Thursday, 26 January 2023
Ganymede
Thursday, 3 October 2013
Future Historical Events
those that are mentioned only in this single work;
those that form the common background of the series, binding it into a single fictitious history.
Despite their pioneering work in interplanetary colonization, the Pilgrims and the White American Church are mentioned only in The Snows Of Ganymede (New York, 1958) - please correct me if I am wrong (Wrong: see combox) - whereas other passages in this work refer directly or indirectly to major events in the Polesotechnic History.
With the help of the Chronology in Starship, we can list these events more precisely:
1958 World War III
1965 First Conference of Rio makes UN world government
1975 Psychotecnic Institute founded
Mars and Venus colonized
2009 Second Industrial Revolution causes mass technological unemployment
2035 Second Conference of Rio begins move towards Solar Union
White Americans begin Ganymede colonization
Venus clans break from UN
2045 City of X founded on Ganymede
2055 Planetary Engineering Corps founded
2080 Corps becomes independent Order
2100 Ganymede isolated from inner Solar System
2105 Solar Union founded
2125 Humanist Manifesto published
2170 Humanist Revolution
Psychotechnic Institute banned
2180 Humanists overthrown
2220 Order now wealthiest, most influential private organization in the System
White Americans ask Order to terraform Ganymede and Callisto
I have not listed events in this pre-FTL period that do not impact on The Snows Of Ganymede. However, these are:
2126 First STL ship launched
2130 Cosmic religion begins
2200 Limited physical immortality developed in secret
2205 Psychodynamic social engineering in an STL ship
The historian de la Garde is short-sighted enough to think that nothing beyond the Asteroid Belt will ever be economically important because:
too few resources;
too difficult to colonize;
energy needed for mere survival.
Therefore, he thinks that the main line of history will remain in the inner System, despite the colonization of Ganymede and the launch of STL interstellar ships.
De la Garde made no allowance for further technological advances. Despite the Second Dark Ages beginning about 2300:
the hyperdrive is invented in 2784;
Nomad culture begins in 2815;
the Stellar Union and Coordination Service are founded in 2900;
the Third Dark Ages do not begin until 3200;
there are interstellar Empires, then a multi-species galactic civilization with extraordinary personal control of cosmic energies, after that.
Excelsior!
Saturday, 18 April 2020
Two More Errors?
The narrative speeds up, presumably because of a magazine word count.
Near the end of XI, "'...well be flayed...'" (p. 212) should be "'...we'll be flayed...'"
In the EPILOGUE, the Coordinator of the Planetary Engineers converses with a prisoner who has broken the Order's rule against involvement in politics. The conversation is recounted objectively, not from either point of view. As they discuss the case, we understand that the prisoner is Davenant and that the case consists of the way that he had handled the situation on Ganymede. What they say fits with what we have just read about Davenant's performance on Ganymede. However, the words "Davenant" and "Ganymede" are not used. Because he got the job done precisely by breaking the rules, the prisoner has, according to the Coordinator, acted correctly. He will receive extra training, will be elected to the Council and might eventually become Coordinator.
I will now quote what happens next as it is presented in two different editions. First:
"They clasped hands. The prisoner wheeled and stepped smartly to the door. It opened for him and he was gone.
"Coordinator Hall Davenant sighed, an old man's envious sigh. Memory ran back over a waste of years, to a night when he had walked across the snows of Ganymede."
-EPILOGUE, p. 213. (See the above link.)
Reading this, we now think that:
we have been misled;
the Coordinator in the EPILOGUE is Davenant;
the prisoner is a young man who has conducted himself in exactly the same way that Davenant did.
However, here is the same passage as presented in an earlier edition:
"They clasped hands. The prisoner wheeled and stepped smartly to the door. It opened for him and he was gone.
"Coordinator Hall Davenant sighed, an old man's envious sigh. Memory ran back over a waste of years, to a night when he had walked across the snows of Ganymede."
-Poul Anderson, The Snows of Ganymede (New York, 1958), EPILOGUE, p. 96.
A space between paragraphs means a change of scene. This implies that the prisoner was Davenant and that, many years having passed, he is now Coordinator. He is envious of someone or something but not of a young prisoner who has just exited the room.
So which is it?
Wednesday, 2 October 2013
The Snows Of Ganymede
Wing-Men, "Complete & Unabridged," is pp. 5-160 on one side of the volume whereas Ganymede, "Complete Novel," upside down on the other side, is pp. 5-96. My rule of thumb for novel length is 100+ pages so I don't count Ganymede.
Everything shorter than a novel I count loosely as a "short story." I recognize that there is in fact an intermediate length but do not understand the terms "novelette" and "novella": long short story and short novel? (I might even have these the wrong way round.) These more precise length delineations make sense to publishers, editors and authors but maybe not to readers.
For both "novels", pp. 1-4 are blurb, Cast of Characters (incomplete), title page and publishing details. The Ganymede Cast of Characters lists:
Hall Davenant
Lyell
Thorval Kruse
Angel-Three Garson
Cinc-Four Halleck
Roberts-John
in each case followed by a cryptic comment but does not include Yamagata, who speaks on p. 5.
The opening sentence:
"Three dead men walked across the face of hell." (p.5)
- if taken literally, would introduce a fantasy but we learn almost immediately that they are on Ganymede with Jupiter on the horizon and the local equivalent of snow falling. They are "dead" in the sense that they will be when their air runs out: prolepsis = referring to a future event in the past tense as if it were already accomplished or completed.
The Snows Of Ganymede II
"'They'll stick my name in Hero's Hall or some such foolishness...'" (p.7)
In his world, that is a more lasting testimonial than a mention on page 2 of an Ace Double published in 1958.
I already knew of the Order of Planetary Engineers from reading other works in this series, mainly "Brake," set c. 2270, but Ganymede gives us the full lowdown on this outfit, which is like the Order of Communicators in "The Communicators." Imagine something like the idea of a medieval religious order but applied to scientific practice instead of to spiritual practice. The apolitical, supranational Order serves mankind. What its members forgo in high salaries, they gain in training, prestige, comradeship and sense of mission. Their Archimedes Academy is a Lunar fortress, nicknamed "the Abbey." (p. 9)
Pages14-16 present just under two pages worth of solid Andersonian future historical writing from "...the lunatic years of the latter twentieth century..." (p. 14) to 2100 AD, as recounted in de la Garde's Short History of Interplanetary Colonization (p. 16). After World War III, both the White American Church and the Pilgrims reacted against "...the spreading of scientific method in human relations..." (p. 14) (The appliance of science to society was championed by HG Wells but opposed by CS Lewis. See articles on my Science Fiction blog. Thus, Anderson contributes to an important battle of ideas.) (2100 AD was a significant year in Robert Heinlein's Future History on which this first of Anderson's several future histories was directly based.)
The Pilgrims tried to reestablish an imagined norm and made an exodus to Mars whereas the White Americans tried to anticipate an imaginary millennium and made an exodus to Ganymede. In Anderson's Planet Of No Return, Dissenters made an exodus to Mars but to escape from a New Christian theocracy, not from scientific society, so these two fictitious histories are parallel but not identical.
Sunday, 26 November 2017
Ganymede II
colonized and being terraformed in Heinlein's Farmer In The Sky;
the setting of Asimov's "Christmas on Ganymede";
colonized and cultivated by Adapted Men in Blish's The Seedling Stars;
colonized and with an underground city in Anderson's The Snows Of Ganymede;
a base for visits to Jupiter in Flandry's period;
colonized thirty years ago, with a small overground town, in Anderson's Three Worlds To Conquer;
colonized and being terraformed in the Epilogue of Anderson's Twilight World.
Instead, other Blish and Anderson characters remotely explore the Jovian surface from the safety of Jupiter V. I am about to be interrupted by a Windows update.
Thursday, 16 April 2020
A Trail Of Clues
We have learned to look for clues when reading so here are some.
As the Planetary Engineers approach Ganymede, their radar detects an orbiting metallic object, larger than an ordinary spaceship, that does not respond to radio. The colonists had broken up their ships for parts and were not known to to have launched a satellite.
When researching in the library on Ganymede, the Engineers find hints of a colony on Callisto. They are told that a small group had gone to Callisto from Earth during the Humanist troubles but was too small to survive on its own so had then come to Ganymede.
Chapter V, which summarizes earlier history, ends by stating that, during the Humanist Revolution, many members of the Psychotechnic Institute went to Mars or Venus but that another group fled in an old ecological-unit spaceship to an unknown destination.
Sunday, 20 October 2024
Behind The Scenes
Planetary Engineers investigating the possibility of terraforming Ganymede have discovered that the outlawed psychotechnicians are clandestinely controlling the Jovian system:
"'Our trying and failing might be what [the psychotechs] really have in mind. It could have a psychological impact, a disappointment and bitterness, which they could very well exploit.'" (VI, p. 184)
To address and try to end the causes of an already existing bitterness is good. To exploit bitterness is bad. To create it in order to exploit it is worse! Psychotechnic science has been thoroughly perverted if this is what its practitioners are doing on Ganymede.
We are able to read more details about the real world that about any fictional world because we are living in the former. People living in the Solar System at the time of the events of "The Snows of Ganymede" must have access to a range of high tech media and will form opinions about, e.g., the role of the Planetary Engineers or whether the Humanists will make a comeback. If you find an alternative news source that you trust, then you might entertain a minority opinion about the probable outcome of a current conflict but the test is always practice and experience. Decades ago, when I knew a lot less, I heard predictions that have proved to be rubbish.
A newspaper editorial anticipates the outcome of the upcoming election. An sf writer anticipates centuries and millennia.
Saturday, 13 April 2019
Ganymede III
has an atmosphere with clouds;
is mostly land but with four seas;
has sharp mountains and sparse lichens;
is inhabited by friendly wallaby-like animals.
Poul Anderson presents more plausible accounts. See:
Ganymede
Ganymede II
Thursday, 17 October 2024
White Americans And Pilgrims
The White American Church:
arose during the lunatic years in the later twentieth century;
became popular in the southern states of the former US;
was a reaction against social troubles and science;
was backed by some politicians but, unlike Robert Heinlein's Angels of the Lord, did not win political power, at least not on Earth;
colonized Ganymede and wants to pay the Planetary Engineers to terraform Ganymede and Callisto.
Terraforming Jovian moons links the White Americans to characters in Anderson's Twilight World, Heinlein's Farmer In The Sky and James Blish's The Seedling Stars.
The Pilgrim Church, which had colonized Mars in "Un-Man," is an attempt to return to an imagined past whereas the White Americans try to leap forward to an imaginary millennium. Future religions are as diverse as past ones.
On the next street to ours, an entirely black church meets on Sundays in hired premises but I have no reason to believe that they are either millennarians or supremacists. That is not the nearest place of worship to where we live because there is a mosque at the end of our street. Everything in the present is a potential seed of the future. Any current religious group might conceivably form a government or colonize Ganymede in the next century.
Wednesday, 27 September 2017
Jovians And Inner Planetarians
Sometimes an author of a future history summarizes by quoting from a fictional history book, e.g., de la Garde's Short History Of Interplanetary Colonization is quoted on pp. 14-16 of Chapter 3 in The Snows Of Ganymede. The Years of Madness (see here) are called "...the lunatic years..." (p. 14) We knew from "Un-Man" that the Pilgrim Church had emigrated to Mars. Now we learn that the White American Church had emigrated to Ganymede in the Jovian System. The psychotechs secretly encouraged the emigration and the government covertly funded it in order to bankrupt the anti-technological movement back on Earth. The plot thickens.
Wednesday, 10 June 2015
Other Planets?
I can think of two. Earth's Moon and Ganymede are satellites but also big enough to count as planets. In fact, an astronomer told me that Earth and Moon are a double planet rather than a planet with a satellite. Anderson has quite a few works either set on or with scenes on the Moon but for once I do not propose to list them all in this post. Unexpectedly, Valeria Matuchek, born in one novel, becomes the first human being on the Moon in her alternative history in another novel.
Which three Anderson novels involve action on the surface of Ganymede? Asking questions is quite an informative exercise. I had to seek out some information even to formulate the questions accurately. I had thought that Anderson's works featured three satellites big enough to count as planets but two of the three turned out to be Ganymede. Then I thought that two novels featured Ganymede but, just in time, I remembered a third.
Having exhausted planets, which named asteroids do his characters spend time on? I do not know the answer to that one. Asteroids are colonized in two future histories: Psychotechnic and Flying Mountains. Do any named asteroids occur in both?
Tuesday, 10 September 2013
The Psychotechnic History
In 1981-82, Tor Books published Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic Future History in three volumes:
The Psychotechnic League
Cold Victory
Starship
The Chronology at the end of Starship brackets four installments of the History as not included in these editions:
"The Snows of Ganymede"
"The Acolytes"
"The Green Thunb"
The Peregrine
Starship includes only a shorter version of "Virgin Planet."
Thus, I have seen on the Internet a more complete listing of this future history as:
The Peregrine
The Snows Of Ganymede
Virgin Planet
The Psychotechnic League
Cold Victory
Starship
This order is wrong because:
The Peregrine and Virgin Planet belong during Starship;
The Snows Of Ganymede belongs during Cold Victory.
That still excludes "The Acolytes" and "The Green Thumb" but I now need to track down The Snows Of Ganymede.
Tuesday, 28 November 2017
Ganymede And Counterrevolution
-Poul Anderson, Three Worlds To Conquer (London, 1966), Chapter 6, p. 43.
Nowadays, we hear global news instantly. Imagine living so far away that Earth was sometimes on the other side of the sun. In some ways, space travel will restore earlier conditions like communication time lags. How long did it take the news of the Russian Revolution to spread around Earth? It was not instantly known about in European trenches.
Somewhere in Anderson's Psychotechnic History, extrasolar colonies are compared to colonies on Earth in previous centuries. Their cultures diverge because of the distances involved.
In the Psychotechnic History, the Humanists overthrow the Institute on Earth but some psychotechnicians plan to make a comeback from Ganymede. In Three Worlds To Conquer, the Sam Halls overthrow the Protectorate on Earth but one loyalist Admiral plans to restore American hegemony form a base on Ganymede. Ganymede's distance from Earth makes it an appropriate base for counterrevolution in more than one timeline.
I am amazed at what I learn by reading Poul Anderson.
Wednesday, 22 August 2018
Twilight World: Epilogue
"Orna of Nildo was a courteous host who wished his guest to see all the sights." (p. 177)
The narrative has moved so far into the future that the forms of names have changed.
"Ganymede didn't have many, but the midnight sky was worth a good deal else." (ibid.)
In the previous chapter, spaceships from Earth had only just arrived on Mars.
"He helped Danivar into flexarmor; he himself needed only put on a coat and facial mask." (ibid.)
So Orna is more adapted to the Ganymedean environment?
They float up a gravity shaft. That technology had not existed before although Alaric Wayne might have invented it.
They see Jupiter at full phase, crags, scarps, a frozen lake and a few stars. Underground fusion plants have warmed Ganymede up to a hundred below and will have made it comfortable in maybe another century. Orna will be quite old before the task is completed. When he was a boy, there was neither hydrosphere nor air.
Collie, on the first Martian expedition, had thought that one day Mars would be green. (17, p. 166) Now, Danivar is from the richest Solar planet, the green Mars, and calls himself a Martian. (p. 178) (In The Winter Of The World, Mars is blue although astrologers say that it used to be red.) Ganymede is the frontier.
Like Isaac Asimov's Second Foundationers, Orna and Danivar converse in gestures and single syllables. Danivar had visited Earth "'...as esthetician of an archaeological party.'" (ibid.) Martians have dug on Earth for millennia. The Terrestrial biosphere collapsed at the time of the emigration to Mars. Danivar acknowledges that Alaric Wayne had established "'...a self-sufficient terrestroid ecology on Mars...'" (p.179) just in time. There is now an ecological restoration program on Earth.
Danivar found a box containing objects including a post card to Hugh Drummond. Having spent a few hours learning ancient languages, he was able to read it. He thinks that, in another hundred generations, when the sense of perception is fully developed, it might be possible to detect lingering auras.
They call themselves Homo Superior by contrast with the Old Humans. The cold gets to Danivar and he wants "'...to go back inside...'" (p. 180)
A comparable concluding story is James Blish's "Watershed."
Tuesday, 5 January 2016
The Solar Union: Physics And Politics
However, I am currently rereading these Psychotechnic History installments not for their hard sf but for their information on the political opposition to the Solar Union. "Holmgang" tells us that the Humanists have an asteroid base and plan a military uprising. Why?
A Humanist argues that:
three ideologically motivated World Wars ruined Earth;
therefore, populations emotionally reacted against ideology in favor of reason;
by applying reason, scientists produced goods, machines, space travel, new food sources, new cures for old diseases and a workable plan for socioeconomic unity;
however, this New Enlightenment has created new practical problems that it cannot solve;
these are mass unemployment on Earth and cultural resistance both from Asia and from the extra-planetary colonies;
the psychotechs are making enemies by responding oligarchically and unconstitutionally to these insoluble problems created by themselves.
Before we continue to discuss Solar Union politics, let me quote a speculative passage from The Snows Of Ganymede (New York, 1958), Chapter 4:
"Seen from space, Ganymede was bleaker than Luna herself - seamed with mountains, pocked with craters, mottled light and dark over her sterile face." (p. 21)
This story was originally published in 1954. Now we have close up photos of Ganymede (see image). Anderson described it before we saw it.
Friday, 17 April 2020
Oparin
"The Snows of Ganymede," VI.
Reproduce and accelerate the "'...physicochemical reactions...'" (p. 182) that generated life and you will generate life.
"'Oparin had sketched that out as far back as 1930 or so.'" (ibid.)
Ninety years ago. So is anyone in our timeline anywhere close to doing that yet? In the Psychotechnic History, only "'...microscopic organisms have been made yet...'" (ibid.) but that suffices for terraforming.
The Planetary Engineer, Yuan, plans rapidly multiplying unicellular organisms that will live on Ganymede as it is while metabolically removing poisons and releasing oxygen. Such organisms are preferable to animals that would need heat-producing cells to prevent them from freezing. The Order can make bacteria and protozoa for any conditions that allow life and it seems that Ganymede does fall within the necessary temperature range.
Wednesday, 27 September 2017
Colonizing The Solar System
When a Planetary Engineer begins to lecture on terraforming, I search the blog for a key phrase, "special bacteria strains," and find a relevant earlier post.
For colonization of Ganymede in Heinlein's Juvenile Future History and also in an independent novel by Anderson, see:
Echoes Of Heinlein
Ganymede And Jupiter
The rings of Saturn are mined for water for a colony on Mars in Anderson's Psychotechnic History and also in Asimov's "The Martian Way."
In Niven's Known Space future history, human beings colonize not the Solar planets, apart from Luna, but the Asteroid Belt. However, a human protector diverts a water asteroid onto Mars not for the benefit of human beings but in order to exterminate the Martians. Becoming extinct on their home planet, Martians survive on the Ringworld.
Comparing future histories, e.g., here, is a fascinating subsidiary discipline within sf scholarship.
Friday, 17 April 2020
Generations And Galaxies
After "The Big Rain," the UN will send a military force to overthrow the Venusian Republic. In "The Snows of Ganymede," a Planetary Engineer says:
"'The Venusian campaign was a small affair. I ought to know - my great-great-grandfather was a UN marine who fought there and settled down afterward.'" (p. 184)
Thus, four generations and six installments of this future history series separate the Venusians and one Un-man that we see in "The Big Rain" from the Planetary Engineers, Jovians and psychotechnicians that we see in "The Snows of Ganymede."
Poul Anderson wrote:
"Heinlein wrote vivid tales of events happening to individuals, but civilization itself became a protagonist too, ever changing..."
-Poul Anderson, AFTERWORD IN Anderson, The Complete Psychotechnic League (Riverdale, NY, 2017), pp. 229-231 AT p. 229.
Thus, Anderson contrasts the historical scale of Heinlein's Future History with the geological scale of Olaf Stapledon's future and cosmic histories. Anderson himself wrote both, e.g.:
"Sol swung onward through its orbit, once around galactic center in almost two hundred million years, and onward and onward."
-Poul Anderson, Genesis (New York, 2001), PART ONE, IX, p. 96.
Thursday, 3 October 2013
Jovian Society
This reminded me of a point that I forgot to make when discussing Perish By The Sword. In that novel, a character who has been faking an accent is advised, first, that "you-all" is a plural and, secondly, that it is usually pronounced more like "y'all." "You-all" is indeed a plural but, in terms of usage, I think that I have heard it used to address a single person and with the first syllable fully pronounced!
Jovian society has four classes:
Cincs are the rulers - Cincs of first and second grade are ex officio Archangels;
Angels are priests, artists, engineers, poets, scientists and philosophers;
Hounds are tall, genetically identical security men;
Sergeants are commoners, "...part of the machinery..." (p. 35), capable only of unskilled manual labor, for which they are cheaper than automation or robotics, with no individuality, conditioned and continually propagandized - Porters are silent and have four arms;
children, taken early from creches, are psych-tested and, if picked for Angel or Cinc, "...never told who their parents were" (ibid.);
each Cinc above novice level maintains as many guards as he can support to protect him not from the easily controlled Sergeants but from other Cincs because:
"'God gives victory to the righteous, but we men can't know who that is. Many're called but few're chosen.'" (p. 36)
Well, that is one way to find out which ones God favors!
The novel gives a practical example of psychotechnic manipulation. When the White American opponents of the American government began to fund the colony on Ganymede, the government surreptitiously subsidized the colony because:
"'The Psychotechs foresaw that the attempt would exhaust and break up the organization on Earth.'" (p. 16)
Thus, the science of social prediction was used not necessarily for the common good but for sectional interests. Consequently, the Psychotechnicians were later overthrown by the Humanists.

















