Showing posts sorted by date for query curious possibilities. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query curious possibilities. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Monday, 5 October 2026

From Wells To Anderson

In HG Wells' The Time Machine, a nineteenth century scientist constructs the Time Machine, sets off into the future and learns that mankind will devolve.

In Poul Anderson's Time Patrol, a twentieth century engineer is recruited by a time travelling organization founded in the future by our evolutionary successors. The Patrol addresses those "...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..." that Wells' outer narrator had only hinted at. 

Although Wells and Anderson are not the only sf writers to address the concept of time travel, the treatment of this idea by these two authors is extremely comprehensive. This is my last thought of the day after the completion of a rereading of Anderson's Wellsian narrative, "Flight to Forever."

What comes next? (We don't know yet.)

Good night.

Wednesday, 13 May 2026

Knowledge And Understanding

Are there things "that man was not meant to know"? Of course not. Not meant by whom for a start? Knowledge is good for its practical applications and, in my opinion, is a value in itself. We are better for knowing, since 1925, that our galaxy is not the entire universe. (I have met people who either disagree with me on that or do not even see the point of such a value judgment.) James Blish's After Such Knowledge Trilogy addresses the question whether secular knowledge is evil.

Sometimes an author reaches a limit of what he is able to explain or account for within a given text. Discussing time travel paradoxes, Manse Everard of the Time Patrol breaks off and says:

"'I hope you understand what I'm saying. I don't.'"
-Poul Anderson, The Shield Of Time (New York, July 1991), PART SIX, 18,244 B. C., II, p. 304.

His fellow agent, Komozino, helpfully adds:

"'It requires a metalanguage and metalogic accessible to few intellects...'" (ibid.)

- and besides:

"'We haven't time to quibble about theory.'" (ibid.)

So the text can move on to practical matters! (But one thing that they do have is time. Komozino might already have spent weeks, months or years of her lifespan on their current problem. Anderson's characters have come a long way from Wells' Time Traveller and his outer narrator wondering about curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion.) 

When Valgard asks Illrede about the new god, the troll-king replies:

"'Best not speak of mysteries we cannot understand.'"
-The Broken Spear, XIII, p. 92.

Indeed, none of us can understand such a mixing of mythologies!

In Neil Gaiman's The Sandman: The Wake (New York, 1997):

"...there are some powers that no one, not even the Endless, seeks to inquire into deeply." (p. 17, panel 4)

Why not?

Wednesday, 15 October 2025

A Long Way

 

What a long way we have come from The Time Machine to the Time Patrol! 

The Time Machine is a single long story or short novel in which a single Time Traveller makes a single journey on a single Time Machine while the outer narrator considers "...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..." (see here) whereas the Time Patrol is a series of stories and novels in which an organization of time travellers with bases throughout history avoids anachronisms and averts utter confusion. 

In The Time Machine, we engage with the discussion of Time and enjoy the descriptions of time travelling. With the Time Patrol, we engage with the discussion of time travel paradoxes and enjoy the history. 

Although Patrol timecycles bypass spacetime instead of dilating through it, the mutant time travellers of Poul Anderson's There Will Be Time recapture the Time Traveller's experience of observing external events flickering past. Anderson, in the Time Patrol and in his other time travel narratives, fully develops all those implicit "curious possibilities."

Tuesday, 23 September 2025

Grisly Paradoxes

 

The Corridors Of Time, CHAPTER EIGHTEEN.

Hu's group has arrived in 1827 BC some weeks later than he had wanted. The width of the human body causes an uncertainty factor when exiting a time corridor. He considers reentering the corridor and trying again but decides against this when his men show alarm and one even begins to object. Hu says:

"'No. That sort of thing can entangle you in the grisliest paradoxes, if you're unlucky.'" (p. 156)

What paradoxes? Hu's remark recalls the "curious possibilities" that HG Wells mentions but leaves unspecified. Later in The Corridors..., Lockridge and Auri do catch sight of their younger selves but that paradox is otherwise avoided in this narrative. Hu has had some couriers back and forth during a few weeks so he has some idea of what to expect in 1827 BC at least as of about month before this latest arrival. If any disaster has struck in that time, he does not know about it yet...

Saturday, 6 September 2025

Two Classics Of Time Travel

See:

Classics

The Classics

HG Wells' The Time Machine and Poul Anderson's There Will Be Time are two "classics" of time travel fiction whereas the former and not the latter is a "Classic" of English literature. Scholars of time travel fiction will agree with me about the Anderson novel whereas scholars of English literature will not have heard of it.

Although written by an author of genre sf, There Will Be Time does not obviously belong to that literary ghetto. It is free of any of the accumulated cliches like faster than light drives, routine interstellar travel etc.

Can we talk about conceptual sequels as well as about linear sequels? There Will Be Time is very much a conceptual sequel to The Time Machine. It obliquely acknowledges Wells and ingeniously develops the "curious possibilities" of time travelling that that author had merely hinted at.

The Time Machine has a first person outer narrator, who seems to be Wells himself, and a first person inner narrator, the Time Traveller. Anderson's novel has two first person outer narrators, Poul Anderson and Robert Anderson, and an inner third person viewpoint character, Jack Havig. Thus, Anderson outdoes Wells as regards narrative complexity. In both cases, it is possible that the core narrative is a fiction within the fiction although Wells' outer narrator does see the Time Machine departing right at the end.

Wednesday, 25 June 2025

When Did The Time Traveller Go?

We know, because it is the basic premise of Poul Anderson's Time Patrol series, that those who go into the past on timecycles can alter the course of past events, whatever our theoretical understanding of this paradox, but we do not know the same of HG Wells' Time Machine. The outer narrator of The Time Machine reflects that time travelling suggests curious possibilities (scroll down) but Wells leaves it to his successors to explore such possibilities and Anderson is the most comprehensive such successor.

We have wondered what happened to the Time Traveller and also tried to tie him in with other fictional time travellers. Causality violation suggests somewhen else he could have gone. If he altered a past event, then he would have initiated a divergent timeline and gone into that timeline, disappearing from ours. Am I the first to suggest this?

Monday, 17 June 2024

Fiction And Literature

Value judgements can be individual or collective. An example of an individual value judgement would be if someone said something like, "I think that the literary qualities of Poul Anderson's A Midsummer Night's Tempest are so outstanding that this novel counts as 'literature.'" However, a collective value judgement is shown by which works of poetry, prose fiction or drama are permanently in print. For present purposes, I refer to the permanently in print as "literature." All science fiction is fiction but how much of it is "literature"? Frankenstein and The Time Machine definitely are. They are also pre-genre science fiction. The Frankenstein theme is continued in Poul Anderson's Genesis and time travel in several of Anderson's works that we do not need to list yet again.

The Time Machine owes its status, I think, to:

its discussion of the nature of Time (I disagree with everything that is said but the point is that there is a discussion);

its vivid descriptions both of time travelling and of several future periods;

its vision of the future and sunset of mankind;

its characterization;

its hints at curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion;

its final mystery about when the Time Traveller went and whether he will return;

its poetic descriptions of the past ages when he might have gone.

Enthusiasts for time travel fiction rightly value Poul Anderson's several contributions to this sub-genre although these works have not become "literature."

Tuesday, 7 November 2023

Through Time And Into The Future With Wells And Anderson

HG Wells' solitary Time Traveller seated on his single Time Machine, hurtling through tomorrow into futurity, then returning to the same day but to the opposite corner of his laboratory because the Morlocks will move the Machine from a lawn to inside the White Sphinx in 802,701 A.D., suggests:

"...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..."
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 3, p. 17 -

- whereas Poul Anderson's thousands of Time Patrol agents seated on their mass-produced timecycles, appearing and disappearing throughout history and prehistory, guard time against anachronism and confusion. The Time Traveller suggested a problem that the Time Patrol addresses. Before the Nine, the Neldorians, the Exaltationists, individual time criminals or personal causal nexuses was the original Time Traveller - albeit in an alternative timeline but the Patrol addresses divergent timelines. Its agents preserve the evolution of human beings into Danellians and prevent aberrations like devolution into Morlocks and Eloi.

Wells' single volume of future history contrasts sharply with Anderson's many volumes recounting eight or nine future histories. Read Wells, then Anderson. 

Monday, 13 June 2022

Anachronisms

"'But I have experimental verification,' said the Time Traveller.
"'It would be remarkably convenient for the historian,' the Psychologist suggested. 'One might travel back and verify the accepted account of the Battle of Hastings, for instance!'
"'Don't you think you would attract attention?' said the Medical Man. 'Our ancestors had no great tolerance for anachronisms.'"
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 1, p. 11.

"...odd potentialities...practical incredibleness, the curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..."
-ibid., 3, p. 17.

"'We can't allow an extra anachronism on the scene. That could scramble events beyond any repair.'"
-The Shield Of Time, PART FOUR, 1990 A. D., p. 184.

Anachronism, utter confusion, scrambled events: Wells realized the mess that he was leaving for later writers - L. Sprague de Camp, Ward Moore and Poul Anderson.

Appropriately, Time Patrol agents often meet in anachronistic settings:

"Entering, Everard found the interior cool, dim, anachronistic. Mahogany, marble, embroidered upholstery, deep carpet, maroon hangings, leather-bound books with gold-stamped French titles, molecularly perfect copies from Toulouse-Lautrec and Seurat, hadn't much business nowabouts, did they?"
-The Shield Of Time, PART TWO, 1987 A. D., p. 66.

"The hotel where Cynthia was to make a reservation and meet him stood on the Left Bank, a charming, slightly dilapidated anachronism where croissants for breakfast were fresh-baked on the premises and the staff liked guests who were lovers...."
-The Shield Of Time, PART SIX, p. 283.

"They met downtown next morning, in the anachronistic opulence of the St. Francis Hotel lobby." (p. 430)  

Sunday, 22 May 2022

Everard And Heidhin

"Star of the Sea," 12.

On the beach, Heidhin is on the verge of asking Maring/Everard to accompany him and Veleda. This would have been an opportunity for Everard to learn more about their origins but it doesn't happen. But what would have happened if Everard had accompanied Veleda and Heidhin and had gained their confidence?

Everard learns that Veleda was attacked by Romans but rescued by the goddess? From their description, he recognizes the goddess as a woman on a timecycle? He investigates in the past? From a distance, he observes Everard and Floris surveillancing the island of Oland, then Floris attacking the Romans? This would mean that he had duplicated himself.

Might a Time Patrol-type timeline become hopelessly complicated and chaotic?

"...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..."
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 3, p. 17.

Manse Everard on a timecycle and the Time Traveller on the Time Machine deserve to meet somewhen. Since we are never told what eventually becomes of either character, there are narrative possibilities here but they should be approached either with subtlety or not at all.

Thursday, 17 February 2022

Wells, Anderson And Others On Time Travel

To recapitulate some of what has already been said in earlier posts -

Timecycles are like streamlined, improved, mass-produced Time Machines.

Human evolution into Danellians is an alternative to devolution into Morlocks and Eloi.

Time is a fourth dimension in The Time Machine and, more literally, in The Corridors Of Time.

Wells presents a simple circular causality paradox in "The Chronic Argonauts" whereas later authors, including Heinlein, Anderson, Powers and Niffenegger, endlessly elaborate this paradox.

Wells hints at curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion whereas Anderson wrote the lengthy Time Patrol series.

Wells warned of the dangers of watching the Battle of Hastings whereas Ward Moore and Poul Anderson showed time travelers intervening in historical battles.

Jack Havig travels like the Time Traveler but without a vehicle.

Wells' Time Traveler explores only the future whereas Anderson's time travelers explore both past and future.

I have probably missed something.

Sunday, 14 November 2021

Time Travel Recap


We have discussed alternative means of:

 FTL
time travel
telepathy
longevity. 
 
Poul Anderson contributes to these four concepts but discussion usually expands to cover several related sf writers and future historians. Before returning to longevity, which is what I had set out to do, let us recapitulate Wells and Anderson on time travel.

The Time Traveler discovers devolution into Morlocks and Eloi whereas the Time Patrol is based on evolution into Danellians.

Patrol timecycles resemble updated, streamlined and mass-produced Time Machines.

Wells's outer narrator thinks that time traveling suggests curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion but does not conceive of a temporal police force.

The Time Traveler's dinner guests imagine observing the Battle of Hastings but:

the hero of Ward Moore's Bring The Jubilee unintentionally alters the course of the Battle of Gettysburg;

Neldorian time criminals deliberately alter the course of the Battle of Ticinus but are counteracted by the Patrol;

the Patrol must also counteract a quantum fluctuation in the Battle of Rignano.

Time is a fourth dimension in The Time Machine and in The Corridors Of Time.
 
Like Wells's Time Traveler, Anderson's mutant time travelers become insubstantial and watch events either rewinding or fast-forwarding.

Remember Wells. Read him and Anderson.

Friday, 21 August 2020

Anachronisms II

Anon.
"Missing One's Coach or An Anachronism." See here.

Wells
"'Long ago I had a vague inkling a machine -'
"'To travel though Time!' exclaimed the Very Young Man.
"'That shall travel indifferently in any direction of Space and Time, as the driver determines.'
"Filby contented himself with laughter.
"'But I have experimental verification,' said the Time Traveler.
"'It would be remarkably convenient for the historian,' the Psychologist suggested. 'One might travel back and verify the accepted account of the Battle of Hastings, for instance!'
"'Don't you think you would attract attention?' said the Medical Man. 'Our ancestors had no great tolerance for anachronisms.'"
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 1, p. 11.

Time traveling suggests:

"...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..." (3, p. 17)

Lewis
"They walked about that village for two hours and saw with their own eyes all the abuses and anachronisms they came to destroy."
-CS Lewis, That Hideous Strength IN Lewis, The Cosmic Trilogy (London, 1990), pp. 349-753 AT CHAPTER 4, The Liquidation of Anachronisms, p. 436.

Anderson
"Everard was used to anachronism..."
-Poul Anderson, "The Only Game in Town" IN Anderson, Time Patrol (Riverdale, NY, 2010), pp. 129-171 AT 1, p. 129.

"Entering, Everard found the interior cool, dim, anachronistic. Mahogany, marble, embroidered upholstery, deep carpet, maroon hangings, leather-bound books..."
-Poul Anderson, The Shield Of Time (New York, 1991), PART TWO, p. 66.

"They met downtown next morning, in the anachronistic opulence of the St. Francis Hotel lobby."
-The Shield Of Time, PART SIX, p. 430.

Past and present interestingly interact.

See also Anachronisms.

Tuesday, 18 August 2020

The Time Machine And Guardians Of Time II

See The Time Machine And Guardians Of Time.

I missed the main difference.

"...I don't think any of us said very much about time travelling in the interval between that Thursday and the next, though its odd potentialities ran, no doubt, in most of our minds: its plausibility, that is, its practical incrediblness, the curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion it suggested."
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 3, p. 17.

Wells coined the term "time travelling," since shortened to "time travel." Twain, pre-Wellsian, had written "transposition of epochs." Wells also wrote:

odd potentialities
plausibility (?)
practical incrediblness
curious possibilities
anachronism
utter confusion

More precise discussion has generated the terms "circular causality" and "causality violation." Wells introduced circular causality in "The Chronic Argonauts." Anderson's Time Patrol series is all about causality violation although it does not use that term.

My point here is that, whereas Wells merely hints at "curious possibilities," Anderson thoroughly explores both paradoxes. This is a conceptual connection but also a definite difference between these two authors.

Wednesday, 12 August 2020

Time Traveler And Time Patrolman

The Time Traveler knows nothing of Manson Everard.

Everard knows of the Time Traveler as a fictional character. (This is not explicitly stated. However, the Time Traveler is universally known.)

We know of both as fictional characters (although, unfortunately, Everard is not universally known).

The Time Traveler was the first character to sit on a temporal vehicle.

Timecycles are an improvement on the Time Machine because:

they are mass-produced;
they are space-time vehicles;
their transit is instantaneous for the traveler;
they have one other direction of movement, into divergent timelines.

The Time Machine refers to curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion but does not pursue this idea which Time Patrol elaborates.

Read both.

Tuesday, 17 March 2020

World And Worlds

In sf, time is not only backwards-and-forwards but sometimes also sideways.

When Poul Anderson's mutant time traveler, Jack Havig, visits, then revisits, the future, he is confident that it is the same future on both occasions whereas the same author's Time Patrolmen have no such assurance. Whereas Havig inhabits a continuum of four-dimensionally static world-lines, Patrolmen refer not only to world-lines but also to macroscopic quantum events. The literary ancestor of Havig, the Time Patrol, the Doctor and other fictional time travelers is HG Wells' Time Traveler whose narrative is ambiguous. He begins by expounding a continuum of static world-lines but then "time travels" in a manner that is incompatible with such a continuum. His outer narrator refers to:

"...the curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..."
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 3, p. 17 -

- suggested by "time travelling."

So does the Time Traveler fail to return because he has disappeared into an alternative or divergent timeline?

Thursday, 12 September 2019

On The Other Hand...

The death of the last Time Patrol Academy graduate might occur not at any point along the timeline guarded by the Patrol but in a divergent and deleted timeline. In the latter case, maybe the moment of that last graduate's final departure from the Danellian timeline counts as the conclusion of Patrol history? But then the Patrol agents who had deleted the divergent timeline would continue their careers.

Patrol agents from different periods communicate and cooperate so maybe there is no single last moment of their common history? There is a finite number of such moments even though what is the last moment for one is going to be an intermediate moment for another.

Also, even an agent or a Danellian who has read the entire history knows that, on any occasion when he travels into his past and returns to his present, he might enter an altered timeline contradicting the history that he remembers. This possibility exists as long as he is alive although it can be avoided just by staying in the present. Clearly, the Danellians want to be free to time travel without having to worry about returning to the wrong timeline.

This has to be the ultimate in "...curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion..."

Wednesday, 11 September 2019

Curious Possibilities

"So I don't think any of us said very much about time travelling in the interval between that Thursday and the next, though its odd potentialities ran, no doubt, in most of our minds: its plausibility, that is, its practical incredibleness, the curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion it suggested."
-HG Wells, The Time Machine (London, 1973), 3, p. 17.

Observations
(i) Immediately after mentioning "time travelling," Wells' outer narrator makes a casual reference to a prosaic period of time: "...between that Thursday and the next..."

(ii) Are the following phrases fully consistent?

odd potentialities
plausibility
practical incredibleness
curious possibilities
anachronism
utter confusion

By "plausibility," he might mean the question of its plausibility?

(iii) Did Wells comprehend the extent of those curious possibilities? Poul Anderson's Time Patrol series has to be the fullest fictional treatment of the potential anachronism and utter confusion.

Monday, 24 July 2017

Conceptual Continuities

Conceptual Continuities Between The Time Machine And Poul Anderson's Time Travel Fiction

The Time Traveller:

initiates a discussion that includes the idea of a visit to the Battle of Hastings;

sits on, not in, the Time Machine;

fast forwards, then rewinds, the rest of the universe;

inaccurately describes this process as motion along the temporal dimension;

causes the outer narrator to contemplate "curious possibilities";

encounters devolved humanity;
 
traverses the entire future history of life on Earth before returning to the nineteenth century.

Time Patrolmen:

visit historical battles;
sit on their timecycles;
address the "curious possibilities";
encounter the next stage of evolution after humanity.

Jack Havig fast forwards and rewinds the universe.

Wardens and Rangers literally move along the temporal dimension inside their corridors.

Martin Saunders traverses the entire future and past histories of the cosmos and thus returns to 1973.

Thursday, 20 July 2017

Literary And Conceptual Sequels

Can Poul Anderson's Time Patrol series, "The Queen of Air and Darkness" and "The Word to Space" be called alternative sequels to Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes series? "The Queen of Air and Darkness" is a sequel to Anderson's own Rustum History.

I think that there are also "conceptual sequels," e.g.:

Olaf Stapledon's Last And First Men is a conceptual sequel to four works by Wells because it does different things with the Wellsian concepts of space travel, time travel, Martian invasion and future history;

CS Lewis' Ransom Trilogy and unfinished Ransom novel are Christian replies to those same four works;

Anderson's Time Patrol series is a conceptual sequel to one of those works because -

timecycles replace the Time Machine;

human evolution into Danellians replaces human devolution into Morlocks and Eloi;

Anderson systematically addresses those "curious possibilities of anachronism and of utter confusion" at which Wells merely hints.

All literature is a single long sequence from ancient epics to modern novels, from the gods of Gilgamesh to the post-organic intelligences of Anderson's Genesis.