In 4300 AD, Martin Saunders contemplates:
"...the far suns that man had conquered without mastering himself." (p. 189)
"...without mastering himself..." reads like an unexamined cliche. Is it just a given that man can master his environment but not himself? In Anderson's own Psychotechnic History, methods of self-knowledge and self-control are developed. In his Brain Wave, intelligence gains control of instinct. Moves in this direction have already been made in Saunders' timeline. In 4100 AD:
"'...the Council will probably order your temporal deportation as unintegrated individuals. The sanity of Sol will be in danger otherwise.'" (p. 186)
"They even pleaded Belgotai's case to the Solar Council, via telescreen. But the answer was inexorable: the Galaxy already had too many barbarians. The travelers would have to go." (p. 187)
In 50,000 AD, the Dreamer offers to remove the time travellers' neuroses but Belgotai declines.
Self mastery is possible.
7 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
Speculations about that kind of mass "self mastery" are totally unconvincing because the individual members of a Fallen race like ours will always be imperfect and innately prone to violence, strife, conflict. Which are things that can only be managed, not "solved." More futile, hopeless Utopianism, IOW.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
I don't think that I need to re-state my disagreements with all of that, particularly the word, "Fallen," and the phrase, "innately prone to violence, strife, conflict."
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
So noted.
Ad astra! Sean
Well, I would substitue "instinctual basis", but it amounts to the same thing. People are shaped by their genes, inexorably.
Kaor, Mr. Stirling!
Not just by our genes but also by how flawed, fallible, confirmation bias, wishful thinking, swayed by passions, etc., our decision making can be.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean: those are all the products of our evolutionary history.
Confirmation bias, wishful thinking:
I began my intellectual life by rationalizing and defending the beliefs in which I had been indoctrinated. Then I read, thought, reflected and moved to a different religious perspective while resisting any interest or involvement in secular political thinking. Now I meditate while acting on a particular political perspective. I have not just confirmed bias or thought wishfully. I am also still learning.
Post a Comment