Thursday, 12 June 2025

One Republic

Rereading James Bond simultaneously with Poul Anderson's Technic History, I find prime facie plot holes in Fleming's novels but, if these are to be posted about, then this should be done on my Personal and Literary Reflections blog and I am currently focused only on Poul Anderson Appreciation.

Fleming's descriptions of exotic locations like Istanbul remind us of sf writers' descriptions of cities on extra-solar planets. Istanbul has Hagia Sophia. Ardaig, ancient capital of Merseia, has the tower on Eidh Hill. See Merseian Prayers.

Appreciating the works of both authors, we reflect that "The Republic of Letters is one," a phrase that I find that I have quoted before although I had completely forgotten what it referred to. See here.

Does sf remain a literary ghetto? Somehow, the description of a real historical city comes across as more substantial and plausible than the comparably detailed description of an imagined city, albeit also ancient, on a terrestroid but extra-solar planet.

3 comments:

Jim Baerg said...

See also "The Commonwealth of Letters", the setting of SilverLock by John Myers Myers.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Thank you, Jim.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, to Both!

Anderson loved SILVERLOCK, a book which I've also read.

Ad astra! Sean