point character, Evalyth, remembers that:

"Clover was another of those life forms that man had brought with him from Old Earth, to more planets than anyone now remembered, before the Long Night fell." (6)

Evalyth's home world Kraken has altered pines, gulls and rhizobacteria but Krakeners had forgotten that these organisms came from Earth with their ancestors.

Returning to "A Tragedy of Errors," Tom and his wives, even while fleeing from their (temporary) enemies, speculate about the scientific oddities of Nike and its sun and have found answers by the end of the story. Despite its small size, Nike has a breathable atmosphere and a biosphere because it is old enough for its weak gravitational field to have had enough time to pull the heavier elements into the kind of solid core that generates atmosphere-producing planetary forces. It follows that Nike's sun is also old. This explains its variability and enables Tom to import solar meteorologists who will predict the weather on a planet where harsh and previously unpredictable storms were catastrophic. But first he must learn that, in the local lingo, he needs to " 'change " with "camarados," not to "do business" with "friends."

The main point of the story is that words change their meanings over time. An opening and closing quotation clarifies that "awful" once meant "awesome" etc. In the story, space raiders attacking the isolated Nike had ironically introduced themselves as "friends" coming to do "business." A decade later, a refugee seeking help and using those same words is in trouble, especially when he refuses to "slave" himself, i. e., to accept precautionary arrest. This is the main communication problem but there are other examples of linguistic shift. When a scientifically based society degenerates into a feudalism, then "Engineer" becomes the title of a feudal lord. Twice in the Technic History, in the League and Empire periods, a "rogue planet," meaning a loose or sunless planet, had played a pivotal role in history. Tom would call that a "bandit planet" because to him "rogue planet" means a planet, like Nike, with an unusual orbit or composition. A character who has studied the classics knows some science because, in the Long Night, scientific knowledge is a classical art!

"A Tragedy of Errors" is one of at least three proto-series in the Technic History, i.e., Roan Tom could have become a series character. The two other potential series characters are Diana Crowfeather and Daven Laure. By contrast, "Margin of Profit," introducing van Rijn, and "Tiger by the Tail," introducing Flandry, would have been proto-series if they had not had sequels. We are told that, during Tom's life-time, his "...name was already in the ballads of a dozen planets." (7) 

He even introduces the story from an imaginary Valhalla where Earth grown tobacco is available but this is only a narrative device. Anderson stops short of introducing the fantasy of a literal Valhalla into the hard sf of the Technic History. One Empire novel refers to Manuel Argos "...in whatever hypothetical hell or Valhalla the Founder dwelt." (8) Fittingly, the Valhalla references link Manuel, slave and Emperor, to Tom, trader and warlord. Manuel responds to the Troubles by leading a slave revolt and founding the Terran Empire. Tom copes with the Long Night by trading when possible and fighting when necessary. He shares van Rijn's ability to identify common interests and to arrange mutually advantageous exchanges that can transform potential enemies into trading partners and allies.

  I would not have remembered the details about Nike, and thus would not have fully appreciated Anderson's work, if I had not set out to re-read and summarize the details.

The remaining three post-Imperial works deal with more fundamental changes than linguistic alterations. "The Sharing of Flesh" occurs when the Allied Planets are restoring interstellar civilization, thus at the beginning of the end of the Long Night. A mutation in a small and impoverished population which for one or two generations had practiced cannibalism for survival entails that boys can reach puberty only by gaining the extra hormones provided by cannibalism. Thus, cannibalism continues until the Allied Planets provide hormone pills, then Terrestrial-type meat animals.

In "Starfog," the Kirkasanter population that has been isolated for millennia has an instinctual compulsion to have children but cannot interbreed with the people of the Commonalty. Thus, Laure cannot after all marry a Kirkasanter woman whom he has met. The single post-Empire novel, The Night Face, is set before "The Sharing of Flesh." Organizations from two civilized planets join forces to explore Gwydion which has been isolated throughout the entire Imperial period. The Gwydiona are unusually peaceful and harmonious without any legal coercion or government control but something mysterious, a transcendent experience that they cannot describe, occurs once a year. It turns out that everyone becomes insane for a few days. They can harm themselves or each other but instantly forget that it is they themselves that have done it. They have unconsciously developed ways to minimize the harm. For example, when everyone is insane, ritual chanting and dancing channels the energy that would otherwise be expressed as homicidal violence. But the ritual is disrupted by the presence of extra-planetary visitors who do not understand what is happening... (9) I think there was a Star Trek episode like this but, of course, Anderson does it better.

What can we say about the post-Imperial period of the Technic History? It comprises four works. Each work describes an encounter with an isolated human community, not with a new non-human species. In each work, something important has changed: language; biology; psychology; again biology. The first biological change is reversible. The second is not. The works present four stages of development from the barbarism of Roan Tom in a small part of the former Imperial volume of space to the support services of the Commonalty stretching across a spiral arm.

Would the Technic History be better balanced and more satisfactory if there were less of Flandry and more of the Long Night? In my opinion, the series would be better if there were more of Flandry and more of the Long Night. It is long but seems too short.

(1) Anderson, Poul, "Starfog," Analog, 1967, IN Anderson, The Long Night, New York, May 1983, pp. 240-310 at p. 251.
(2) Anderson, P, Virgin Planet, London, April 1966, 151.
(3) Anderson, P, "Concerning Future Histories," Bulletin of the Science Fiction Writers of America, Volume 14, No 3, Whole No 71, Fall 1979, pp. 7-14 at p. 13.
(4) Anderson, P, "A Tragedy of Errors," Galaxy, 1967, IN The Long Night, pp. 133-201 at p. 155.
(5) Anderson, P, ibid, p. 177.
(6) Anderson, P, "The Sharing of Flesh," Galaxy, 1968, IN The Long Night, pp. 203-240 at p. 205.
(7) Anderson, P, "A Tragedy of Errors," p. 139.
(8) Anderson, P, A Knight of Ghosts and Shadows, London, 1978, p. 39.
(9) Anderson, P, The Night Face, London, 1972, pp. 113-124.