Monday, 2 November 2026

On Joril

 

The Quest For The Perfect Planet by WE Johns was a juvenile sf novel about an attempt to find an extrasolar planet with an environment that would be perfect for human beings to colonize. Surely impossible?

In Poul Anderson's "Turning Point," a survey ship from Earth finds the planet Joril:

"...with more water than Earth, it offered a mild climate everywhere. The biochemistry was so like our own that we could eat native foods, and there didn't seem to be any germs that UX=2 couldn't handle. Seas, forests, meadows made us feel right at home..." (p. 268)

UX=2?

Eat native foods? Surely impossible when those foods are end products of an entirely separate evolution? Anderson usually writes about incomers at least needing dietary supplements.

A five-man gravboat team comprises:

Jacques Lejeune, pilot;

the first person narrator, unnamed as yet, engineer;

Commander Ernest Baldinger of the Solar Peace Authority Space Force, Federal militechnic representative;

Walter Vaughan, Federal civil government representative;

Don Haraszthy, Trader agent -

- all skilled planetographers like our Adzel on whom be peace in his alternative timeline.

That gives us some idea of the political setup and is as much as I am going to write over toast and coffee this morning before going out to gym. Zen group this evening and Andrea above the Old Pier Bookshop tomoz.

Ad astra.

Addendum: The following page names the narrator as Cathcart.

2 comments:

Jim Baerg said...

"with more water than Earth, it offered a mild climate everywhere."

I think the distribution of the water is at least as important.
When earth's continents were jammed together in Pangea that resulted in *extensive* desert regions. Europe-Asia-Africa so close together results in extensive deserts too.
Even a modest size continent can be mostly desert with a modest mountain range on the upwind side rain-shadowing most of the interior. See Australia.
Put a continent at one pole and it is quite likely to be most covered by an ice sheet. Antarctica.

See this for an exercise in worldbuilding where those factors make much of the land rather unpleasant because accidents of geography result in a pair of Antarcticas and a bunch of Australias.
http://www.worlddreambank.org/K/KAK.HTM

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I have to agree with your doubts and Jim's comments. Even a very terrestroid planets is more likely than not for human colonists to need some dietary supplements from Earth (crops and meat animals) to complement what was found on the new planet.

And the planet Hermes, as described in MIRKHEIM and A STONE IN HEAVEN, fits Jim's description of what happens when multiple continents are jammed together.

Ad astra! Sean