Poul Anderson's Technic History;
Ian Fleming's James Bond;
Anderson's "The Pugilist."
I now see a wider issue that connects Bond and "The Pugilist" in a more roundabout way. First, let us differentiate several kinds of fictional narrative:
in a contemporary novel, our familiar contemporary world exists at the beginning of the narrative and still exists unchanged at the end - anything else would take us out of the realm of a "contemporary novel"!;
in some sf novels by HG Wells, the Time Machine, Cavorite, invisibility etc is invented but then lost so that the world remains unchanged (and the impressionable reader understands why it is that he still lives in an unchanged world!) - Wellsian novels set in the future do not fit into this category;
Poul Anderson's Brain Wave begins in the (then) contemporary world but major changes happen and the human race winds up in a transformed future;
in some contemporary thrillers, there is a threat that would have caused major changes but the threat is averted - thanks to Bond, London is not nuked, the British Secret Service is not discredited by a double killing and a scandal on the Orient Express, the gold is not stolen from Fort Knox, hijacked nukes are not detonated with great loss of life and Britain is not devastated by biological warfare.
And here is the connection. In "The Pugilist," there has been a nuclear war and the US is now ruled by the USSR. Thus, the "Pugilist" is set in one of those possible futures that the heroes of contemporary thrillers, like Bond, strive to prevent. The task of MI6, CIA etc is to ensure that the world remains exactly as it is.

12 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
Strictly speaking, the goal or job of MI6 and the CIA is to help defend the safety and existence of the UK and US.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
Strictly speaking, that means keeping things exactly as they are.
Paul.
Paul: well, when things change, they usually get worse.
Kaor, Paul!
Good! Because as Stirling said above "changes" will often be for the worse. The Serbian Black Hand terrorists wanted change--and looked what happened when they succeeded in assassinating Archduke Francis Ferdinand! Or look at what happened when the Germans wanted to "change" things when then injected Lenin & Co. into Russia like a plague bacillus. We got no good "changes" in either case!
Ad astra! Sean
Correction: "...when then injected..." above should be "...when they injected."
Sean
The world is crying out for great changes right now!
Kaor, Paul!
The only "great changes" for the better, when given a chance, were the rise of limited States, in no matter what form, accompanied by free enterprise economics. And I love how Elon Musk and other entrepreneurs have brought about truly great changes.
As for the world in general, the only great change I see possibly being beneficial would be the rise of an Andersonian style Solar Commonwealth or United Commonwealths unifying/conquering the world.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
I have replied about "free enterprise" before and about the kind of international order that I would prefer.
We are destroying the environment! Governments and corporations are not addressing this. Governments are waging wars and threatening more wars. There is a cost of living crisis. Further changes are unnecessary?
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
Free enterprise works, when given a chance. And NOTHING else has.
The kind of international order you hope for is hopelessly futile, because human beings are not going to be what you want them to be.
We have discussed the environment before, with me citing what Robert Zubrin believed would actually work, in his book THE CASE FOR SPACE. And that includes, like it or not, nuclear power as the only feasible alternative for fossil fuels for the foreseeable future. If it hadn't been for ignorant and hysterical Luddites, Western nations might have mostly abandoned fossil fuels by now.
Moreover, the two worst polluters are China and India, who pollute more than all the rest of the world put together! The US, for example, manages fossil fuels far more efficiently than those two countries. NOTHING the US/UK does will even put a dent in the pollution China/India pours out. What do you propose be done about China/India?
We have wars because human beings are strife prone and quarrelsome. IWHBD. The only tolerable "solution" is some kind of big state unifying the world, preferably one of the Andersonian alternatives mentioned above.
The changes I mentioned above are the only ones I believe to be realistic.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
Economic competition will be redundant and counterproductive when wealth is abundant.
Human beings behave differently in different conditions. You cannot say what will never happen.
Pollution has to stop, whoever is responsible. The problem is that neither governments nor corporations are implementing Zubrin's or anyone else's solutions.
We have wars because of economic competition and armed states. I do not want to attack any individual in Russia and neither does anyone else.
The changes that I mention are the only ones I believe to be realistic.
I get the impression of a heavy vehicle that is running along a fixed track and cannot be deflected from it.
Complete repetition.
Paul.
I really don't want to spend a lot of time on this stuff but I realize that I missed the question: "What do you propose be done about China/India?" What do you propose be done about them? If nothing can be done, is that not a major problem for all of us? I believe in the power of Chinese and Indian workers to oppose their employers and governments. That does not mean that I predict imminent workers' uprisings but I do believe that that is where the power lies to change things. And nowhere else.
By proletarianizing their population, the Chinese bureaucrats and billionaires create their own potential gravediggers. And, sure, if workers everywhere do not succeed in replacing present regimes with better ones, then we are all in a mess. Your proposed world state would pollute and impoverish us out of existence.
It is very difficult to address every single bit of this:
"...ignorant and hysterical Luddites..."
Whatever else they are, many of these "Luddites" are very well informed professionals and academics who DISAGREE WITH you.
I could indeed denounce "ignorant and hysterical Trumpists" but can we avoid such extreme and over the top language? (BTW, why has the US twice elected as President a climate change denier, one, moreover, who publicly instigated a riot in which people were killed?)
Post a Comment