In some works of speculative fiction, a representative of a future society explains that society to a time traveler or to a returned relativistic space traveler. In Poul Anderson's "Quixote and the Windmill," two drunks explain their society to each other. Their social positions differ so their perspectives are complementary:
"'Machines do all the routine work, all of it, they produce so much that the basic necessities of life are free.'
"'The hell. They want money for everything.'
"'Not much. And you get your citizen's allowance, which is just a convenient way of making your needs free.'"
-Poul Anderson, Cold Victory (New York, 1982), pp. 20-21.
So what is the role of money? The machines are not paid a wage or salary. However, human servotechnicians and their managers are. So who pays them? In an earlier post, I listed the human beings who still work:
highly skilled and trained engineers and technicians;
scientific geniuses;
painters;
writers;
musicians;
spacemen;
tavern keepers.
Several of these groups might be self-employed? The Solar Union government might easily employ the rest. So no longer any private employers?
Brady was bored as a servotechnician but is not bright enough to be employed as a mathematician although he has studied that subject as hard as possible. But why should he be employed in order to continue the study and application of mathematics? To satisfy the needs, not just the physical needs, of its citizens, the Union should allocate resources to enable people like Brady to engage with their preferred areas of study as long as they live. If artificial intelligences are doing "'...independent research...[a]t a higher level than the human brain can operate...'" (p. 23), then human beings can spend life-times stretching their own abilities and discussing the AI's discoveries.
Showing posts with label Cold Victory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cold Victory. Show all posts
Tuesday, 5 January 2016
Wednesday, 16 December 2015
The Psychotechnic History II
See The Psychotechnic History. In Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History, clones (not yet called that) are grown exogenetically, not in a host mother.
On reflection, this History should definitely be collected in two omnibus volumes:
Vol I, THE SOLAR UNION - the entire contents of The Psychotechnic League and Cold Victory plus The Snows Of Ganymede;
Vol II, THE STELLAR UNION - the entire contents of Starship plus "The Acolytes," "The Green Thumb," the longer version of "Virgin Planet" and The Peregrine but maybe minus "The Chapter Ends."
For comparison, the first three omnibus volumes of the Technic History should be:
RISE OF THE POLESOTECHNIC LEAGUE;
DECLINE OF THE POLESOTECHNIC LEAGUE;
RISE OF THE TERRAN EMPIRE -
- and we know that the political framework of the League is the Solar Commonwealth. Thus, in Anderson's first future history, the Solar Union is succeeded by the Stellar Union whereas, in his second, the Solar Commonwealth is succeeded by the (interstellar) Terran Empire.
Recently, when I began to reread this future history, I became entirely focused on the future historical content of its opening three stories:
Etienne Fourre;
Stefan Rostomily;
political gangsterism;
the protean enemy;
the Pacific Colony;
the three class education system.
However, this post-World War III period is dwarfed by the much vaster context of two Dark Ages and two periods of interstellar civilization. The Un-man, Naysmith, flies his air boat to the Rockies; the Stellar Union Coordination Service field agent (Cordy), Trevelyan, flies his air car to that same mountain range but over a thousand years later in a different civilization facing different problems.
Naysmith identified the UN's protean enemy as man himself. This "enemy" destroys the Solar Union. Trevelyan, psychologically integrated, instead confronts the external problem of cosmic complexity overwhelming any cerebral or computational attempt to coordinate it. This problem destroys the Stellar Union.
Monday, 14 December 2015
Brotherhood And Order
In Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History, another force for order is the Order of Planetary Engineers, which even thwarts a plot by the discredited and exiled psychotechnicians. Appropriately, "Brake," the last story set in the pre-interstellar period, features an Engineer who is also a Rostomily Brother. The Brotherhood had disbanded three centuries previously (the Chronology seems to be wrong on this point) but the Order must have kept some of the cells.
However, the fact that humanity is only three decades away from the Second Dark Ages is sufficient proof that the UN attempt to build a single sane world civilization has failed. Instead of uniting, Earth is split between Oriental Kali worshipers and Occidental protechnological puritans. The latter sound like a legacy of the earlier Pilgrims. Complicating matters further:
the Kali worshipers are only one branch of the Ramakrishian Eclectics;
there are pro-Technic Asians and Kali-worshiping Americans;
there are also Husseinite Moslems and a New Christendom.
Earth is in a mess. A spaceship captain consoles himself by reflecting:
"Thank all kindly gods that there were men on other planets now! The harvest of all the patient centuries since Galileo would not be entirely lost, whatever happened to Earth."
-Poul Anderson, Cold Victory (New York, 1982), p. 234.
And, indeed, the rest of the Psychotechnic History is about humanity outside the Solar System with only two brief passages set back on Earth.
However, the fact that humanity is only three decades away from the Second Dark Ages is sufficient proof that the UN attempt to build a single sane world civilization has failed. Instead of uniting, Earth is split between Oriental Kali worshipers and Occidental protechnological puritans. The latter sound like a legacy of the earlier Pilgrims. Complicating matters further:
the Kali worshipers are only one branch of the Ramakrishian Eclectics;
there are pro-Technic Asians and Kali-worshiping Americans;
there are also Husseinite Moslems and a New Christendom.
Earth is in a mess. A spaceship captain consoles himself by reflecting:
"Thank all kindly gods that there were men on other planets now! The harvest of all the patient centuries since Galileo would not be entirely lost, whatever happened to Earth."
-Poul Anderson, Cold Victory (New York, 1982), p. 234.
And, indeed, the rest of the Psychotechnic History is about humanity outside the Solar System with only two brief passages set back on Earth.
Saturday, 2 November 2013
Psychotechs
It is impossible to ban technology especially when technology itself must be used as the means of repression. In Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History, the Humanists outlaw the Psychotechnic Institute and it remains outlawed even when the Humanists have been overthrown. Despite this, it is likely that both sides used psychotechnics during the conflict.
When the Solar Union fleet must assemble a sabotage team, volunteers are accepted simply because there is not enough time for the psychotechs either to pick a compatible team or to weld them "...into an unbreakable brotherhood." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 175) However, this makes the team "...an anachronism...a resurrection from old days when war was a wilder business." (p. 174)
On the other side:
"...the Humanists had had ten years in which to build a hard cadre of hard young officers to keep the men obedient." (p. 177)
It is unlikely that the Humanists' principles would make them refuse psychotechnic advice about which young officers would be most reliable. This would have been rationalized by claiming that they would dispense with the psychotechs when the war was won.
In fact, we see psychotechnics surviving into later periods and psychotechnicians coordinating Galactic Civilization in a further future.
When the Solar Union fleet must assemble a sabotage team, volunteers are accepted simply because there is not enough time for the psychotechs either to pick a compatible team or to weld them "...into an unbreakable brotherhood." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 175) However, this makes the team "...an anachronism...a resurrection from old days when war was a wilder business." (p. 174)
On the other side:
"...the Humanists had had ten years in which to build a hard cadre of hard young officers to keep the men obedient." (p. 177)
It is unlikely that the Humanists' principles would make them refuse psychotechnic advice about which young officers would be most reliable. This would have been rationalized by claiming that they would dispense with the psychotechs when the war was won.
In fact, we see psychotechnics surviving into later periods and psychotechnicians coordinating Galactic Civilization in a further future.
Cold Victory
"Quixote And The Windmill" informs us that, in Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History, high technology causes mass unemployment. This fact then becomes part of the background of subsequent stories. Thus, in "Cold Victory," Robert Crane remembers a childhood encounter with an old tramp who drew his citizen's allowance, traveled around the world and told forgotten stories about Br'er Rabbit.
Robert and his brother are on opposite sides in a civil war, a perennial theme. The Humanist revolutionary government has withdrawn Earth and Luna from the Solar Union so Mars and Venus assemble a fleet to restore the Union. Mercenaries are promised booty from the treasure vaults of the Terrestrial dictator and a Venus clan member "...bought a dozen new reclamation units with his share of the loot..." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 191) But is booty a feasible concept in technological warfare?
Crane argues that chance rules history. By chance, Robert was captured but, by chance, he was interrogated by his brother whom he knew how to mislead, crucially influencing the outcome of the battle. The Martian professor replies that a battle does not deflect a historical movement:
"'...no solution has yet been found to the problems which brought forth the Humanists. They will come again; under one name or another they will return. The war was merely a ripple.'" (p. 193)
And the Humanists do come again as anti-technological Kali-worshipers, leading to the Second Dark Ages.
At the start of the argument, the Engineer remarks:
"'If [the dictator] and his cohorts had been doctrinaire, the government of Earth might still be Humanist!'" (p. 166)
- to which the professor replies:
"'But being born of a time of trouble, Humanism was inevitably fanatical...'" (ibid.)
Is the word "...less..." missing before "...doctrinaire..."?
Robert and his brother are on opposite sides in a civil war, a perennial theme. The Humanist revolutionary government has withdrawn Earth and Luna from the Solar Union so Mars and Venus assemble a fleet to restore the Union. Mercenaries are promised booty from the treasure vaults of the Terrestrial dictator and a Venus clan member "...bought a dozen new reclamation units with his share of the loot..." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 191) But is booty a feasible concept in technological warfare?
Crane argues that chance rules history. By chance, Robert was captured but, by chance, he was interrogated by his brother whom he knew how to mislead, crucially influencing the outcome of the battle. The Martian professor replies that a battle does not deflect a historical movement:
"'...no solution has yet been found to the problems which brought forth the Humanists. They will come again; under one name or another they will return. The war was merely a ripple.'" (p. 193)
And the Humanists do come again as anti-technological Kali-worshipers, leading to the Second Dark Ages.
At the start of the argument, the Engineer remarks:
"'If [the dictator] and his cohorts had been doctrinaire, the government of Earth might still be Humanist!'" (p. 166)
- to which the professor replies:
"'But being born of a time of trouble, Humanism was inevitably fanatical...'" (ibid.)
Is the word "...less..." missing before "...doctrinaire..."?
Friday, 1 November 2013
Battle Rock House
I have mentioned several comfortable hostelries in Poul Anderson's works. There is one that we might miss at the midpoint of the Psychotechnic History:
"Battle Rock House...is a quiet tavern on the edge of Syrtis Town...on Mars." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 165)
Its attractions include "...massive sandwood rafters..." and "...competent chess..." (ibid.)
Four converse there:
from Earth, Captain Crane, wearing Solar Guard uniform and insignia;
from Mars, Professor Freylinghausen, wearing an academic gown;
from Venus, Freelady Neilsen-Singh,wearing a Lucifer Clan tartan kilt;
from Luna, Engineer Buwono, wearing the Order of Planetary Engineers uniform.
Thus, this story, "Cold Victory":
informs us that Venus had developed a clan system after the overthrow of the dictatorship by an Un-man in "The Big Rain";
introduces the Planetary Engineers who will play major roles in "The Snows of Ganymede" and "Brake".
Further, the four-sided conversation informs us that the Humanists, who had plotted in "Holmgang", have, between stories, seized power but not been able to hold it. Thus, this story, linking four others, is pivotal to the future history. Its conversation is a framing device for an account of a crucial space battle during the anti-Humanist counterrevolution.
The characters discuss:
"...the old argument, Historical Necessity versus the Man of Destiny." (p. 165)
I think that the Freelady talks much sense:
"'If there are folk around at a crisis time with enough force, they'll shape the way things turn out...Otherwise things will drift.'" (p. 166)
"Battle Rock House...is a quiet tavern on the edge of Syrtis Town...on Mars." (Cold Victory, New York, 1982, p. 165)
Its attractions include "...massive sandwood rafters..." and "...competent chess..." (ibid.)
Four converse there:
from Earth, Captain Crane, wearing Solar Guard uniform and insignia;
from Mars, Professor Freylinghausen, wearing an academic gown;
from Venus, Freelady Neilsen-Singh,wearing a Lucifer Clan tartan kilt;
from Luna, Engineer Buwono, wearing the Order of Planetary Engineers uniform.
Thus, this story, "Cold Victory":
informs us that Venus had developed a clan system after the overthrow of the dictatorship by an Un-man in "The Big Rain";
introduces the Planetary Engineers who will play major roles in "The Snows of Ganymede" and "Brake".
Further, the four-sided conversation informs us that the Humanists, who had plotted in "Holmgang", have, between stories, seized power but not been able to hold it. Thus, this story, linking four others, is pivotal to the future history. Its conversation is a framing device for an account of a crucial space battle during the anti-Humanist counterrevolution.
The characters discuss:
"...the old argument, Historical Necessity versus the Man of Destiny." (p. 165)
I think that the Freelady talks much sense:
"'If there are folk around at a crisis time with enough force, they'll shape the way things turn out...Otherwise things will drift.'" (p. 166)
Thursday, 1 August 2013
Cold Victory
Of the short stories by Poul Anderson collected in Conquests (London, 1981):
the first is set in space;
the second is set during the Jurassic Period;
the third, "Cold Victory," is a conversation piece set in a tavern on Mars during an early period of Anderson's Psychotechnic future history.
Thus, three settings widely distributed through space and time. Conquests is a collection on the theme of war. In "Cold Victory," war and history are discussed not just indirectly by the author but also directly by the characters:
a Martian (human colonial) academic;
a man in the uniform of the Order of Planetary Engineers;
a woman wearing a kilt displaying the tartan of the Lucifer Clan on Venus (Anderson calls her a "Venusian" but the correct adjective, used by Wells, Stapledon and Heinlein, is "Venerian");
the narrator, a Captain in the Solar Guard.
They represent four inhabited planets, Mars, Luna, Venus and Earth. The Captain, from Earth, will suggest that the anti-Humanist counterrevolution was an example of accident, not law, determining history, but his argument will have to wait until I have had a night's sleep and a day of other activities.
the first is set in space;
the second is set during the Jurassic Period;
the third, "Cold Victory," is a conversation piece set in a tavern on Mars during an early period of Anderson's Psychotechnic future history.
Thus, three settings widely distributed through space and time. Conquests is a collection on the theme of war. In "Cold Victory," war and history are discussed not just indirectly by the author but also directly by the characters:
a Martian (human colonial) academic;
a man in the uniform of the Order of Planetary Engineers;
a woman wearing a kilt displaying the tartan of the Lucifer Clan on Venus (Anderson calls her a "Venusian" but the correct adjective, used by Wells, Stapledon and Heinlein, is "Venerian");
the narrator, a Captain in the Solar Guard.
They represent four inhabited planets, Mars, Luna, Venus and Earth. The Captain, from Earth, will suggest that the anti-Humanist counterrevolution was an example of accident, not law, determining history, but his argument will have to wait until I have had a night's sleep and a day of other activities.
Tuesday, 25 September 2012
Holmgang
In Poul Anderson's Hrolf Karki's Saga (New York, 1973):
"In the morning the holmgang took place." (p. 117)
So far, a straightforward narration although we need to know what a "holmgang" is but we might guess this from the context. A man called Svipdag has just challenged the king's berserkers to single combat one at a time.
The text continues:
"This is a usage among the heathen, when men wish to fight out a challenge." (p. 117)
This confirms that the holmgang, like a duel, is the formula for fighting a challenge. It also reminds us, after just over a hundred pages, that the reader is not being addressed by an omniscient narrator. Instead, a Danish woman is addressing an English Christian court several centuries after the events described. That is why she pauses to explain to her audience that the holmgang is a "...usage among the heathen...," where Anderson or his readers might have said "a Norse custom."
The holmgang practice is then described in detail to an audience unfamiliar with it:
a holm is a small island where the antagonists are isolated;
four willow wands mark a field;
an antagonist loses if he is driven beyond them;
the blows go by turns till first blood, yielding or death.
As noted of Saxo and Starkad in the previous post, readers of Anderson's sf have already encountered this term. In a story called "Holmgang," two space suited men agree to fight on an asteroid. Anderson has a unique ability to project the past into the future for story purposes as well as to speculate about possible futures differing qualitatively from previous history.
"In the morning the holmgang took place." (p. 117)
So far, a straightforward narration although we need to know what a "holmgang" is but we might guess this from the context. A man called Svipdag has just challenged the king's berserkers to single combat one at a time.
The text continues:
"This is a usage among the heathen, when men wish to fight out a challenge." (p. 117)
This confirms that the holmgang, like a duel, is the formula for fighting a challenge. It also reminds us, after just over a hundred pages, that the reader is not being addressed by an omniscient narrator. Instead, a Danish woman is addressing an English Christian court several centuries after the events described. That is why she pauses to explain to her audience that the holmgang is a "...usage among the heathen...," where Anderson or his readers might have said "a Norse custom."
The holmgang practice is then described in detail to an audience unfamiliar with it:
a holm is a small island where the antagonists are isolated;
four willow wands mark a field;
an antagonist loses if he is driven beyond them;
the blows go by turns till first blood, yielding or death.
As noted of Saxo and Starkad in the previous post, readers of Anderson's sf have already encountered this term. In a story called "Holmgang," two space suited men agree to fight on an asteroid. Anderson has a unique ability to project the past into the future for story purposes as well as to speculate about possible futures differing qualitatively from previous history.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






