Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Whimpering Wind And A Slashed Book

Roma Mater, VI, 1.

In a sacked town very near Ys:

"...as sunset smouldered away, Gratillonius stood fingering a shard of a jar, among the burnt-out shells of buildings surrounding a forum where only he and the whimpering wind had motion." (p. 97)

Appropriately, of course, this wind neither roars nor whispers but whimpers.

Finding a slashed book sprawled outside a church, Gratillonius discerns Greek letters, identifies a Gospel and places it in the altar inside - surely an acceptable offering?

Why does Ys endure while Rome crumbles? Gratillonius needs to know but has no sources of information. And he will soon be there.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

That is what barbarians do. And that is also what Muslims do, killing Christians and destroying their churches in countries like Nigeria. The savagery of the Saxons is not new or surprising.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

I'd say the Germanic ("Saxon") pirates -- which Romans said for "German in a boat" -- would be fearful of attacking Ys.

S.M. Stirling said...

NB: the "Saxons" were sort of more southerly, premature Vikings. They were raiding Britannia a century before they settled there.

Anonymous said...

I agree, "Saxons" and Scandinavians both shared common roots and origins. And it was first the weakness and then collapse of the Western Empire which enabled the "Saxons" to go from "mere" raiding to invasion and conquest.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

You must by now be able to anticipate what kind of replies I could make about Christians and Muslims.

Paul.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

Your views about Islam are dangerously naive. It's a barbaric faith founded by a misogynistic warlord who preached it was Allah's will for Muslims to conquer all non-Muslims and force them to either become Muslims or cowed, humiliated, despised dhimmis paying the jizya tribute to Muslim rulers. The Islamic ideal is for a global theocracy headed by caliph.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

But many Muslims do not believe or live by that.

See:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_of_the_World

Read what one Catholic propagandist wrote in a work of speculative fiction:

"Rome was given entirely to the Pope, who then instituted the death penalty for offenses including adultery and apostasy."
-Hugh Benson, LORD OF THE WORLD.

Heretics disagreeing on the most abstruse theological points were executed in Benson's THE DAWN OF ALL.

Paul.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

We can dismiss Benson as a nutcase extremist but the fact remains that, in some social conditions, Catholicism can move back in that direction, regarding heretics as dishonest, obstinate, sinful etc. In current conditions in Britain, most Muslims accept mosque-state separation, are law-abiding businessmen, shop owners, taxi drivers etc.

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

I don't care about the "nice" Muslims you know when what matters is what ISLAM teaches as black letter doctrine in its primary sources. The "nice" Muslims can't deny what Mohammed and those sources teach without being denounced as heretics and apostates. At most there might be some generations of relative laxity--which are then followed by renewed waves of Muslim fanaticism, jihadism, and persecution of non-Muslims. Which is exactly what we have been plagued with over the past 80 years. My bet is too many nice Muslims have fanatical children/grandchildren.

One of the most catastrophic policies of UK politicians, European leaders, and US Democrats, has been their eagerness to allow hordes of Muslims with barbaric, savage, and incompatible beliefs totally inimical to the best ideas/beliefs of Christianity and the West to pour in. Terrorist outrages committed by Muslim fanatics, the recent chaos in France, and the election of Jew haters in the US, are ominous signs of what may be coming.

Nor do I care about trivia like Benson's novel LORD OF THE WORLD. The views expressed in his books are not Catholic teachings. Boniface VII himself, in the controversy about UNAM SANCTAM, denied he was claiming in that document the right to rule France (or any other nation). That was a lie spread by his enemies.

Btw, I have read LORD OF THE WORLD, which I thought an interesting dystopian novel strangely prescient in some ways (e.g., its use of "euthanasia/assisted suicide"). Benson seems to have been one of the few SF writers to take any interest in Esperanto.

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

I care.

Not Jew haters.

Jim Baerg said...

See "A Darkening Age" by Catherine Nixey, for evidence for the claim that Christians after Constantine did much to destroy classical Greek and Roman culture. The fact that some Christians copied classical scrolls doesn't mean that others Christians did not destroy much literature and art either deliberately or by neglect. See the work by Archimedes on parchment that was scraped to allow some hymns to be written for an example of destruction by neglect.

I think one can make a case for Islam being worse than Christianity for intolerance, but likely only in the last few centuries, post enlightenment, when Christians improved greatly.

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

All religions change. Nothing remains the same.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Jim and Paul!

Jim: I agree only in part. What little I've read about the topic you raised tells me orthodox Christians preserved far more of Greco-Roman culture than was lost or destroyed by other Christians by either neglect or malice. Catholics as early as Cassiodorus and Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius (have to love those sonorous Latin names!) were making deliberate efforts to translate, copy/preserve Classical literature in the early AD 500's. Boethius, a devout Catholic, translated many of the works of Aristotle from Greek into Latin. His labors contributed greatly to the first Renaissance seen in the 1200's.

It's my belief far more was lost due to hard and expensive it was to copy books by hand, and the best material available, parchment, was very costly. Meaning that if only a few hundreds of a book were made that made it easy for many to be lost during times of chaos.

You should be glad that palimpsest of one of Archimedes' works was made! Reusing it for those presumably Greek hymns was probably the only reason it survived at all. I also recall how the only reason the MEDITATIONS of Marcus Aurelius survived at at all, in a single manuscript copy, was because that copy was made at the behest of one of those Christians, a bishop, some atheists like to sneer at.

Paul: Let me know when Islam renounces jihadism, a merging of mosque and state in a theocracy, the laws of dhimmitude, Jew hating, polygamy, etc. NOT holding my breath.

Ad astra! Sean