Is consciousness an energy field that interacts with a brain and that might continue to exist after body and brain have ceased to function? (Here, I am thinking more specifically of Midsummer Century by James Blish, of Immortality, Inc. by Robert Sheckley and of Riverworld by Philip Jose Farmer although the question is obviously more generally relevant. The Time Machine refers to immaterial mental existences.)
I do not think that such a field exists but, if it does, then it is not consciousness. Some objective processes somehow cause subjective processes. When an organism not only is (objectively) dangerously hot but also (subjectively) feels uncomfortably hot, then that organism has become conscious. Thus, consciousness is a property of an organism caused by processes within that organism which in turn are caused by that organism's interactions with its environment.
Empirically, the organic processes causing consciousness occur within a central nervous system and involve neurological interactions. Whether those neurological interactions in turn interact with an energy field is an empirical question but, if so, then this energy field is part of the causation of the property of consciousness. It is not simply identical with consciousness. Empirically, neurons are necessary for memory so would the hypothetical field retain memories after separation from a brain?
1 comment:
Kaor, Paul!
The HARVEST OF STARS books and GENESIS, written during Anderson's last years, all examined ideas like conscious, self aware computer programs and humans somehow becoming able to upload memories/personalities into such programs. These books were among the most difficult of Anderson's works for me to get a grip on. And that's a commendation, not a criticism. I have strong doubts such things will become realities, but it was good that Anderson challenged his readers with such difficult notions, no matter how unlikely they are. Anderson was showing in his last years that he was not content to rest on his laurels, but would advance on his previous achievements.
That said, one or two more Technic stories would have been great!
Ad astra! Sean
Post a Comment