Tuesday, 26 November 2024

Merseians' Limitations

It is hard to find a sympathetic Merseian in the Roidhunate. Cnif is an ok guy but, like apparently everyone else in the Wilwidh culture, he unconsciously patronizes other rational species. Ydwyr recognizes that such species can make a contribution but wants them on board only as junior partners. Flandry realizes that the Roidhunate misses out by underestimating its subject races. Will it miss out to the extent of provoking rebellions that it assumes will never happen? What we do see is the Roidhunate suffering several major defeats by the Terran Empire. These defeats will demoralize the Roidhunate leadership long term. Events that we do not see happen between volumes but we can infer some of what must have happened.

Brief post. Busy today.

2 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I mostly agree. I esp. recall how Flandry discussed in "Tiger By The Tail" how the Empire was wise enough to refrain from scorning its subject races. In fact Terran citizenship was widely available to non-humans (esp. for those who directly served the Empire), with some entire non-human species being Imperial citizens. This all helped in giving many people of different races a personal stake in the Empire. This policy can also be traced back to the Founder himself, Manuel Argos, in "The Star Plunderer."*

I agree, the Merseian ideology of racial supremacism must have been causing smoldering resentment among many in the subject races of the Roidhunate. I do assume many Merseians had enough sense to avoid being needlessly offensive. But I think resentment and accumulating grudges slowly building up and provoking rebellions among non-Merseians.

My chief caveat here is thinking it would take longer than you might think for demoralization in the leaders of the Roidhunate plus non-Merseian anger to bring about its disintegration. But repeated defeats at Terra's hands would also help!

Ad astra! Sean

Sean M. Brooks said...

I forgot to add a comment to my " * ". There is an alternative title for "The Star Plunderer," which I like better: "Collar of Iron."

Ad astra! Sean