Many of us appreciate and analyze what fiction writers do without being able to do it ourselves. This observation is relevant to what we are doing here on Poul Anderson Appreciation. James Blish wished that Lewis had written more fiction because of his psychological and moral insights. I have recently reread Lewis' Ransom Trilogy but Anderson left a vaster output to reread. We have learned to appreciate Anderson's multi-sensory descriptions of nature and the seasons and his use of the Pathetic Fallacy. Lewis would have approved.
See:
Writing Advice From C.S. Lewis
(The young American writer was called Joan Lancaster.)
3 comments:
There's skill, and then there's what someone wants to do. Lewis (and Tolkien) were university professors, for example. Poul was a professional writer.
Kaor, Mr. Stirling!
Alas, Tolkien did not write or complete as many stories as I wished he had done. Partly because he was an obsessive perfectionist--constantly rewriting his stories.
I loved Tolkien's posthumously pub. THE CHILDREN OF HURIN, which his son Christopher assembled, with minimal editorial intrusion, from his father's papers.
Ad astra! Sean
Kaor, Mr. Stirling!
I thought of your mention of Tolkien when I read an interesting bit about him in the special 70th Anniversary issue of NATIONAL REVIEW (December 2025) on page 30: "Back beyond politics, were we able to move the culture? Occasionally a periodical does, usually a journal in the 20th century. THE CRITERION introduced modernism to the right, PARTISAN REVIEW introduced it to the left. Perhaps the closest we came was our early appreciation of J.R.R. Tolkien (Meyer tried to get him to write for us). THE LORD OF THE RINGS has had a long, slow fuse, but it may be the most considerable expression of tradition in popular culture of our time. We were right to see it coming."
That interested me, Frank Meyer, one of the earliest associate editors of NATIONAL REVIEW, was such a fan of Tolkien that he tried to persuade JRRT to become a contributing writer. Btw, Poul Anderson did write two articles for NR.
I know CS Lewis' Narnia books has its share of devoted fans, but I believe Tolkien's THE LORD OF THE RINGS and his other Middle-earth books has made a far deeper and wide ranging impact in our culture. I recalled how passionately devoted to Tolkien one of your Emberverse characters was!
Ad astra! Sean
Post a Comment