Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Beta Centauri. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Beta Centauri. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, 27 December 2018

The Astronomy Of The Technic Civilization Saga by Johan Ortiz

-Hard science, artistic license and obsolete data-

 

The son of an engineer and with an education in physics himself, Poul Anderson was not shy about including hard science in his fiction. While future tech was often handwaved off with a minimum of techno-babble, when it comes to strange stars and planets, we get a veritable catalogue of facts from spectral type of the star, the axial tilt of the planet, even in some cases including the geology of his worlds! And while he did create a lot of fictional stars, he also made use of real ones when building his future histories. This is very apparent in his Technic civilization stories, where some actual stars are recurring “characters” together with some fictional ones. It is notable that in that series of stories, most of the action takes place either in the Sol system or in rather distant star systems. Hardly any Technic story takes place within 20 light years of Sol (excepting Sol itself). Staple stars of science fiction like Epsilon Eridani, Sigma Draconis or Tau Ceti are seldom mentioned. In a rare exception, the future first Emperor of Terra, Manuel Argos, is captured by the Gorzuni on Alpha Centauri. Another relatively close system mentioned is Chee Lan’s home planet Cynthia which orbits Omicron 2 Eridani A, 16,3 LY from Sol.

The position of the real star systems used, just as the fictional ones, are often described at least relative to the Sol system – and it is here that the advancement of science has made a disservice to Anderson’s work. During, and especially after the period during which he worked on the technic civilization saga, the data we have on the distance from Sol of many of the stars mentioned in the stories have improved considerably.

Because we do not know with certainty the absolute luminosity of a distant star – we cannot really tell at a glance if it is a shining giant at an enormous distance we are seeing or a modest dwarf closer to Sol – we can measure distance from us by using the parallax method. It is how our depth vision work. Just as our brains can calculate the distance to an object through (among other means) the slight difference in angle between the picture of either eye, astronomers can measure the angle to a star at two points in time. Using the difference in angle between the two observations, trigonometric calculus can give an estimate of the distance to a star. However, the more distant the star, the smaller the angle is and the harder it is to accurately calculate the distance. And in this, the state of the art has advanced considerably since the 1950s. For example, in the 1990s, close to the end of Poul Anderson’s career, the Hipparcos mission obtained parallaxes for over a hundred thousand stars with a precision of about a milliarcsecond, providing useful distances for the first time for stars out to a few hundred parsecs (a parsec is equal to about 3.26 light years). With the Hubble telescope we can today reliably determine distances out to 5 000 parsecs. None of this was possible in the 50s, 60s or even 70s.

This coupled with the fact that the Technic stories involve mainly distant stars has caused the distances mentioned by Poul Anderson to become very dated. I shall name a few examples.

In A SUN INVISIBLE, the distance from Sol to Beta Centauri is given as 190 LY. Currently, it is believed to be 397 LY. In SATAN’S WORLD, the Serendipity supercomputer tells David Falkayn that Beta Crucis is 204 LY from Sol. Currently it is believed to be 287 LY. Note that this also means that the author thought of these two stars as being be much closer to each other than what we now believe.

The obsolete data for distance to real stars have consequences also for the locations of fictional ones, since their position is often described as relative to real stars.

In WINGS OF VICTORY, in which an Earth star ship of The Great Survey visits the Home world of the avian Ythrians, their star is said to be “beyond the great stars Alpha and Beta Crucis”, “in the constellation Lupus” and “278 light years from Sol”. As mentioned earlier, this is inconsistent with modern data, since the closer of the two stars, Beta Crucis is about 287 LY from Sol, and Alpha Crucis is 326 LY. To be considered “beyond” both these stars in any sense of the word, Ythri must be no closer than 326 LY to Sol. Add to this that Ythri is to be found in Constellation Lupus, not Crux as Alpha and Beta Crucis, that is to say a considerable distance to one side of Crux.  If we are truly to consider us to be “beyond” and not “beside” Alpha Crucis, we would have to increase the distance further – exactly how long is impossible to determine, but one could safely assume another 100 LY at the least, to place A .Crucis “behind” rather than beside us.

But we have more clues in other stories. In THE PEOPLE OF THE WIND, the Terran Empire initiates a war of conquest against the Ythrians. Among the reasons are to secure for Terra the system of Beta Centauri, around which orbited several Krakoan- and one human-inhabited worlds before Ythri might beat them to it, as they already had with the Dathyna-system (from SATAN’S WORLD). Beta Centauri is, also as mentioned, 397 LY from Sol, and while it is not inconceivable that Terra and Ythri would dispute a system beyond Ythri from Sol, intuitively we would assume that the disputed systems are between the two. Beta Centauri is not mentioned as a close neighbour to Ythri in “wings of victory”, which makes sense since we know that the author believed B. Centauri to be only 190 LY from Sol, we can conclude that he also thought of Ythri as being no closer to B. Centauri than 88 LY (which would any way require it to be behind Beta Centauri and in Constellation Centaurus, not Lupus). These considerations would lead us to the conclusion that Ythri is near to 500 LY from Sol.

Another problematic set of data appears in Anderson’s Dominc Flandry stories set in the decadent Terran Empire of the early 31st century. The Empire is said to control a rough sphere with a radius of two hundred light years including around 4 million stars – but within that sphere are Beta Centauri (397 LY away), Alpha Crucis (326 LY from Sol), Beta Crucis (287 LY) and Antares (609 LY from Sol). Betelgeuse (642 LY from Sol) is not within the Empire, but a buffer state between Terra and Merseia (which is said to be located in “the wilderness between Betelgeuse and Rigel” in THE DAY OF BURNING). To make matters worse, Antares and Betelgeuse are almost exactly opposite each other from Sol. The Empire thus claims space up to more than 600 LY in both these directions.

Another problem is that within a sphere with even a 250 LY radius from Sol, there are in the proximity of 260 000 stars, so nowhere near the 4 million stars mentioned. That amounts to about 0,0038 stars per cubic light year. Using this star density, it would require a sphere with a radius of almost 630 LY to include 4 million stars.

On the other hand, in THE REBEL WORLDS, Polaris and Deneb are said to be “unutterably far beyond the Empire and its enemies”. This is doubtlessly true about Deneb (1 547 LY from Sol) but Polaris is “only” 431 LY from Sol, that is to say closer  than both Antares and Betelgeuse and also notable for being on one end of the sphere controlled by the Polesotechnic League in the era of Van Rijn and Falkayn, which held sway “from Polaris to Canopus” (Canopus is 313 LY from Sol, by the way). While it is mentioned by Flandry that the Polesotechnic League explored far beyond the Empire’s reach, it is odd that Polaris should be considered “unutterably” beyond the Terran sphere, when being closer to Sol than some of the Empire’s more notable border systems.

None of the this would really be problematic unless for the oft-repeated statement that the Empire controls a “rough sphere” 400 LY across, or with a radius of 200 LY. An Empire that controls Antares, Alpha and Beta Crucis, Beta Centauri and which borders Betelgeuse but otherwise only holds sway out to a radius of 200 LY from Sol is not a sphere – rather it is shaped like a three-dimensional starfish!

Now, how to reconcile these inconsistencies with Poul Anderson’s texts? One way is to decide that the entire universe is fictional, and that in the universe of the technic civilization, Beta Crucis really is only 200 LY from Earth. Another approach is that of “minimum rewrite”, i.e. to ignore those measure of distance given by the author that are inconsistent with modern data but accept all other facts – in other words, accept that Antares is an Imperial system, and Betelgeuse is a buffer state, and thus conclude that the Empire is over 1 200 LY across between those systems. That would also mean accepting that the Empire, as stated, is a rough sphere rather than a starfish, but that it is a sphere with a diameter of roughly 400 parsec (rather than light years). Interestingly, the earlier mentioned radius of a sphere required to englobe 4 million stars, 630 LY, corresponds to 193,1 parsecs. A sphere with a 200 parsec radius would hold, on average, 4,4 million stars. Close enough!

Not all astronomic inconsistencies in Anderson’s work stem from obsolete data however. Above all, he was a writer of fiction, and as such he would engage, from time to time, in artistic license. In WE CLAIM THESE STARS, the dastardly Merseians are trying a land grab (or star grab perhaps?) in the fictional Syrax star cluster, which, if held by the Merseians would “bypass Antares” (presumably an imperial bastion) and thus hasten the demise of the Terran Empire by a century or more. The only problem is that, as mentioned before, Antares in constellation Scorpio is on the exact opposite side of Sol from constellation Orion where Merseia orbits the star Korych between Betelgeuse and Rigel (according to THE DAY OF BURNING). Thus, if we are to take this at face value, the Merseians have completely surrounded the Terran Empire at least on one side and can threaten it from the exact opposite direction of their home world, more than 1 250 LY away, in a straight line and more than 2 000 LY away if they have to fly around the circumference of the Terran sphere. Assuming speeds similar to those given in SATAN’S WORLD (Sol to Beta Crucis in two weeks), such a journey would take close to 100 days. It could be less, if the state of the art of hyperlight travel has improved in the centuries since SATAN’S WORLD, or it could be more, given that the estimated travel time in that story was for a small, swift ship for a few passengers. A heavy battlefleet might be considerably slower. The Merseian fleet at Syrax could well have made a journey comparable in length to that of the ill-fated Russian Baltic Fleet sailing to Tshushima in 1904-1905 (which took around six months).

On the other hand, we are told the Merseia threatens the Empire on its “Betelgeusan flank, and the barbarians everywhere else” – the Empire does not have Merseia around half of its periphery. This leaves a distant Merseian base the only possible explanation, perhaps similar to Cuba becoming a Soviet base during the Cuban missile crisis. That analogy makes clear the problem with that assumption obvious – while the US would have very much deplored and opposed a Soviet attempt to take over, say Haiti from its Cuban base in 1961, the really big beef was having Soviet missiles on Cuba in the first place.

By the same token, if the Merseians were threatening Syrax from a distant exclave in Constellation Scorpius, then surely it would be worth at least a passing mention by Flandry or his superiors? Such a base would constitute a major strategic conundrum for Terra, far more important in itself than the fate of the Syrax cluster and one it could scarcely leave unaddressed, even in it morose decadence. Nonetheless, this is what the reader will have to assume, if we are not to dismiss the premises of the story out of hand!

In this case, obsolete data are not to blame – the directions of Antares and Betelgeuse where as well known in 1969 when that particular story was written as they are today.  But Antares had been used in several prior stories and connects the reader with the Technic universe through familiarity of places and names. It will be noted though that never in the story does Anderson say that Antares is anywhere near Betelgeuse or Korych. The inconsistency is not in astronomy but rather in somewhat implausible geo- or rather astropolitics.

Thursday, 4 April 2019

Metonymies

Poul Anderson, "Horse Trader" IN Anderson, Space Folk (New York, 1989), pp. 261-303.

The title character of "Horse Trader" has to negotiate with 61 Cygni A, Tau Ceti and 70 Ophiuchi B. We recognize these as the names of stars. Each is identified by its position in a constellation and also by a letter if it is a member of a binary or multiple system. Anderson informs us that each of these stellar names is a "metonymy." (p. 263)

Each of the beings with whom the "Horse Trader" negotiates represents neither a star nor its entire planetary system but just one society on one planet of that star. Thus, a representative of the United Kingdom, the European Union or the United States, having arrived in the system of 61 Cygni A, might be metonymously described as "Sol."

One being is referred to as a "Centaurian" although he is from the clan of Brogu on the continent of Almerik on the planet Alpha Centauri B II, not from Alpha Centauri A III, which is also mentioned, let alone from Beta Centauri.

Centaurus is a constellation.
Alpha and Beta Centauri are stellar systems.
Alpha Centauri B is a star.
Alpha Centauri B II is a planet.
This "Centaurian" represents one tribe on one continent.

And so on.

Extra-solars might place Sol in a constellation as seen from their planet or might use some other system to classify stars. 

Thursday, 3 May 2018

How Falkayn Did It

(Beta Centauri.)

See here.

The Kraoka could not and did not settle on planets with suns as cool as Sol.

Antoran has six planets with liquid water.

The outermost colonized planet, Neuheim, is too cold for the Kraoka but suitable for human beings.

Its brilliant auroras even in temperate zones entail an energetic giant star.

Neuheim must be very far out because the sun is not seen as a disc, because there are no solar tides and because the year is very long.

The year must be very long because human beings settled there forty standard years ago and have recently moved poleward as the lower latitudes became too hot.

Despite its enormous distance from the sun, Neuheim is humanly habitable and its inhabitants even have a deep suntan.

Only a blue giant star meets these criteria. Beta Centauri is the only nearby blue giant. Giants do not form planets so Beta Centauri must have captured a rogue system, which explains the eccentric orbits.

Q.E.D.

Tuesday, 25 November 2014

From The League To The Commonalty

(i) In "A Sun Invisible," David Falkayn is the factor on the planet Garstang's for the Solar Spice & Liquor Company and the Polesotechnic League. In "Starfog," Daven Laure is a Ranger of the Commonalty.

(ii) "A Sun Invisible" begins as Falkayn travels solo in a speedster through hyperspace to the planet Vanessa. "Starfog" begins as Laure, with the consciousness-level computer of his spaceship, Jaccavrie, travels through hyperspace to the planet Serieve.

(iii) Falkayn is forty light years from Beta Centauri, which is 350 light years from Earth, in the twenty fifth century whereas Laure is at the galactic fringe two spiral arms away in the seventy second century.

(iv) For information on his destination, Falkayn reads Terrestrial Pilot's Guide To The Beta Centauri Region on microreel. For information about what to expect at his destination, Laure asks Jaccavrie to display on screen a text molecularly recorded on a plugged-in memory cylinder.

(v) On Vanessa, Falkayn has a sometimes difficult conversation with the meter-tall factor Beljagor. On Serieve, Laure has a sometimes difficult conversation with the small physicist Vandange.

(vi) Beljagor would have preferred to be sent "'...an experienced man... '" rather than "'An unlicked cub!'" (The Van Rijn Method, p. 275). Vandange had hoped that "'...the Rangers would have sent a real team, instead of - '" (Flandry's Legacy, p. 721).

(vii) Beljagor denies that the blue giant, Beta Centauri, can have a planetary system. It does but those planets did not condense around that star. Vandange denies that the "Cloud Universe" as described by the Kirkasanters can exist. It does, although not as a separate universe.

Wednesday, 31 January 2018

How David Falkayn Indirectly Caused The Discovery Of Satan

The Serendipity computer presents a "...dry recital, in that windful tone..." (p. 353) (For full reference, see here.) Windful?

David Falkayn had demonstrated that the blue giant star, Beta Centauri, had captured a system of rogue planets;

this discovery excited interest elsewhere;

the Collectivity of Wisdom in Kothgar on Lemminkainen dispatched an expedition that checked every previously unvisited giant star within several hundred light years;

as expected, none had planets;

however, the Lemminkainenites detected one rogue planet approaching Beta Crucis;

several years later, a Lemminkainite captain who had been on that expedition consulted Serendipity;

Serendipity reduced his fee in exchange for information from several expeditions, including the incidental datum about the planet approaching Beta Crucis, which had not been included in the report that originally reached Earth;

Falkayn asked the Serendipity computer about ways that he might make money;

the computer correlated Falkayn's discovery about Beta Centauri and the Lemminkainite discovery about Beta Crucis with the observation that the planet passing close to Beta Crucis would be a favorable site for the production of heavy isotopes...

Thus, Satan's World is a sequel to "A Sun Invisible."

Wednesday, 25 March 2020

Nebular Friction

(Alpha and Beta Centauri.)

"A Sun Invisible."

I had forgotten some details. When Falkayn deduces that Beta Centauri had captured a cluster of rogue planets, Beljagor objects that single bodies cannot make captures. (V, p. 301) So it must have happened when the star was still condensing. Beta's gravity deflected the planets, then friction with its nebular cloud slowed them down so that their hyperbolic orbits became elliptical albeit eccentric. Possibly also, a secondary center of condensation, later spiraling into the main mass, had helped to decelerate and capture the planets.

Although these Beta Centaurian planets "'...were sterile, with poisonous atmospheres...,'" (V, p. 302) the Kraoka:

converted their atmospheres by seeding them with photosynthetic spores;
released life forms that consumed primeval organic matter and initiated ecologies;
thus, created conditions in which microbes multiplied exponentially;
thus, further, made the planets habitable in a few centuries.

This post describes two processes, the first preceding any intervention by conscious beings.

Saturday, 4 December 2021

Mentioning Previous Installments

A series gathers momentum as it gains new installments. In From Russia, With Love, Bond's enemies summarize his cases to date, only four at this early stage: Le Chiffre, Mr. Big, Hugo Drax and some diamond smugglers.

When van Rijn interviews Falkayn, he mentions what the latter did on Ivanhoe but not what he did at Beta Centauri because that story, although set earlier, had not been written yet. Later, the Serendipity computer tells Falkayn:
 
"'Your name is associated with a number of accounts in these data banks, most notably the episodes involving Beta Centauri, Ikrananka, and Merseia.'"
-Satan's World, III, p. 349.
 
The less notable will include Ivanhoe and some others that we do not know about and that does summarize Falkayn's career to date. After Satan's World, he will appear only in "Lodestar" and Mirkheim. Although it feels like it should be more, all that significance and substance is concentrated into these seven installments.

Sunday, 6 November 2016

Conversations Before War

The Terran Empire and the Domain of Ythri are about to go to war. How better to dramatize this and to inform the readers than through several conversations? On Avalon in the Domain:

Second Marchwarden of the Lauran System Daniel Holm speaks by phone screen with his son, Christopher, who explains that, as Arinnian, he must fare to his choth to attend a Khruath;

Arinnian and Eyath see an orbiting guardian satellite;

First Marchwarden of the Lauran System Ferune of Mistwood Choth, newly returned from Ythri, consults with Holm in the Admiralty building in the city of Gray;

Christopher Holm consults Tabitha Falkayn because his regional Khruath has decided that western Corona and northern Oronesia must jointly defend the Hesperian Sea;

Vodan tells Eyath that they will not become betrothed until after the war.

On the Imperial colony planet of Esperance, Ekrem Saracoglu, governor of Sector Pacis, meets the daughter of Fleet Admiral Juan de Jesus Cajal y Palomares who has come from Nuevo Mexico to be her widowed father's official hostess. The governor mentions the Antoranite-Kraokan civilization at Beta Centauri, Dathyna (now under Ythri) and Merseia.

Ythri, Avalon, Beta Centauri, Dathyna and Merseia have appeared in earlier installments of the Technic History as have characters from Esperance and Nuevo Mexico. We have also seen Terra although not yet in its Imperial glory.

What a future history!

Saturday, 21 April 2012

Unusual Heavenly Bodies

In Poul Anderson's History of Technic Civilization:

Planets
Jupiter has solid land masses because that was a reasonable assumption when Anderson wrote about it.
Diomedes' poles are in the ecliptic plane. Each spends half the year in winter and night. Intelligent Diomedeans are winged migrators.
Although the planet Woden has two and a half Terran gravities, its sun is so energetic that Wodenite life can grow massive.
Tidal action has forced one hemisphere of the small, eccentrically orbiting, librating planet Ikrananka to face its red dwarf sun but such slow rotation generates a weak magnetic field so that the planet retains an atmosphere although most of its water has frozen on the cold side making the warm side a slowly deteriorating desert whose inhabitants, struggling for survival in their season-less, rhythm-less environment, regard nature as hostile, believing in demons but not in gods, whereas dwellers on the edge of the Twilight Zone with rain, snow, day, night and constellations, more conventionally believe in an annually dying and rising god and a single devil whose power can be neutralized. The latter are easier to trade with.
Pressure and temperature gradients on Daedalus refract light around the curve of the planet so that there is no horizon. Sunset is a ring of fire.
Nike is very small but holds an atmosphere and biosphere because it is so old that its weak gravity has had enough time to pull heavier elements into an atmosphere-generating solid core. Age explains its sun's variability which adversely affects Nikean weather.


Giant Stars and Rogue Planets
The red giant Betelgeuse has planets, some of them with life, because that was a reasonable assumption when Anderson wrote about it.
David Falkayn brags of finding a rogue (sunless) planet between Tau Ceti and 70 Ophiuchi although this adventure really happened to someone else.
The Merseians keep a base on Vorida, a rogue planet in the Betelgeuse sector.
The rogue planet Satan bypassing the blue giant Beta Crucis in a hyperbolic orbit becomes a base for the industrially valuable transformation of elements into heavier isotopes when its cryosphere becomes atmosphere and hydrosphere, coolants for heat waste.
A condensing giant star's gravity prevents the condensation of planets but nebular friction around the condensing blue giant Beta Centauri converted the hyperbolic orbits of a cluster of passing rogue planets into eccentric elliptical orbits.
A rogue planet hitting the star Saxo causes it to explode destroying its planets, including the inhabited Starkad.


Giant Planets and Eccentric Orbits
The captured planets of the blue giant Beta Centauri have eccentric orbits. See above.
Another star passing near Siekh skews its planets' orbits. The planet Talwin's distance from Siekh varies from 0.87 to 2.62 astronomical units. Huge ice caps form and melt each twice Terran year. There are floods and rain storms. One intelligent race hibernates in caves. Another estivates at sea. They do not meet.
In the Cerulian system, resonance with the jovoid planet Ogre has multiplied perturbation and brought the eccentricity of the terrestroid Vixen's orbit close to one-half so that, with a 24 degree axial tilt and midsummer nearly at periastron, once every eighteen month year the northern hemisphere is scorched with four times the radiation that Terra receives from Sol - snow melts, rivers overflow, lakes bake dry, storms rage, fires break out, erosion prevents mountain formation, hot wind blows dust and ash across dry plains.
A subjovian planet, which lost most of its lighter gasses when an eccentrically orbiting moon crashed on it, now has 15 Terran masses concentrated in a solid globe called Paradox but 8% of its atmosphere remains helium which diffuses through any material, ruining unprotected equipment.
The Cloud Universe globular cluster's eccentric orbit passes through dense clouds near the galactic centre, gathering gas and dust which condense into heavy-metal-rich stars and planets.


Supernovae
When a superjovian planet of 1500 terrestrial masses orbits a star that goes supernova, the planetary core, now called Mirkheim, survives coated in valuable supermetals which are impossibly expensive to synthesize.
The massive star Valenderay, older than normal for its type in its region, must have come from elsewhere. Its supernova explosion will cause ecological disaster on the planet Merseia a parsec away unless artificial force screens protect the planet.
A nearby supernova causes a superjovian planet of 3000 Terrestrial masses to lose all its hydrogen and helium, over 90% of its mass, transforming it into Ramnu, a glacial globe of 310 Terrestrial masses, later inhabited by small, intelligent gliders.
A peak of radiation from the planet Dathyna's massive, metal-rich, irregularly variable sun, which probably condensed near a recent supernova, destroyed civilization but produced a killer mutation which exterminated the parent race, appropriated its technology and now threatens the Polesotechnic League.
Periodic ingestion of new matter by the Cloud Universe (see above) causes several supernovae per century for at least a million years.


Notes on the Above

Falkayn spells out why Satan alone is ideal for producing heavier isotopes. This cannot be done:

on inhabited planets because heat and radioactive waste would make them uninhabitable;
on uninhabited planets because heat waste added to solar radiation would vaporize the rivers needed for coolants;
on uninhabited planets with orbiting albedo-raising dust clouds because these would trap home-grown heat;
in newly formed systems because factories would be bombarded by meteors and asteroids;
on airless planets because the necessary heat exchangers are expensive and put engineering limits on the size of a plant;
on Jovoid planets because free hydrogen diffuses through materials and interferes with nuclear reactions;
on ordinary rogue planets because temperatures near absolute zero affect the properties of matter and because liquid water and gaseous atmosphere are necessary coolants.

 
Anderson invented several ways to disrupt familiar celestial processes:

a giant star capturing rogue planets;
a supernova transforming one of its own planets into the industrially valuable Mirkheim;
a supernova potentially devastating a planet in a nearby system;
a supernova transforming a planet in a nearby system into the massive but solid Ramnu;
a supernova affecting the condensation of another star;
a rogue planet causing a nova by hitting a star;
a rogue planet becoming the industrially valuable Satan by just missing a star;
a star causing eccentric planetary orbits by just missing another star;
an eccentrically orbiting moon transforming its planet into the massive but solid Paradox by hitting it;
an eccentrically orbiting globular cluster causing new stellar condensations and novae by gathering dust from clouds near the galactic center;
planets with eccentric axial tilts;
a planet with no horizon;
a planet with a very close horizon!


Unscientific readers forget technical details so it is good to summarize them. The explanations begin to sound similar but, in each case, they are used to create a unique effect. Supernovae:

usually destroy all their own planets;
can affect planets in nearby systems;
possibly affected the condensation of a nearby star. 

 
In "A Sun Invisible," Anderson planned to introduce the unexpected Beta Centaurian system as the solution of a puzzle so he had Falkayn mention rogue planets earlier in the story. Thus, it was not a deus ex machina when captured rogues turned out to explain why there are planets orbiting a giant star. In Ensign Flandry, Anderson introduced the planet Starkad only to reveal, near the end of the novel, that its sun was doomed to be hit by a rogue planet so, again, Anderson made sure that a rogue, Vorida, had been mentioned much earlier in the novel.
 
These features recur:
 
giant stars;
superjovian planets;
novae and supernovae;
industrially valuable planets;
massive but solid planets;
stellar and planetary condensations;
metal-rich stars and planets;
rogue planets;
collisions;
near misses;
eccentric orbits;
other odd planets;
intelligent fliers or gliders.


Responding to these phenomena, Anderson's characters:

negotiate with Ikranankans and Betelgeuseans;
let extra-solar hydrogen-breathers who have colonized Ogre colonize Jupiter;
colonize the Beta Centaurian system;
trade with Diomedeans;
save Merseia;
incorporate Wodenites and Dathynans;
evacuate some Starkadians;
exploit Satan, Mirkheim and the Cloud Universe;
study Talwin, Ramnu and Paradox;
live on Kirkasant (in the Cloud Universe), Vixen, Daedalus and Nike.

Added on 12/5/12: A revised text explains that the Betelguesean planets were seeded and colonized but should they have existed? 

Added, 23/5/12: Data on Diomedes that I missed above: the system is metal-poor though not old possibly because the electromagnetic action of a passing neutron star fractionalized the original cloud of dust and gas. Consequently, Diomedes has 4.75 terrestrial mass but a low density so its gravity is only 1.10.

Friday, 3 April 2026

How It Looks To Fenn

The Fleet Of Stars.

We have read about:

the colonization of the Alpha Centaurian system;

the exploration of 82 Eridani, Beta Hydri and HD44594;

the colony at Beta Hydri IV;

download Guthrie's journey from Beta Hydri to Alpha Centauri, then to Proserpina in the outer Solar System.

Now we learn how news of these interstellar events filters through to Fenn in the inner Solar System:

"...few people ever came to space any more. Those inside Luna or the Habitat, even those on Mars, they didn't count, not really. The Lunarians at Proserpina and Alpha Centauri - and now fugitive stories of Terrans at three new suns, whole new worlds, and the galaxy open to them -" (4, p. 44)

Fenn wants to be out there and has to choke back his craving.

Most Lunarians in the outer System are not on Proserpina but:

"...in lesser colonies on smaller bodies and in mining bases on comets, thinly spread across immensities that dwarfed the inner Solar System, but growing, venturing, driving their frontiers ever outward, starward." (17, p. 213)

These Lunarians have far more solitude than among the crowded asteroids at Alpha Centauri. One Selenarch, Luaine of Phyle Janou, Wardress of Zamok Gora, represents the Captains of the Outer Comets. There is more activity in the Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud than among the inner planets and there seems to be none among the outer planets. (Addendum: This last statement is mistaken. See here.)

Saturday, 18 August 2012

The Fleet Of Stars

Poul Anderson's The Fleet Of Stars, "Harvest Of Stars" Tetralogy Vol IV, is the first real sequel to Harvest Of Stars, Vol I. Its action begins not back in the Solar System during the later events of Harvest Of Stars but in the system of Beta Hydri which, like two other planetary systems, has been colonised from Alpha Centauri considerably later.

On the one hand, the continuing characters, whether downloaded into artificial neural networks or re-incarnated in newly grown human bodies, have moved even further away from Earth. On the other hand, there are first hints of interstellar interaction. A laser message beamed from Proserpina to the Lunarians at Alpha Centauri and relayed to Beta Hydri informs the colonists that the cybercosm on Earth:

may be suppressing data from a solar gravitational lens;
may have sabotaged a Proserpinan lens;
had stopped antimatter production on Mercury as no longer needed by the stabilised Earth-Luna economy;
but has restarted production, possibly to power interstellar craft (the Proserpinans have detected signs of such craft leaving and entering the Solar System).

The incarnate Anson Guthrie of Beta Hydri IV reflects further that the cybercosm may be spying on the extra-solar colonies with mini-robots and would be able to plant cybercosms in the galaxy faster than organic life can proliferate on an interstellar scale. The scene is set for a potentially galactic conflict albeit at sublight speeds. Guthrie has been working on a shipyard project while his partner visits one of their sons, his wife and children on another continent but a download Guthrie will now travel to Sol via Alpha Centauri to investigate.

Of course, this moves the story back to the Solar System after all but, meanwhile, the action has definitely progressed beyond the end of Harvest Of Stars. We are no longer reading of events that are contemporaneous with any that were described in a previous volume. Onward.

Wednesday, 27 March 2019

To Beta Virginis

Poul Anderson, Tau Zero, CHAPTER 3.

The Leonora Christine is bound for the third planet of Beta Virginis, not that it will arrive there. A probe has beamed data back to Earth. The blog also has images for Beta Centauri (scroll down) (for the image, see here) and Beta Crucis (scroll down) (for images, see here, here, here, here and here).

The Leonora Christine operates herself but men find it necessary to stand by. How will we feel about traveling in self-driving cars?

"There was no space to spare in space." (p. 27)

A beautiful sentence:

eight words of one syllable each;
two meanings of "space";
three words, "space," "spare" and "space," differing by a single letter;
the remaining words serving to connect these three.

An approving tick if such a sentence appeared in an essay at school.

Chapter 1 was Stockholm. Chapter 2 was arrival in the ship. Chapter 3 is departure.

Wednesday, 12 April 2023

Interstellar Empires And Cosmic Events

Interstellar sf need not be about clashes between interstellar empires! See Poul Anderson's:

Rustum History
Kith History
Tau Zero
Starfarers
Geneisis
Harvest of Stars Tetralogy

All of these works involve slower than light interstellar travel which tends to rule out imperialism. Future histories involving faster than light travel are more likely to feature interstellar empires. Despite his much smaller output, James Blish has more such empires than Anderson. Blish argued that interstellar distances meant that such conflicts could remain inconclusive.

Blish's "This Earth of Hours" ends as conflict is about to begin between the telepathic Central Empire and the Terrestrial Matriarchy.

Blish's second Jack Loftus novel ends as conflict is about to begin between the Heart Stars and a new alliance led by Earthmen, dolphins and energy beings called Angels.

In Blish's "A Style in Treason," there is a long term stand-off between the Green Exarchy and High Earth.

In Blish's Cities in Flight, Arm II of the galaxy is successively ruled by an unnamed civilization, by the Vegan Tyranny, by the Earthman culture and by the Web of Hercules. While Earth is ascendant, it favours interstellar trade by flying cities as against several interstellar empires proclaimed by rebel Admirals etc.

In Anderson's Technic History, the Terran Empire and the Merseian Roidhunate wear each other out so that neither of them is still around in a story set several centuries later.

Anderson also focuses on cosmic events:

Beta Centauri captures rogue planets;
a rogue planet orbits close to Beta Crucis;
a supernova covers a planetary core with supermetals;
a rogue planet impacts the star Saxo;
another star passes through the system of Siekh, disrupting planetary orbits;
a supernova blasts the hydrogen and helium away from a super-Jovian planet;
a globular cluster on an eccentric orbit between the galactic centre and the rim periodically gathers interstellar matter which condenses into new stars whose close proximity causes intense radiation and frequent novae. 

The Beta Crucis rogue, the supermetals planet and the globular cluster are sources of immense wealth.

Anderson excels with these events.

Sunday, 5 December 2021

Mercantilism And Astronomy

Satan's World.

David Falkayn's discovery that the nebula which condensed into Beta Centauri slowed down by friction and captured a system of rogue planets inspired the Lemminkainenian search that discovered a rogue planet falling toward Beta Crucis.

Falkayn's inquiry with the Serendipity computer disclosed the industrial value of a rogue falling past Beta Crucis.

Falkayn hypothesized, sought and discovered the even more valuable planet, Mirkheim.

These are his specifically astronomical achievements, Polesotechnic League equivalents of discovering a new oil field or gold mine.

Wednesday, 12 June 2024

Fictional And Real Astronomical Objects

The rogue planet, Satan, orbits around Beta Crucis and back out.

In "Lodestar," the trade pioneer crew is on the planet Tametha. The nearest major League base is on Irumclaw which, later, is on the Terran frontier of the Betelgeuse sector. When leaving Tametha, Falkayn looks at the Crab Nebula which is over a thousand parsecs away.

We are trying to get some sense of where Poul Anderson's fictional locations are in relation to each other and also to real astronomical objects. So far, in our comparisons, the real objects, working backward for convenience, have been:

the Crab Nebula
Betelgeuse
Orion
Taurus
Rigel
Alpha Crucis
Beta Crucis
Beta Centauri
Antares
Hercules
Arcturus
Pegasus
Lupus
the Milky Way
Polaris

That is more than we might have expected, fifteen so far, and might give an astronomer some sense of a vast three dimensional space with fictional spacecraft moving around in it instead of just a list of names.

Sunday, 11 November 2018

The Centaurian System

Poul Anderson, Harvest Of Stars, 40.

Alpha Centauri A and B are in orbit around each other;

Proxima, a red dwarf, discovered telescopically, is on a wider orbit;

(Beta Centauri, elsewhere in Centaurus, is the second brightest star in the constellation);

A had three planets but captured Phaethon from B;

A's outermost planet, Demeter, bears life;

B had two planets but lost Phaethon;

between A and B is the forbidden zone of chaotically orbiting asteroids;

Phaethon passed through the forbidden zone and now orbits A on retrograde comet-like ellipses that will make it collide with Demeter in a thousand years;

human beings will colonize Demeter;

Lunarians led by Rinndalir will colonize the Centaurian asteroids rather than staying in the Solar System where social evolution is not to their liking.

Monday, 23 July 2018

Extra-Solar Races

Poul Anderson, The Avatar, XI.

T machines allow contact with many rational species. "Betans" are from an extra-solar planet humanly designated "Beta," not from a planet of the star, Beta Centauri. Their biology and therefore their history is different from ours. Rather than summarize it here, I urge everyone to read it.

The Betans have contact with several races, including humanity, and find that our kind of equality between the sexes is what they are trying to achieve. Other species are not as helpful:

"(For instance, one race, winged, was perpetually migratory, around and around its world. None of its institutions, mores, attitudes, beliefs were adaptable to surface dwellers.)" (p..114)

We remember the Diomedeans.

"Humans, despite every divergence, had a basic likeness..." (ibid.)

However, Betans are not mere surface dwellers. They speak two languages, one in air, the other underwater. Poul Anderson imagines genuine aliens.

Friday, 24 May 2019

Introducing Merseia

Satan's World.

(i) Again, imagine that we are reading not Baen Books' seven-volume The Technic Civilization Saga, compiled by Hank Davis, but the original book version of Poul Anderson's History of Technic Civilization, beginning with what I call the Polesotechnic League Tetralogy, which is followed by the two Avalonian volumes.

In this order:

in Volume II of the Tetralogy, The Trouble Twisters, David Falkayn has adventures on the planet Ivanhoe, in the Beta Centaurian System and on the planet Ikrananka;

in Volume III, Satan's World, his name is associated with "'...episodes involving Beta Centauri, Ikananka, and Merseia.'" (III, p. 349);

in Volume IV, Mirkheim, we see a Merseian and learn something about the episode involving Merseia;

in the second Avalonian volume, The Earth Book Of Stormgate, we read "Day of Burning," about Falkayn's experience on Merseia.

"Day of Burning" had not been in The Trouble Twisters (1966) because it was published in 1967, one year before Satan's World, and thus got a mention in that novel. In the original order of reading, Satan's World, III, presents the first, as yet unexplained, reference to the planet Merseia which will play a major role later in the Technic History.

Wednesday, 12 June 2024

Sectors Pacis And Alpha Crucis

Continuing from the end of the preceding post, Avalon is about eighty light-years from Ythri and joins the Domain of Ythri which stretches across about 80 light-years as against the Terran Empire's 400. Imperial Sector Pacis, centred on the star, Pax, and its colonized planet, Esperance, is close to the Domain and the Empire attacks the Domain from there.

Also close to the Domain is Imperial Sector Alpha Crucis, centred on the star, Virgil, and its colonized planet, Aeneas. Ythri is about 100 light-years from Aeneas toward Beta Centauri. Alpha and Beta Crucis are close enough to Aeneas to cast shadows on its surface at night. I think that someone looking at the Aenean night sky sees the stars of the Empire and beyond them those of the Merseian Roidhunate but am having trouble finding that passage. Part of the reading experience is remembering but sometimes uncertainly.

Addendum: To be more precise, Sector Alpha Crucis is governed from the city of Catawrayannis on the planet Llynathawr and Sector Navy HQ is on the planet Ifri in another system but the McCormac Rebellion of the Sector against the Empire is led by the Firstman of Ilion on Aeneas. (As complicated as real life.)

Saturday, 17 November 2018

Dead And Alive

Poul Anderson, The Fleet Of Stars, 17.

For thirty years en route from Beta Hydri to Alpha Centauri A, then for thirty five years en route from Alpha Centauri A to Sol, download Guthrie is not asleep, possibly dreaming, but switched off, effectively dead. However, he also exists both as a download and as an organism in three different planetary systems. When any of these organisms approaches death, it is downloaded first so that it can function through a robot body and secondly so that its pattern can be imprinted onto the nervous system of a newly grown organic Guthrie body. If any of these Guthries meet each other, then they can also be downloaded into each other. However, they are not converging but on the contrary proliferating through interstellar space.

When the download who went to Sol returns to Beta Hydri IV, the organic Guthrie who sent him will have died and been replaced and the returned download will be downloaded into the download already there.

This is the continuity of a flame passed between candles as in the Buddhist teaching of "no soul."