Friday 25 January 2019

What A Contrast

I refer to two works by Poul Anderson: whereas "How To Be Ethnic In One Easy Lesson" is both a juvenile short story and an installment of Anderson's History of Technic Civilization in which aliens come to a thriving Earth to learn, After Doomsday is a one-off adult novel in which the few human survivors of the sterilized Earth go out into the galaxy and teach so we detect a common theme here.

We value "How To Be Ethnic..." for its snapshot of daily life on Earth in the Solar Commonwealth and After Doomsday for its unique background of the multi-species civilization-clusters. We wish that both works had been longer than they are but also find that they can be revisited and re-mined for yet more colorful and imaginative details.

Imagine a Technic History including multiple volumes of short stories presenting daily life in the future, like the first part of Heinlein's Future History, and also a series of novels set in the civilization-clusters scenario of After Doomsday

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I dunno, while I have some sympathy for your wish to see more stories showing us daily life in either the Technic series or AFTER DOOMSDAY, I have my doubts many readers would find them interesting. I mean science fictional stories showing us ONLY how people lived their every day lives and what they did would seem rather dull. Finding out the details of how people got up from bed, what they wore, had for breakfast, what kinds of jobs or occupations they had, fretting about bills or traffic congestion, and so on wont, I believe, interest that many readers. What makes many stories, science fiction or not, INTERESTING is when the characters have to cope with problems and conflicts NOT part of their everyday lives.

Not that I object to some mention of how characters lived the every day details of their lives sometimes. We get some glimpses of how Dominic Flandry lived when he was at home in Archopolis in A STONE IN HEAVEN. But stories ONLY about ordinary, everyday life won't appeal that much to many readers.

Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,
Personal dramas like those in THE GREEN HILLS OF EARTH or "How To Be Ethnic..." would suffice.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

That I can agree with!

Sean