Naysmith reflects on Donner:
"...his brain darkened, withdrawn into the great night..." (IV, p. 35)
An accurate description of death. In Donner's brain, neurons have stopped firing electrically and interacting electrochemically in ways that generate consciousness, including the perception of light. We experience night when we are awake after sunset but "the great night" refers to a time when we are in a deep, dreamless sleep.
The Un-Men tend to quote Shakespeare:
"In that sleep of death, what dreams may come..."
But how can dreams come when neurons have stopped firing?
"We are such stuff as dreams are made on, and our little life is rounded with a sleep."
9 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
Except, of course, I also believe in the survival of the spirit or soul after bodily death.
Happy New Year! Sean
Sean,
Yes but, as ever, merely stating the belief is not enough to persuade anyone else to accept it.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
And merely stating disbelief in that idea is also not enough to convince others to accept it.
Happy New Year! Sean
Sean,
But I know that. That's not an answer. We need a reason to believe a proposition. We do not need a reason not to believe a proposition.
Someone says, "I believe in reincarnation/alien visitors to Earth/a Catholic conspiracy/fill in the blank. Why do you not believe in it?" Because I do not see any reason to believe in it.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
I have tried suggesting positive reasons for not believing as you do. Since you disbelieve in those reasons, an impasse was reached, nothing could be said. I see no reason to believe as you do.
Happy New Year! Sean
Sean,
When positive reasons for a belief are proposed, they can be and I trust have been discussed. But don't fall back on "I can't prove it but you can't disprove it!" We are not obliged to disprove anything. Neither you nor I is obliged to disprove reincarnation to any of the people who all too readily accept that.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
Granted. But I think there is more evidence in favor of the supernatural being real than many who more or less think as you do are willing to admit.
Happy New Year! Sean
Sean,
But there are religious believers who simply blank out and do not consider contrary arguments. This criticism of the motives of people on the other side again gets us nowhere.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
Granted.
Happy New Year! Sean
Post a Comment