Sunday, 25 January 2026

Detective Fiction

Anyone who reads a lot of Poul Anderson leads some particular lifestyle (in the case of the present blogger, retired) and also reads other authors. Consequently, over time, some other stuff should could come through in a blog. We can focus on details within Anderson's works but can also appreciate those works in their wider literary contexts of the Bible, Eddas, Sagas, Shakespeare, Mary Shelley, Arthur Conan Doyle, HG Wells, Olaf Stapledon, Robert Heinlein, James Blish etc. 

Detective fiction is relevant to Poul Anderson Appreciation, first, because Anderson wrote three novels and at least one short story about a fictional detective, Trygve Yamamura, and would have continued to write detective fiction if sf had not paid better and, secondly, because of the Holmesian influence on several of his works. (An alternative literary history: Anderson writes a long Trygve Yamamura series and many other detective novels and only a few sf works!)

In the course of blogging, we have mentioned some other fictional detectives, e.g., Father Brown and Inspector Montalbano. (Scroll down.) Here is one more before we return to Ythrians, maybe, this evening. Today, while out for a walk, we bought for £10 in a charity shop a boxed set of all thirteen Inspector Morse novels by Colin Dexter. That might constitute my late night other reading for a long time to come. Early in the opening novel, a minor viewpoint character compares Morse unfavourably to Holmes and Poirot. And Holmes referred disparagingly to Poe's Dupin. Detective fiction authors always acknowledge their predecessors. British ITV dramatized Morse and cleverly created both a sequel and a prequel.

As Kevin, whom I meet in the Gregson Institute, once said, "It's endless, i'n't it?"

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

My recent comments in another combox where I mentioned Dorothy L. Sayers in connection with her work on Dante's COMEDY also reminded me of her mystery novels featuring Lord Peter Wimsey. I read those books with great pleasure in the 1970s, and I should get back to rereading some of them. I recall reading of critics who praised them because Sayers gave readers more than just intricate puzzle stories. She also gave them carefully fleshed out characters and mysteries solved by logic and playing fair to the readers and the rules of the genre.

Have you read any of the Wimsey books? Now I'm wondering if Anderson ever read any of them--Stirling might know!

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

I might have read one Wimsey book once. I am not sure. I have had glimpses of him on TV with two different actors. That is all.

Paul.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

I believe her Wimsey books are worth reading.

Ad astra! Sean