Showing posts with label The Man From UNCLE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Man From UNCLE. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 December 2015

World Conquest Or World Government

Blogging while rereading makes for a close engagement with a text but also means that I sometimes make remarks that have to be revised. I said here that the Americanist Party was the collective villain of Poul Anderson's "Un-Man." In fact, this Party is the American front for an international collective villain called by its UN enemies "the gang." (The Psychotechnic League, p. 73)

When the world was young and dinosaurs walked the Earth, fictional evil organizations tried to conquer the world. James Bond fought SMERSH, the assassination wing of Russian Intelligence, while his dramatic offspring, UNCLE, fought THRUSH. The UN of UNCLE means "United Network," not "United Nations." However, UNCLE retains a UN feel:

HQ in New York;

its top two agents, Numbers One and Two of Section Two, an American and a Russian - logically, in the new film, former CIA and KGB, respectively.

In "Un-Man," Poul Anderson has UN (United Nations) agents called "Un-men." However, these "Men from the United Nations" oppose not would-be world conquerors but an international alliance of opponents of world government, comprising:

nationalists;
militarists;
industrialists;
financiers;
politicians;
labor leaders;
religionists;
cranks and fanatics, significantly including the Pilgrims (we saw one on Mars);
individuals or groups harmed by UN actions;
some governments;
subverted UN Councillors and employees.

Nationalists cooperate against international cooperation! The "labor leaders" are said to:

"'...want a return of the old strife which means power and profit for them.'" (p. 72)

As long as there are employers and employees, there is a role for trade unions to negotiate with the former on behalf of the latter but I am not sure how trade unions will cope when, because of automation, the majority are both unemployed and well provided for. Perhaps these labor leaders are against not only the tendency towards world government but also the UN-sponsored technology that will reach fruition, according to the Chronology, in the Second Industrial Revolution?

Friday, 18 September 2015

Reflections On The Twentieth Century

Does a Danellian regard the world in exactly the same way as a late twentieth century American? Of course not. Throughout his works, Poul Anderson successfully presents alternative world views among his characters, particularly in the political novel, Mirkheim.

A Danellian says:

"'...the death, maiming and destruction of the Second World War were evil; so were the new tyrannies it seeded; and yet the breaking of Hitler and his allies was necessary.'" (The Shield Of Time, p. 434)

Was nothing else evil in the world or in the international order? I am confident that there would have been strategic conflict between Eastern and Western powers even if the former had not been tyrannies. Also, of course, democracies and dictatorships can make economic and strategic alliances. Thus, the issue was never as simple as: there are democracies and there are dictatorships so there must be conflict between them. Of course, the Danellian does not exactly say that. Perhaps he tailors his remarks to his audience? His observation is of more general significance than this specific example.

Referring to other relevant fiction, the recent The Man From UNCLE film presents a good fictional explanation of how, despite the Cold War, a Brit (Waverley) wound up commanding a Yank (Solo) and an Ivan (Kuryakin) against common threats (corporate crime and neo-Nazism.)