Saturday 9 January 2016

Rise And Fall

To recapitulate from several earlier posts:

Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History is a future history series of twenty installments;

eleven installments are set during the period of slower than light (STL) space travel whereas the remaining nine are set during the later period of faster than light (FTL) space travel;

the entire History could be collected in two omnibus volumes corresponding to these periods;

the STL period subdivides into four episodes set during the period while the UN is becoming a world government and seven works set within the Solar Union, an alliance between the governments of the Earth-Luna system and the Martian and Venusian colonies;

the FTL period has two stories set during a period of early interstellar exploration and colonization, six (of which most of us have read only four) set in the Stellar Union and one set in a much later Galactic civilization;

no installments are set either during the Second Dark Ages, which separate the Solar Union from the early interstellar period, or during the Third Dark Ages, which separate the Stellar Union from at least two interstellar Empires, then the Galactic civilization;

(this contrasts with the later History of Technic Civilization which has one pivotal story during the Time of Troubles separating the Solar Commonwealth from the Terran Empire and one set during the Long Night separating the Terran Empire from the Allied Planets and later civilizations);

the STL period begins with Europe recovering from World War III and ends with Earth, although not the entire Solar System, sliding into the Second Dark Ages;

the important figure of Fourre, who had fought in World War II, appears in the opening two stories of the History and is invoked in "Brake," the concluding story of the Solar Union period;

Fourre's man, Stefan Rostomily, appears in the opening story but dies before the second;

however, Rostomily's clones continue to work for Fourre and a later clone even appears in "Brake";

the even more important figure of Valti remains off-stage although he initiates the science of psychotechnics which is still practiced in the later Galactic civilization;

in the STL period, there is a rise to an almost utopian economy but then a fall to the Second Dark Ages;

in the FTL period, there is a rise to the Stellar Union, a fall to the Third Dark Ages and interstellar imperialism, then a rise to the vast and powerful Galactic civilization.

8 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Very interesting, except I would argue that the "Galactic civilization" story, "The Chapter Ends," does not truly belong in the Psychotechnic series. That seems to have been Sandra Miesel's opinion, which was not necessarily that of PA. Any full collecting of the Psychotechnic series should have a note prefacing "Chapter" saying not all readers and commentators agree it belongs there.

Sean

Paul Shackley said...

Sean,
Somewhere among my posts while you were in Hawaii, I did come to accept that "The Chapter Ends" belongs in this future history. The Third Dark Ages led to the First Empire. Order was restored by force, not by science. However, Nomads, some led by former Coordinators and their descendants, preserved a seed of knowledge. The Galactic civilization has psychotechnicians and Integrators.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Yes, but "The Chapter Ends" is so different from the undisputed Psychotechnic stories that I simply don't agree it belongs with them. In some ways "Chapter" seems so "primitive" and in other ways it postulates such drastic advances in human abilities not hinted of in the Psychotechnic series that I still can't agree it belongs there.

Sean

Paul Shackley said...

Sean,
After the Stellar Union, there are the Third Dark Ages and
the First Empire. "The Chapter Ends" is set 50,000 years after the First Empire. The primitiveness is due to dark ages and imperialism but, since then, there has been enough time for human advances that could have built on psychotechnics.
Paul.

Paul Shackley said...

Sean,
I think that the interstitial passages could be rewritten to draw the connections better.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor ,Paul!

Thanks for both of your new comments. Let me clear up what I meant by "primitiveness." I was trying to say that "Chapter" is a very early story by PA first pub. in 1954 and written in ways and with ideas that doesn't truly FIT IN with the undisputed Psychotechnic stories. Which is why I don't think it belongs with that future history.

I think the interstitial comments could be rewritten as you suggested. AND that it should include a note that not all readers agree "Chapter" belongs with the Psychotechnic stories.

Now, if among the papers of PA something is found saying he agrees "Chapter" belongs with the Psychotechnic series, that would settle the matter for me!

Sean

Paul Shackley said...

Sean,
I realized on reflection what you meant by "primitiveness." But could the same term not apply to some other Psychotechnic stories? I thought that some of my posts of last month presented a strong case for including "The Chapter Ends." I might return to this theme.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Yes, I agree, some of the other Psychotechnic stories are "primitive" when compared to the more skillfully written works of PA in his middle and late phases. Your detailed analysis of "Brake" makes me include that story in the "primitive" category.

I used to think "The Big Rain" was not one of Poul Anderson's better early stories. However, later rereadings made me take a kinder view of the story, while still considering it a bit "primitive."

It seems whether or not "The Chapter Ends" belongs with the Psychotechnic stories will be perennially debated by SF and Poul Anderson critics! (Smiles)

Sean