Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Valeria. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Valeria. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, 13 September 2012

The Valeria Matuchek Trilogy

It is almost a trilogy.

Volume I
In Poul Anderson's Operation Chaos, Valeria's parents meet and marry. Valeria is born and grows to the age of three. A demon kidnaps her but her parents rescue her from Hell.

Volume II
In Anderson's Operation Luna, Valeria turns fifteen and is the first human being on the Moon in her timeline.

Volume III
In his A Midsummer Tempest, Valeria, now a graduate student travelling between timelines, advises other travellers, including Holger Danske from Three Hearts And Three Lions, whom she meets in the inter-cosmic inn.

Epilogues
In "House Rule," we meet a regular of the inter-cosmic inn.

In "Losers' Night," the regular lists spectacular women including Moll Flanders, Sojourner Truth and Valeria Matuchek.

The writing order of the Volumes was I, III, II so Anderson filled in an account of Valeria's teenage years after he had included the adult Valeria as a supporting character in A Midsummer Tempest.

Maybe her flight to the Moon qualified her as a spectacular woman or perhaps there was more later? We would like to know the rest of her career but, as far as it goes, this trilogy, or tetralogy if we include Three Hearts And Three Lions, and its Epilogues is already a comprehensive, and not merely linear, narrative sequence.

Monday, 29 August 2016

Retcon

The order of writing of works that feature or mention Valeria Matuchek was:

"Operation Changeling" (1969);
A Midsummer Tempest (1974);
"Losers' Night" (1991);
Operation Luna (1999).

In these works, Valeria:

is three years old and abducted to the Hell universe;
is a young adult and a witch (training or qualified?) traveling between universes;
is listed among women who had spectacular lives;
turns fifteen and is the first human being on the Moon in her timeline.

Thus, Operation Luna "retconned" a spectacular event into Valeria's teens. Poul Anderson did not yet know about Valeria's lunar expedition when he wrote the earlier published works.

In A Midsummer Tempest, Chapter xi, "THE TAPROOM OF THE OLD PHOENIX," Prince Rupert and Will Fairweather enter the inter-cosmic inn, the Old Phoenix. Already present are a man and a woman who continue their conversation. She addresses him as "Holger" (p. 93) and he addresses her as "Valeria" (p. 94). Thus we know, or begin to suspect, that we have met both before although Valeria is considerably older than when last seen in "Operation Changeling."

Later: In A Midsummer Tempest, Valeria is "'...on a field trip, collecting material for a master's thesis.'" (Chapter xii, p. 103)

Saturday, 27 August 2016

Three Narratives

Poul Anderson, Operation Luna (New York, 2000).

When Steve Matuchek writes that his story splits three ways:

he confers with Native American gods;
Ginny consults Mimir;
Valeria remains at home.

The riddle that Ginny asks Mimir to solve is the US tax code. Thus, in this chapter, the story becomes a satire. The wise jotun consulted by Odin about the Ragnarok gnaws his beard while struggling to understand income tax.

There is a further point here. We read chapters that are narrated from Ginny's and Valeria's points of view. Thus, in these chapters, third person narration replaces first person narration. For example, Valeria wonders:

"How about rereading a Magister Lazarus book? And, after dinner, playing some music to fall asleep by? Who knew but what Daddy and Mom would both be back when she woke..." (p. 362)

If the entire book had been written from Valeria's pov, then we would accept that this was what she thought. However, Steve has already told us that he had reconstructed this part of the story from information received later and from guesswork. Thus, Valeria might not have thought precisely this. It is her father's guess at the kind of thing that she might have thought.

He has also told us (see here) that his narrative is to be be put under a hundred-year seal so that, in any case, none of his contemporaries and none of Valeria's acquaintances will ever read it. And it is not addressed to us in our timeline as the telepathically broadcast Operation Chaos was. So we are not reading it either. The process of narration becomes ever more mysterious.

Saturday, 1 February 2014

Superstition

Poul Anderson, "Superstition" IN Anderson, Fantasy (New York, 1981), pp. 231-264. (Originally published in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, 1952.)

This is a queer short story:

two of the characters' names are familiar from Anderson's two Operation... novels but these are different characters;
 
this is yet another impoverished-Earth-recovering-from-nuclear-war-with-limited-resources story;

the story describes a routine journey in a spaceship from Earth to Mars, which is a standard sf theme;

however, the characters practice magic rituals and take for granted that these work so this seems to be a "hard fantasy" story;

but one of the characters is an Old Believer in science who denounces the rituals as mere superstition - so, in effect, the characters argue about which kind of story they are in!

The Argument
Hall: If a rain dance does not bring rain, you say that there was a counter-influence, so your ideas are unfalsifiable and therefore meaningless.

Valeria: If your radio circuit fails to work, you say that there is something wrong with it so what is the difference?

Hall: I can find out what is wrong and correct it.

Valeria: If a rain dance fails, the warlock finds out what was amiss, makes amends and holds another dance until it works.

Captain Martin: Earth stays in its orbit because of American Indian rituals.

Hall: But there were no such rituals in the old days.

Martin: There were always rituals in so-called backward tribes.

Hall: But before mankind?

Martin: God did it, then turned over the responsibility to mankind.

Maybe magic was less effective in the old days because there was so much disbelief?

When Valeria detects a meteor swarm not by radar but by foresight, Martin sees approaching meteors through the telescope but Hall suggests that he has hypnotized himself to see them. When two meteors penetrate the ship but Valeria says that she has deflected the rest, Hall suggests that telepathy, precognition, psychokinesis and psychosomatics are mental powers that are aided by believed-in rituals but can now be understood scientifically. Valeria replies that magic given such names is "'...still magic!'" (p. 263) So we still do not know which kind of story we are reading.

But the story contains yet another issue.

Martin: "'But the superstition is this, son: that science could understand everything, and do everything, and make everything good.'" (p. 262)

Then he cites radioactive craters and mutations as proof not that science does not work but that it does not make everything good. We must agree with this - that science alone does not make everything good. Politicians and their publics must stop waging wars, especially when they have become so destructive.

Wednesday, 20 May 2020

A Time Travel Hypothesis

Operation Chaos, XXXIII.

It seems that a demon abducted Valeria because of an impulsive curse by a single Johannine, not because of any Johannine plot, but I will confirm or disconfirm this before finishing the current rereading of the novel, probably tomorrow.

Let us finish today with a hypothetical time travel paradox. If the Matucheks arrive in the hell universe early enough to prevent Valeria's kidnapper from departing on his kidnapping mission, then what happens?

I suggest that the Matucheks return to a goetic universe in which:

Valeria was not kidnapped;
the Matucheks did not set off to rescue her;
thus, they have duplicated themselves.

However, they have left behind them a goetic universe in which:

Valeria was kidnapped;
her parents set off to rescue her and did not return;
Valeria was taken to the hell universe and was not rescued, at least not by her parents.

That is the best that I can come up with tonight.

Tuesday, 19 May 2020

Time And Times

Operation Chaos, XXVII.

Marmiadon tells Matuchek:

"'If [Valeria] were in the Low Continuum, retrieval operations would involve temporal phasing. Do you know what I mean? I'm not learned in such matters myself, but our adepts are, and a portion of their findings is taught to initiates, beginning at the fourth degree. The mathematics is beyond me. But as I recall, the hell universe has a peculiar, complex space-time geometry. It would be as easy to recover your daughter from the exact instant when she arrived there as from any other moment.'" (p. 202)

I do not think that either the peculiarity or the complexity of the space-time geometry of the hell universe is necessary to reach Marmiadon's conclusion that Valeria can be rescued from the moment of her arrival in the hell universe.

The (a) goetic universe and (b) hell universe are two spatiotemporal universes, each with at least three spatial dimensions and at least one temporal dimension. If there were a one-to-one relationship between any given moment in (a) and a corresponding moment in (b), then (a) and (b) would be not different universes but different spatial regions within a single temporal universe - and, even then, the relativity of simultaneity would prevent an exact one-to-one correspondence.

(a) and (b) can be compared to two entirely different books. I am currently rereading Operation Chaos by Poul Anderson and Blood Royal by Dornford Yates. Neither book is a chapter, part or sub-section of the other. They are not two volumes of a single series. Each has its own fictional timeline. No moment in Chandos' experience is simultaneous with any moment in Matuchek's experience. If I cease to reread Operation Chaos at the bottom of p. 202, then I am not obliged to begin rereading Blood Royal from the top of p. 203. I can begin at the beginning or at any other point in the text. It would be a mere coincidence if my rereading of p. 202 in one book were to be immediately followed by my rereading of p. 203 in the other book.

Leaving (a) the goetic universe, the expedition to rescue Valeria will enter (b) the hell universe entirely from outside that entire spatiotemporal universe, like opening a book, not necessarily at p. 1. We can open a book either at random or at the page where we have placed a bookmark. Scanning (b) from entirely outside that universe, the expedition can identify not only a place, a set of spatial coordinates, but also a time, the moment of Valeria's arrival, and can then enter (b) at that place and time - or, better still, slightly earlier to rescue her at the instant when she arrives.

If, further, the expedition can return to (a) at any moment of its existence, then they have found a means of time travel within (a). However, I imagine that there are some physical limitations, e.g., that the spell that enables them to leave their universe returns them to the set of spatiotemporal coordinates from which they had departed. (A span of time in (b) would correspond to zero time in (a).)

Saturday, 16 December 2017

Ways Of Knowing: Tomorrow Is Yesterday

(I referred here to an object passing through the Solar System. Here is a later report.)

How might we learn about multi-dimensional space-time? Our inter-dimensional guides this evening are:

HG Wells;
Robert Heinlein;
James Blish;
CS Lewis;
Poul Anderson;
Neil Gaiman;
SM Stirling.

Wells, Men Like Gods
An experiment in the Utopian timeline transports several Earthlings to Utopia.

Heinlein, "Elsewhen" and Waldo
Thought alone gives access to other universes.

Blish, The Quincunx Of Time and Midsummer Century
After receiving a message about time-projection from 25,000 AD, Thor Wald invents a metalanguage which shows that science cannot choose between future paradigms because it is one of those paradigms.
John Martels falls into a radio telescope of a radically new design with an inconceivable reach, thus prompting the message intercepted by Wald.

CS Lewis, Perelandra and "The Dark Tower"
In Oxford, Lewis reads an early seventeenth century Latin text about the celestial frame of spatial references.
In Cambridge, Lewis and his colleagues observe an alternative Earth through a chronoscope which also becomes the mechanism for an inter-Earth mind transference.

Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest
Valeria Matuchek's theorems let her reach the continuum that she wants "'...or a reasonable facsimile of it.'" (Chapter xii, pp. 95-96) whereas Holger Danske has traveled at random, using a "'...superstition-riddled medieval grimoire...,'" (p. 96) so Valeria refers Holger to Sokolnikoff's Introduction to Paratemporal Mathematics and to the Handbook of Alchemy and Metaphysics.

Neil Gaiman, The Sandman: The Wake
A reality storm strands travelers in the Inn of the Worlds' End. When they leave, they will return to the worlds from which they came or very similar ones.

SM Stirling, The Peshawar Lancers
A clairvoyant simultaneously experiences multiple alternative presents.

I like the contrasts between:

the radio telescope and the chronoscope;

Wald's Machine language message from 25,000 AD, Lewis' Latin manuscript from the seventeenth century and Valeria's reference books;

Valeria reaching the continuum she wants or a facsimile of it and the Inn guests returning to their worlds or similar ones;

Wald theorizing about multidimensionality and Stirling's Yasmini directly experiencing alternative realities.

Thursday, 21 May 2020

Rescue From Hell

Operation Chaos, XXXIII.

In the hell universe:

a monstrous towered castle, several square miles in area;

within the castle, a courtyard;

at the center of the courtyard, a small, stone, steepled, windowless house like a perverted chapel;

within the house, a single room with a lighted altar, a pattern of objects to be used for a magical transit, the changeling not yet transmitted to the goetic universe and refuse from the Matuchek's house displaced by the demon who has gone to kidnap Valeria.

Matuchek knows that Virginia's familiar, the cat Svartalf, fought the demon who then departed with Virginia but has not yet arrived back in the hell universe:

"At this moment, if simultaneity had meaning between universes, the fight ramped and Svartalf's blood was riven from him." (p. 267)

Simultaneity cannot have any meaning between two different space-time continua (see Time And Times). However, for practical purposes, Matuchek can think in terms of simultaneity because he has arrived at the demon's departure point before the demon's return to it. He then makes a perfectly straightforward point which I previously misunderstood because I misinterpreted it as a time travel paradox (see Two Air Fights With Demons). When Virginia draws a diagram for defense against the demons trying to follow the Matucheks into the small stone house, she must not disturb the pattern of objects that has been laid out for the demon's transit between worlds:

"They were the demon's return ticket. Given them, he need simply cast the appropriate spell in our cosmos... If the kidnaper found himself unable to make it back with his victim, God alone knew what would happen. They'd certainly both leave our home and a changeling replace them. But we'd have no inkling of how this came about or where they'd gone. It might provide the exact chance the enemy needed to get his project back on the rails." (p. 267)

I thought that the situation was as follows:

Matuchek knows that the demon had arrived back in the hell universe with Valeria;

therefore, to prevent that arrival would be to "change the past" with all the complications or contradictions that that always entails.

However, the situation is much simpler:

Matuchek knows that the demon had departed from the Matuchek household with Valeria;

however, he does not yet know for sure that the demon had arrived back in the hell universe with Valeria,

therefore, to prevent that arrival will not be to "change the past" but would be to generate a new problem - where did they go instead?

Wednesday, 1 July 2020

Character Consistency And Plot Continuity Even In The Multiverse

Happy July.

For blog purposes, we regard Poul Anderson's Operation Otherworld (=Operation Chaos + Operation Luna) as the middle volume of a multiversal trilogy beginning with Three Hearts And Three Lions and concluding with A Midsummer Tempest:

in THATL, Holger Carlsen fights for Law against Chaos in two universes;

in Operation Chaos, the Matucheks fight for Law against Chaos in a third universe;

in A Midsummer Tempest, Holger meets Valeria Matuchek in the Old Phoenix Inn between universes.

At the end of THATL, Holger has:

returned from the Carolingian universe to (what looks like) our universe where World War II was against Nazi Germany - whereas, in the Matuchek's universe, it was against the Saracen Caliphate;

converted to Catholicism because of his experiences in the Carolingian universe which included remembering that he is native to that universe and a legendary hero of Christendom;

searched bookshops in London, Paris, Rome and the US for grimoires because he wants to return to the Carolingian universe by magic;

disappeared.

When he meets Valeria, he has:

used grimoires to travel between universes but without direction;
has had many mishaps, e.g., barely escaping from Aztec gods;
entered the Old Phoenix by accident.

Valeria uses Sokolnikoff's Introduction to Paratemporal Mathematics and the Handbook of Alchemy and Metaphysics to teach Holger theorems that will enable him to travel to the continuum that he wants but he will have to understand the transcendental calculus to prove the theorems.

And, unfortunately, that is the last that we see of either Holger or Valeria. Anderson's many vast series show us that there is always more than we know.

Saturday, 8 September 2012

Operation Chaos Conclusion

Poul Anderson's Operation Chaos combines three ideas:

Hell, a place inhabited by malevolent demons;

a universe at full entropy, dark space containing only dead stars and planets;

a universe with radically non-Euclidean and locally variable spatiotemporal relationships.

Do these ideas fit together? Parapsychic forces move and animate otherwise inert matter so that, on a dead planet in the full entropy universe, demons are embodied and dead armies fight an endless battle.

Considered in isolation, the non-Euclidean space-time idea might have led just to a game of hide and seek in a four dimensional labyrinth but, combined with the first two ideas, it enables:

demons to prepare horrific conditions for anyone arriving from Earth;

the Matucheks, rescuing their kidnapped daughter Valeria, to arrive in Hell/on the dead planet before Valeria and her kidnapper, thus to return her immediately to Earth before she has had time to experience any of the Hellish conditions.

So Anderson just about pulls it all together.

The Adversary, or some other being almost as low down in Hell, had directly addressed Steve Matuchek a few times in a way that had suggested a build up to a big showdown that never really happens. The kidnapping of Valeria was not, as I had thought, an attempt to lure the Matucheks to a place where they could be disposed of but more of a local accident. The Matucheks confront only a local baron and his hordes in Hell. However, there is a sequel, Operation Luna, which I will shortly reread.

(Incidentally, though, the Matucheks return from Hell with a prisoner, Valeria's kidnapper, whose evidence closes down a demonic front, the Johannine Church, so they have indeed set back the Adversary's plans as he had anticipated they would.)

Monday, 22 June 2020

Same Space Or Other Space

Three Hearts And Three Lions, CHAPTER SEVEN.

Holger continues to try to make sense of his experiences. Both the similarities and the differences to his own world rule out another planet in the same universe. Gravity and chemistry operate but allow for magic unless the apparent magic is telekinesis? Maybe many universes can occupy the same space and time without interacting except for some as yet unknown link?

In the DC multiverse, universes occupying the same space vibrated at different rates. If you changed your vibratory rate, then you dematerialized from one universe and materialized in another but hopefully on an alternative Earth, not in empty space.

Universes occupying the same space, whether by vibrating differently or in some other way, can fit into the same four dimensions and therefore need not coexist along a fourth spatial dimension contrary to what I said here.

Valeria Matuchek confirms this:

"'...the cosmoses...occupy the same space-time...'"
-Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), xii, p. 101 -

- i.e., the same four dimensions -

- but then contradicts it:

"'...being separated by a set of dimensions ''" (ibid.)

However, the only role of Valeria's remarks at this stage in the narrative is to cause Holger to interrupt her to say that she is leaving him and Rupert behind. Valeria then concentrates on the practicalities of historical divergences rather than on their physics or metaphysics.

Thursday, 4 February 2016

Alternative Shakespeare

(The Old Phoenix sequence, the Time Patrol series and the Technic History in a single image.)

Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), Chapter xii.

Valeria points out to Rupert that he inhabits a world with a particular geography, astronomy, natural laws, people, nations, societies, past, present and future. He agrees although I can imagine him getting puzzled and asking how it could be otherwise. She is used to the idea of multiple worlds; he is not, yet.

Next, she asks him to imagine a divergent history. Since she is starting easy with the idea of alternative histories, not of alternative cosmologies, why does she initially confuse the issue by mentioning geography, astronomy and even natural laws? She prompts him with the obvious example of "'A battle lost instead of won...'" (p. 100) An obvious starting point in England would be 1066: two crucial battles with several possible outcomes. Instead, Rupert goes further back, imagining that:

Hamlet did not die young;
thus he, not Fortinbras, became King of Denmark;
King Hamlet helped his kinfolk to overthrow the usurper, Macbeth;
then the Danes turned their primitive cannon against Norman William...

This is both a crossover and an alternative history/imaginary story/Elseworld/What if? etc for Shakespeare's plays.

Valeria explains that there could be two whole universes but she uses twentieth century terms that Rupert cannot possibly understand:

"space-time" - he will have a common sense understanding only of "space" and of "time";
"galaxies" - he will not know what this means;
"planets" - he will have a different understanding of this term (Sun and Moon are "planets," Earth is not);
"matter and energy particles" - he might know some Greek Atomist philosophy but that does not refer to energy particles;
"dimensions" - will this mean anything?

Holger rightly points out that Valeria is leaving Rupert behind. However, the reader gets the message, more or less.

A Large Gathering In The Old Phoenix

Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), Epilogue, pp. 228-229.

During a later visit to the Old Phoenix, Valeria recognizes:

a monk with a wolf;
a drunken Chinaman writing a poem;
a rangy fellow with a harp;
a man with an iridescent jewel on his wrist;
a lean Victorian with a lame companion;
a freckled boy with a black companion "...in tatterdemalion farm clothes..." (p. 228);
a warrior with coppery skin, a feather crown, a calumet and an ear of maize.

I recognize only two of them, both fictional in our timeline. There are others whom she does not recognize and some of those are not human.

In Valeria's timeline as in ours, Prince Rupert helped invent the mezzotint. Her and our timelines diverge about 1900. Valeria identifies the real New World as science, "...reason triumphant..." (p. 229), hopeful, challenging and liberating. Yes, if other social forces do not destroy it.

Monday, 3 July 2017

Time And The Hereafter

If there is a hereafter, which I doubt, is its passage of time the same as ours? If someone died a week ago, has he now been in the hereafter for a week? It is impossible that the hereafter is timeless because consciousness requires time.

In Poul Anderson's Operation Chaos, the baby Valeria Matuchek has been kidnapped to Hell. It takes time for Valeria's parents to organize a rescue team. However, the team is able to arrive in Hell just before Valeria so that she is rescued after only a few moments in the infernal realm where space and time are chaotic in any case.

In SM Stirling's Emberverse, one character arriving in the Summerlands and another visiting Heaven are greeted by people whom they know to be still alive on Earth.

"'The great Governors seem to have no time sense as we understand the term...'"
-James Blish, Black Easter (New York, 1977), III, p. 42.

"'Only One has descended into Hell.'
"'And will he ever do so again?'
"'It was not once long ago that He did it. Time does not work that way once ye have left the Earth. All moments that have been or shall be were, or are, present in the moment of His descending.'"
-CS Lewis, The Great Divorce (London, 1982), p. 114.

Monday, 29 August 2016

Valeria on The Moon II

Poul Anderson, Operation Luna (New York, 2000), Chapter 47.

Does Valeria have it rather easy on the Moon? She lands on the demon-infested Moon but:

she lands among the exiled Fair Folk;
they tell her that there are less than a hundred demons;
the demons are scattered because, although they were expecting Valeria, they did not know where she would land;
three attack;
she kills them, following her sentient sword's good advice ("...no silly overhead cuts leaving your belly wide open..." (p. 420);
a fairy enters her broomstick to help it back to Earth;
she takes off just as more demons swarm over the horizon.

Thursday, 6 September 2012

Operations Incubus, Changeling And Luna


Steve Matuchek and Virginia Graylock meet, become engaged and marry.

They dispose of an incubus/succubus on their honeymoon.

Their daughter Valeria is born.

At the age of three, Valeria is kidnapped/exchanged and has to be rescued from Hell.

Steve attempts telepathic contact with other timelines which may exist.

As a teenager, Valeria is the first person on the Moon in their timeline.

As a graduate student, she explores other timelines which are now known to exist.

In the Old Phoenix, the inn between the world, she helps other travellers, Holger Danske and Rupert of the Rhine.

Another series that we wish had continued...

Saturday, 13 June 2026

Old Phoenix POV's

Careful rereading is necessary. The first person narrator of Poul Anderson's "House Rule" informs us that the Peter Abelard whom he sees in the Old Phoenix Inn is:

"...still a whole man."
-Poul Anderson, "House Rule" IN Anderson, Fantasy (New York, September, 1981), pp. 9-20 AT p. 16 -

- i.e., has not been castrated, as he was in our history. 

The first person narrator of Anderson's "Losers' Night" informs us that he has:

"...heard, or seen for myself..."
-"Losers' Night," p. 111. (my emphasis)

- that several legendary, mythical, fictional, literary or historical persons have visited the Old Phoenix and that these include:

"...an Abelard who remained a whole man..." (ibid.)

I had to check. The absence of that phrase, "...or seen for myself...," would have implied different narrators for these two stories.

That narrator is absent from the Old Phoenix passages in A Midsummer Tempest which are all in the third person. Chapter xi begins with Prince Rupert's point of view (pov) but becomes omniscient narrator when he leaves the taproom. In xii, Rupert returns to the taproom and the narrative returns to his pov. In both cases, Valeria Matuchek is present. In the Epilogue, Rupert and his companion, Will, are long gone, Valeria has just finished recounting their story to a larger group of guests and the narration is from her pov.

And that is it for Old Phoenix povs. As Valeria concludes:

"'I hope you've enjoyed my story.'"
-Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), p. 229.

Here the author addresses his readers.

Tuesday, 2 September 2014

Multiverse III

Valeria Matuchek tells Holger Carlsen:

"'...God never felt obliged to make the universes easy for us to understand.'"
-Poul Anderson, A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), p. 98.

There is some empirical basis for Valeria's reference to "God" because, in her universe, where magic works, it is possible to contact a Heaven, a Hell and their inhabitants. But are these supernatural realms specific to that universe? Another timeline visited by Holger has Aztec gods. Are those supernatural beings autonomous or subordinate to a single multiversal creator, as Bacchus and the river god are subordinate to Aslan, although with a surprising degree of autonomy, in Narnia?

Valeria's father makes the point that:

"...if parallel worlds exist, they must be linked in a very fundamental way; otherwise the hypothesis is unverifiable in principle and therefore meaningless. Deriving from the same source, embedded in the same matrix..."
-Poul Anderson, Operation Chaos (Sutton, Surrey, 1995), p. 2.

But is the single source a common creator? If every possibility exists, does this include universes where statements like "God does not exist" or "God is dead" are true?

I thought that "God is dead" meant something like "God never existed but now more people realize it," but apparently some "God is dead" theologians mean that a powerful supernatural being literally ceased to exist. I think that every possible interpretation is put on unverifiable statements of this kind.

James Blish's Black Easter ends with a demon announcing God's death but the sequel ends with Satan wondering whether He has merely withdrawn. In Mike Carey's Lucifer, a character says that God is dead whereas He has merely withdrawn - but will not return. Could such options exist within Anderson's multiverse?

Tuesday, 12 November 2019

Parallel Reading

Poul Anderson's Steve Matuchek rescues his young daughter, Valeria, from Hell whereas Alan Moore's Swamp Thing rescues his girlfriend, Abby, from Hell.

Matuchek is a werewolf who meets other standard fantasy beings whereas Swampy meets a werewolf and other standard fantasy beings.

Matuchek tries to communicate telepathically with parallel Earths and Valeria later travels between them whereas Swampy must respond to the spiritual and supernatural aftermath of the destruction of many parallel universes and the merging of five.

Valeria meets characters from two other Anderson novels whereas Swampy meets characters from several other DC Comics titles.

Tuesday, 30 August 2016

Cavaliers And Roundheads

My childhood:

cops and robbers;
cowboys and Indians;
Cavaliers and Roundheads.

I read a comic strip with a Cavalier as hero and Roundheads as Nazi-like villains. In my teens, I read a series of novels about a Roundhead spy, Nicholas Pym:

Pym's immediate superior, the equivalent of M, was John Thurloe;

Pym also met Cromwell and prevented his assassination;

Pym's enemies were Guido Fawkes, son of Guy, and the Sealed Knot, which answered to the exiled Stuart.

In Poul Anderson's A Midsummer Tempest (London, 1975), Chapter xii, Valeria Matuchek says:

"'...I always had sympathy for the Cavaliers. Maybe that was schoolgirl romantics; and anyhow, the issues may not be identical in Rupert's home.'" (p. 105)

Would you fight for a King against a Parliament? Leon Trotsky, analyzing seventeenth century England, identified three successive "dual powers," actual or potential civil wars:

King versus Parliament - Parliament won;
Parliament versus Army - Army won;
generals versus rank and file - generals won.

The significance of Cromwell was that he was on the winning side each time and thus became Lord Protector, dictator. My sympathies would have been with the Levelers, who wanted common ownership of land and an end to social hierarchies. However, I would have been pleased enough to see the merchants gaining political power as against the aristocrats, which is what came to pass.

Valeria concludes:

"'Nothing ever was forever, anyway. Peace never came natural. The point is, it can sometimes be won for some years, and they can be lived in.'"
-Epilogue, p. 229.

Dominic Flandry and Manse Everard say the same. We recognize Poul Anderson's authorship and philosophy in the Technic History universe, the Time Patrol universe and the old Phoenix multiverse.

"'Enough. I hope you've enjoyed my story.'" (ibid.)

So has Valeria narrated the entire novel?