Tuesday, 27 October 2026

Keeping The Future World As It Will Be

"The Pugilist."

The Decaturist rebels are embedded in the US military. Their plan is to seize control of the US missiles in order to prevent those missiles from being used to intervene in the Russian civil war. Without any outside help given to either side, that civil war will weaken Russia, thus enabling the US to become the dominant partner in the alliance. However, thanks to the turncoat, Dowling, the People's Republic of the United States retains control of its missiles and, on this basis, is able to issue threats that make the Kunin faction back down. As in a contemporary thriller, the status quo is preserved but, in this case, that is not a good outcome. But Poul Anderson explored every kind of possible future, good and bad. I must eat and get out to the Gregson.

8 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I agree, "The Pugilist" is a very good example of Anderson being willing to examine almost every possible scenario, no matter how dystopian. And the very last words of the story was grimly appropriate!

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Science fiction authors used to predict the future -- near-future "histories" were the rule.

Poul eventually realized this was a trap; you -can't- predict the future. For one thing, emotions get in the way; for another, it's inherently impossible because the course of history involves lots of low-probability accidents.

For example, in the 1980's virtually nobody predicted the collapse of communism.

(Though I wasn't surprised, or only mildly so that it happened at that time; I thought it would come later.)

Note that 'future histories' have gotten displaced more and more to -centuries- in the future.

S.M. Stirling said...

The above is why I prefer alternative histories. Predictions turn into alternative histories involuntarily -- so I do it deliberately.

S.M. Stirling said...

To choose one example; WW2 happened because Churchill was PM of Great Britain.

Hitler didn't want WW2: he wanted a series of short, sharp campaigns to free Germany of potential rivals, taking down France, and then an attack on the USSR.

This strategy worked well until the summer of 1940, when France fell. Hitler then wanted a deal with Great Britain.

If anyone else had been PM of GB, this would probably have happened -- Halifax, the alternative choice for PM, wanted a deal and would have made one.

Then Hitler would have attacked the USSR with no distracting war with other powers.

But Churchill was quixotically dedicated to taking Hitler down, and was willing to bankrupt Great Britain to do it. Britain actually went bankrupt in late 1941, and the US stepped in to rescue her. Sustaining a war with Germany alone was beyond Britain's means.

And Churchill nearly died half a dozen times between 1914 and 1940. He was involved in a serious traffic accident in New York in 1930, for example -- half a step further forward and he'd have been dead or crippled.

High politics depends on the personalities of leaders.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Regarding that "collapse of communism," illusions continued until the end and beyond. After the collapse, someone told me that he would have preferred if "...the experiment had continued a bit longer." All that oppression and suffering were an "experiment"! There were those on the left who rejoiced at the collapse although the mainstream media never tell you this. I am glad to have access to alternative sources of analysis and understanding and would certainly be lost without them.

S.M. Stirling said...

Yeah, Soviet communism was a drag on the left. "See? See?", in other words.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

I do understand the problem faced by Anderson and other writers of classic "future histories" (Heinlein, Asimov, Blish, Piper) when set too near real times. That didn't bother me, I simply accepted how they became alternate world histories. And I recently finished rereading your second Black Chamber book, THEATER OF SPIES.

I shed no tears at the collapse of that Evil Empire, the USSR. Like you, I probably thought in 1989-91 that it would last longer. The failure of every single Marxist state to be anything but tyrannical proves communism doesn't work and will never work (an important reason for that was given by Anderson in "The High Ones").

Yes, without Churchill as PM in 1940 I can see the UK making a strategically disastrous devil's bargain with Hitler. The caveat I have being uncertain Lord Halifax would have succeeded Chamberlain as PM. I did look up Halifax and the impression I got was he didn't want to become premier. Would it have taken the urging of the King and of both the Tories and Labour for Halifax to agree to become PM?

Nazi Germany was too dangerous and evil for its existence to be long tolerated. The USSR was more than evil enough without a second regime like it!

I have wondered what might have happened if Hitler had resigned himself to cultivating patience and postponing OPERATION BARBAROSSA till he was free of entanglements in the west.

Fortunately, Churchill did not die in those incidents you alluded to between 1914 and 1940. It was also fortunate his political career was not wrecked by the Gallipoli fiasco (as alluded to in "Losers' Night").

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

Disagree.

Paul.