Tuesday, 27 October 2026

Good Guys, Bad Guys

Popular fiction is usually unambiguous and unequivocal about who are the good guys and who are the bad guys. If our hero works for the government, then the rebels are the bad guys. If our hero is a rebel, then the government are the bad guys. 

However, in Poul Anderson's Technic History, we are with some characters against the Terran Empire and with others for it. The Day Of Their Return sympathetically presents both the government guy, Desai, and the rebel, Frederiksen, and we have to read to the end to find out what happens.

In his opening novel, Casino Royale, James Bond has an existential crisis and wonders which side is good and which is bad but, by the end, he has identified SMERSH as the bad guys and that defines the rest of the series although, when he has to prevent arms from getting to Castro:

"He hadn't wanted to do the job. If anything, his sympathies were with the rebels..."
-Ian Fleming, "A Quantum of Solace" IN Fleming, For Your Eyes Only (London, 1964), pp. 84-108 AT p. 85.

In Anderson's "The Pugilist," the first person narrator, a rebel, changes sides and does not, as we might have expected, change back again. The rebel leader is that fictional convention, a mysterious background figure who remains off-stage until the end - when our hero kills him. Then he reads:

"We hold these truths to be self-evident..." (p. 126)

- etc for the very first time and realizes that he has backed the wrong side but by then it is too late.

5 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Frankly, I formed a much better opinion of Commissioner Chunderban Desai than I did of Ivar Frederiksen in THE DAY OF THEIR RETURN. The latter struck me, at first, as a naive young idiot who might have easily become a willing dupe of Merseia. Fortunately, Ivar wised up!

And the Terran Empire was the better side in the Flandry era stories.

I remember that, how Dowling came to realize, too late, he made the wrong decision, to work against the Decaturists.

Bond made the right choice: to be for Queen and Country.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Bigger States are, other things being equal, superior.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

I can agree with that, as a general rule. But some big states will be very bad, such as the USSR and Maoist China.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Sean: Or the Assyrian Empire. OTOH, the Roman Empire was a good thing, particularly for the first few centuries.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

Oh, certainly! Assyria was the Evil Empire of those days, hated and feared by all its neighbors. The Book of Nahum gives us evidence of how the Jews rejoiced at the downfall of Assyria, the tyrant and oppressor of the ancient Near East.

I agree, the Roman Empire, despite barbarities like gladiatorial games, was a good thing, down till at least the Third Century Crisis of the Empire. I wonder if Artoriius will try to do something about those "games" in your Antonine series?

Ad astra! Sean