Tuesday, 10 March 2015

"Coolies"

SM Stirling, The Peshawar Lancers (New York, 2003).

Is it wrong to print the term "'...stinking coolies...'" (p. 400)? Yes, if the phrase is printed in a propaganda leaflet denigrating foreign workers or immigrants. No, if the phrase is enclosed in inverted commas and attributed to a character in a novel. In the latter case, instead of complaining to the publisher, we merely note that this speaker is racist.

Nevertheless, it was an unexpected pleasure when Princess Sita informed the offending airship captain that he would "'...never, ever, refer to Imperial subjects as "stinking coolies" again.'" (p. 401) Even better, Sita's father, King-Emperor John II, when informed, remarked, "'Damn the man, and may he be reborn as a labor-tenant on his own estate...'" (p. 404)

However, when his heir points out that, "'Those chickens are going to come home to roost, someday, sir,'" John replies, "'With luck, not in my time or yours...'" (ibid.)

The chickens have already come home to roost. There has been at least one "'...suppression of a native uprising...'" (p. 402), in which the offensive Captain Pienaar played a heroic role. John continues:

"'...more often than not, if you leave a problem alone long enough, it solves itself - something governments are loath to learn.'" (p. 404)

The world is full of problems that show no sign of solving themselves! - although they might look fairly remote from the perspective of the Lion Throne.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

The world is full of problems that show no sign of solving themselves. However, it is also true that attempts to solve them from the Lion Throne or a real-world equivalent do not always work out as intended.

Best Regards,
Nicholas D. Rosen

Sean M. Brooks said...

Hi, Nicholas!

Exactly! You beat me to making the same point to Paul. While I do concede that a policy of "benign neglect" does not always work, it's better than trying to sove a problem too hastily and failing, ending up with an even worse problem.

I"m reminded of what Dominic Flandry said in Chapter I of A KNIGHT OF GHOSTS AND SHADOWS after his son complained of how hard it was for reports to make their way thru official channels: "When a fleet can incinerate a world," Flandry said bleakly, "I prefer governments not have fast reflexes." So I agree more with King-Emperor John II and Flandry than I do with Paul.

Sean

Paul Shackley said...

Nicholas,
too true.
Paul.