Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Rheatics. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Rheatics. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, 9 September 2012

Magic And Goetics


Poul Anderson's "Operation..." series began with the same premise as Robert Heinlein's "Magic, Inc.":

magic works and is practised like a set of technologies.

The series presents not any new premise but some new implications of Heinlein's premise. However, the concluding novel, Operation Luna (New York, 2000), changes the premise.

First, new terminology is coined. The characters practise "goetics"; magic was merely protogoetics.

Secondly:

"...goetic quantum-wave transference across a potential difference..." (p. 99)

 - is a new energy source and all energy, whether from fuel, goetics, a waterfall etc, is conserved. Thus, Operation Luna,and retroactively the earlier "Operation..." stories, are science fiction (sf) whereas their inspiration, "Magic, Inc.," about supernaturally based magic, was fantasy.

Operation Luna presents a history of goetics.

The Stone Age

There were mammoths, bears and cave men but also dragons, centaurs, elves and even "half-world...plants..." (p. 126) Dead half-world organisms dissolve in sunlight and natural chemistry and therefore leave no fossils. This difference caused human fear or abhorrence so that Stone Age art shows little or nothing of the half-world. Some shamans contacted it but warlocks and witches mainly tried to control the elements.

The Bronze Age

Warrior aristocrats discouraged any magical challenge to their power but diviners etc practiced their arts and paranatural Beings flourished beyond areas controlled by humanity.

The Iron Age

As ferrous materials spread, ferromagnetism cancelled rheatic forces, the paranatural ecology withered and the Beings began their Long Sleep. European dwarfs withdrew underground because, although unharmed by iron, they had lost their trade with gods and Faerie and their goetically charged jewelry, weapons etc became unacceptable to human beings now abhorring paganism and witchcraft.

The Goetic Age

Instead of Einstein originating relativity theory and Planck originating quantum theory, they cooperated to originate rheatics. Moseley applied rheatics to degaussing the effects of cold iron, thus releasing the goetic forces from their electromagnetic inhibition. The Sleepers Awoke but to a changed world:

"...wilderness reduced to a few enclaves...goetics...essentially a new set of technologies..." (p. 48)

Some of the Fair Folk fled to the Moon. To avoid sunlight, they must travel back and forth between Earth and Moon only during an eclipse.

Thus, Operation Luna considerably extends the story as told in Operation Chaos.

Friday, 29 November 2019

One Very Easy Quiz Question Followed By Speculations

SM Stirling, Shadows Of Annihilation, Advance Reading Copy, FIFTEEN.

Which "...Jewish physicist from Switzerland..." had "...daring new theories...," including "...that gravity was things like planets and stars making a downward dimple in space. Rather like a cannonball on a sheet of rubber, and everything rolling down the slope it made toward it." (p. 335)

And will his theories be applied in timeline (B) in the same way that they were in (A)? How many years or decades of (B) are we going to be shown?

We have seen great scientists in alternative timelines before, e.g.:

Instead of Einstein originating relativity theory and Planck originating quantum theory, they cooperated to originate rheatics. Moseley applied rheatics to degaussing the effects of cold iron, thus releasing the goetic forces from their electromagnetic inhibition.
-copied from here.

Tuesday, 2 June 2020

Speculative History

Imagine a history in which:

Einstein and Planck did not cooperate in 1901;

instead of a single theory of rheatics, they developed distinct theories of relativity and quantum mechanics;

transport was by rail, of course, but otherwise mainly by horseless carriages and dirigibles;

witches were charlatans, not professionals;

Africans', Australians' and Native Americans' practical knowledge of magic provided no basis for any negotiations with European invaders;

biologists had no idea what certain parts of some people's DNA was for;

the inevitable early twentieth century European war took a different course with different consequences.

Steve Matuchek's speculations, which I have summarized, do not correspond at every point to Earth Real. However, I have summarized these speculations twice before. See:

Imagining Alternative Histories
Our Alternative History

For whether dirigibles are safe, see:

Theater Of Spies: Some Questions and its combox.

Thursday, 12 June 2025

Usual

What is "usual"? What we are used to which can be very different from what someone else is used to. 

Two fictional examples, the second from Poul Anderson:

(i) In a DC comic, a supervillain had found himself on a very peculiar parallel Earth where no one had gained any superpowers so that the only place to read about superpowered beings was not in the newspapers but in comic books. Another supervillain commented that that seemed unlikely and it was unlikely, to them.

(ii) In Poul Anderson's Operation Luna, Einstein and Planck cooperated to originate neither relativity nor quantum mechanics but rheatics, then Mossley degaussed the effects of cold iron, thus releasing goetic forces which we call "magic." Therefore, among many other consequences, it is usual to cross the Atlantic not in an airliner but on a flying carpet. I kid you not. 

Inhabitants of those parallels would find our everyday circumstances highly unusual. 

Tuesday, 16 May 2017

A Rule Of Thumb

There is a rule of thumb in sf but it can be broken. The rule is "save the appearances." What do I mean by that phrase in this context?

A premise of much sf is technological and social change. The future will be unlike the past and present. New things will happen in the future and the future begins tomorrow. Tomorrow, a large interstellar spaceship might enter the Solar System, approach the Earth and hover above the UN building. But, if there are ETs already here, then they are concealed or disguised. Thus, the appearances are saved. There has to be a sufficient explanation of why history went as it did and why the present is as it is even if tomorrow everything will be different.

Thus:

the Cavorite sphere was lost;
the Time Traveller never returned;
the Martians will arrive tomorrow - even though, in this case, we read an account of their invasion after the event;
in various works by Poul Anderson, aliens, immortals and time travellers are concealed among us now.

It goes without saying that immortals or time travellers conceal themselves. We do not know anything about them, do we?

But how can the rule of thumb be broken? First, the story can be set in an alternative present - and Poul Anderson did this also. His goetic timeline will not diverge from ours tomorrow because it has already diverged earlier when Einstein and Planck cooperated on rheatics instead of independently originating relativity and quantum theory, respectively.

Secondly, much superhero fiction maintains the pretence that political and economic structures, even including the identities of current post holders in high office, would be able to remain unchanged despite the public presence of a host of superhuman beings whose mere existence should change everything utterly. Thus, their timeline is the same as ours except that superhuman beings appear in newspaper photographs instead of in comic strips.

Alan Moore showed twice that superhero fiction can only be set in a genuinely alternative timeline:

the US wins in Vietnam if it has a superhero;
the Warpsmiths teleport weapons of mass destruction into the Sun.

And, in the goetic timeline, World War II was fought against a Caliphate and with magic. Poul Anderson worked only in prose, not in a visual medium, but his ideas were at least as fantastic as anyone else's.

Tuesday, 6 August 2019

Limits To The Multiverse

"The multiverse does not quite involve all logically possible universes; it involves only those that are consistent with the laws of physics. There is not, for example, a universe in the multiverse in which magic is allowed."
-Frank J. Tipler, The Physics Of Christianity (Doubleday, New York, 2007), II, pp. 14-15.

See my distinction between realistic and fantastic alternative histories here.

Logically possible universes include all those in which there are, or at least can be, red triangles whereas an example of a logically impossible universe would be one in which there are square triangles. "Is there a red triangle hidden somewhere in this room?" is an empirical question whereas "Is there a square triangle hidden somewhere in this room?" does not succeed in being a question.

Tipler's limitation on the multiverse rules out Robert Heinlein's Magic, Inc. and would have ruled out Poul Anderson's Operation Chaos if Anderson had not subsequently written the sequel, Operation Luna. See the blog search result for Rheatics.

Saturday, 8 September 2012

Imagining Alternative Histories

Characters in Poul Anderson's Operation Luna speculate -

If Einstein and Planck had not cooperated in 1901, then they might have developed distinct, mutually incompatible, theories of relativity and quantum mechanics instead of the single theory of rheatics.

Next, if Moseley had not released goetic forces by applying rheatic equations and thus degaussing cold iron, then:

fossil fuels and electricity would have been major energy sources;

transport would have been by horseless carriages or dirigibles;

astronomers would have analyzed spectra, not specters;

paranature would have remained Asleep, concealed;

witches and warlocks would have been cranks, not respected professionals;

werebeast DNA would not be understood;

those who had maintained magical traditions (Africans, Australians, Native Americans) would not have had their head start in practical goetics.

Imagining inhabitants of other timelines speculating about our timeline is a way of commenting on our timeline. I have found some comparable examples of this in graphic fiction.

A DC Comics supervillain, traveling between alternative Earths, claims to have found one where no one has gained any super powers. A colleague comments that that sounds unlikely.

Superman flying between parallel Earths passes briefly through the sky of Earth Prime, where superheroes are fictions. A man looking up shouts, "Look, up in the sky, it's...it's nothing!"

Alan Moore's Watchmen universe had real superheroes so their comics were about pirates, then horror, and a comics shop was called "Treasure Island," not "Forbidden Planet."

A Watchmen universe newspaper headline asks "RR for President?" A character asks, "Who wants a cowboy actor in the White House?" We realize that they mean Robert Redford.

One of the "Watchmen" comments that the US would have gone mad as a nation if it had lost in Vietnam.

Sunday, 26 April 2026

Alternative Fiction

Alternative history fiction is a kind of science fiction written by HG Wells, Poul Anderson, SM Stirling, Harry Turtledove and others. Imagine that a familiar event happened differently and has been remembered that way by fictional characters. In a BBC TV series, a character who was a TV script writer had agreed to write a series set during what to him and his contemporaries was the historical 1940's when the Germans invaded and conquered Britain after the death of Churchill. Asked how he would handle it, he replied, "Well, I can't rewrite history," whereas, of course, history has already been rewritten to bring such a character and his entire social context into (fictional) existence.

Anderson's main alternative historical speculations are in "The House of Sorrows," "Eutopia" and some installments of his Time Patrol series. More fanciful alternative histories feature not just events happening differently but also alternative laws of physics allowing magic to work. But, even here, historical events, Einstein originating relativity and Planck originating quantum mechanics, are given an alternative twist: Einstein and Planck cooperated in originating "rheatics," which led to the degaussing of cold iron and thus to practical magic.

See:

Magic And Goetics

Imagining Alternative Histories

Characters in that alternative timeline imagine ours.

We sometimes draw attention to works by other authors in which ideas discussed here have been taken further or developed differently. Thus, our familiar fictional narratives might have taken alternative directions. Superman, as written by Alan Moore, experiences a scenario in which Krypton did not explode. A heckler interrupts a political speech by Jor-El, asking which catastrophe is coming now, the planet blowing up again or just floods and plagues this time. Jor-El laments the passing away of a noble and proud Krypton - the Krypton of the old comics! In Moore's Watchmen, superheroes in the real world caused comic books to switch from superheroes to pirates. A news vendor remembers that there used to be SUPER-MAN and FLASH-MAN...

Imaginative writers take us out of our reality and back into it.

Monday, 10 September 2012

Alternative Literatures

Literary references become strange when a text is set in an alternative reality. Here is one that remains unchanged. In Poul Anderson's Operation Luna (New York, 2000), Ginny Matuchek's new familiar is a raven called Edgar. At one point, he says, "Nevermore," and she addresses him as "...you Edgar Allan Crow!" (p. 105)

Edgar Allan Poe's dates are 1809-1849, safely before the Operation... timeline overtly diverged from ours in 1901. Therefore, their life and works of Poe are indistinguishable from ours.

However, Ginny wears, as a talisman, a cloak in which Fritz Leiber had played Prospero. (Ginny's daughter will encounter a timeline where Prospero was real.) Leiber's dates are 1910-1992. What he wrote in the Goetic Age has to differ from what he wrote in our twentieth century.

It seems that, in that timeline, Robert Heinlein (1907-1988) continued to write under his early pen name of Lyle Monroe - unless there was another writer of that name?

What would Poul Anderson (1926-2001) have written in the Goetic Age? First, he might not exist in that timeline. Changing history changes the lives of individuals, therefore changes whether or when they have children. In Anderson's "Delenda Est," there is a timeline in which Carthage won the Second Punic War. Therefore, all of history is different from that point onwards. Therefore, soon after that and certainly by the twentieth century, the world population is entirely composed of different individuals.

There would be timelines in which:

exactly the same Poul Anderson exists because those timelines diverge after his death;

the same Anderson exists but his life and experience differ from a certain point onward;

a different version of Anderson exists, e. g., genetically identical but with life and experience differing from birth;

no Poul Anderson exists because his parents did not exist or did not meet or came together in other circumstances and had different children etc.

The Goetic Age Anderson could have written:

the same historical fiction as in our timeline;

futuristic fiction about goetically powered interstellar travel, time travel and artificial intelligence;

speculative fiction about the timeline in which Einstein and Plank independently originated relativity and quantum mechanics instead of cooperating on rheatics.

Saturday, 20 August 2016

Our Alternative History

Our history is just one of many possibilities. Steve Matuchek and his brother-in-law speculate:

if Einstein and Planck had not cooperated, then, instead of rheatics, there might have been "'...distinct theories of relativity and quantum mechanics, hard to reconcile...'" (Operation Luna, p. 43);

if Moseley had not degaussed cold iron and released goetic forces, then fossil fuels and electricity would have dominated the world;

transport would have been by horseless carriages and dirigibles;

astronomers would have analyzed spectra, not specters;

there would have been nothing living on the Moon;

paranature would have remained Asleep;

witches and warlocks would be cranks and charlatans, not respected professionals;

lycanthropy DNA would not be understood;

Africans, Australians and Native Americans who had the advantage of practical magical traditions would not have been able to negotiate on favorable terms with Europeans;

World War II would have been against someone other than the Caliphate.

We may add that there would have been no Johannine Church.

Hard to imagine but possible nevertheless.