Tuesday 20 February 2024

Imaginary Space

Much American sf shares these premises:

(i) that faster than light (FTL) interstellar travel is possible - a tall order;

(ii) that such travel will become easily affordable, at least to some sections of society, and will even become an entirely routine matter like contemporary air travel - a considerably taller order;

(iii) that many uninhabited terrestroid extra-solar planets are humanly colonizable without needing to be terraformed;

(iv) that there are also many inhabited planets;

(v) that human beings will quickly communicate and interact with the inhabitants of such planets;

(vi) thus, that civilization, trade and warfare will, in the next few centuries, occur on an interstellar scale - that contemporary human international relations will simply be continued in future human and non-human interstellar relations.

Does that seem implausible and anthropomorphic to you? There is a non-human universe out there. What is it really like? Premise (iii) has become a lot more plausible in my life-time but I remain sceptical about the rest.

Poul Anderson wrote sf that accepted these premises but also other sf that did not.

Robert Heinlein, James Blish and Poul Anderson thought about these premises, instead of just assuming them, and tried to make FTL believable. Blish's main future history begins with the composite premise that both FTL and antiagathics are necessary for interstellar travel. Heinlein's Future History has the long-lived Howard Families hijacking a generation ship, then a mathematical genius inventing the FTL drive in flight. In Heinlein's Time For The Stars, a slower than light interstellar expedition confirms that telepathy operates instantaneously across interstellar distances, thus providing a theoretical basis for an instantaneous irrelevant drive. The most ingenious FTL drive is Anderson's quantum jump hyperdrive although he also imagined several others. But, in one later story, Blish as author commented on this whole idea by labelling his newest version of an FTL drive the "Imaginary Drive." 

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Point i, some real world scientists have speculated seriously about FTL being possible, such as the Alcubierre hypothesis. So I would not totally dismiss FTL as a possibility.

Besides Anderson's fictional hyperdrive, there's also Pournelle's Alderson drive, placed in his Co-Dominium timeline. Both well thought out, IMO.

Point ii, if FTL is ever possible and made practical I see no reason it can't accessible to relatively many people.

Point iii, it remains to be seen if there are many planets with liquid water and oxy/nitrogen atmospheres having gravities tolerable to humans.

Point iv, I simply don't believe ours is the only world with intelligent life!

Point v, I don't believe it would be impossible to communicate with aliens or to learn non-human languages. See Anderson's "The Word to Space" and Piper's "Omnilingual."

Point vi, exactly, mankind is a fallen, imperfect, flawed race and I would not be in the least surprised if many non-human species are also fallen. So I would expect humans to have both positive and negative interactions with other intelligent species, including conflicts and wars.

Ad astra! Sean

Jim Baerg said...

A problem with (almost) any hypothetical FTL travel is that FTL implies the possibility of travel backward in time.
I put (almost) in that sentence because a 'wormhole' network might allow FTL without time travel. Some investigators of the wormhole idea find that if a series of wormholes gets close to allowing a "closed timelike curve" EM radiation or gravitational waves would build up in a way that either destroys some of the wormhole connections or preferably pushes them away from making such a "closed timelike curve".

So if stable 'wormholes' can be made and one end can be sent across interstellar distances, then an advanced civilization can set up something similar to the network of Alderson points in "The Mote In Gods Eye"

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Jim!

I sure as heck don't claim to be able to understand such things, but I first came across the notion of FTL also meaning time travel in the third of Stirling's ISLAND IN THE SEA OF TIME books.

And I like what you said about how some think "wormholes" might allow for a possible FTL drive a la Pournelle's Alderson drive!

Ad astra! Sean