Sunday 3 March 2024

Speculations

Future histories enhance one another. Although Olaf Stapledon's Last And First Men and Poul Anderson's Technic History present two mutually incompatible fictional futures, both works occupy different regions of that vast intellectual and imaginative space encompassing all futuristic speculations. When sf readers encounter either of Anderson's two intelligent flying species, the Diomedeans or the Ythrians, some might remember Stapledon's equally winged Venerians - or his devolved, then re-evolved, Neptunians. Stepping just outside the realm of future histories as such, HG Wells' two extra-terrestrial races, the Selenites and the Martians, stand up well against any of the (many) intelligent species imagined by Wells' many successors. Martians, Merseians (of the Roidhunate) and kzinti are all threats to humanity. 

In time travel fiction, Anderson's Time Patrol timecycles read like higher tech - and mass-produced - Time Machines whereas his ultimately evolved Danellians contrast sharply with Wells' devolved Morlocks and Eloi. I suggest that the Danellians encountered by Manse Everard during the twentieth century can be described as "extra-temporals," the time travel equivalents of extra-terrestrials. They originate from a later era (our descendants) rather than from another planet (no relations). And these "Danellians" - their name never explained - also contrast sharply with Stapledon's mentally time travelling Neptunians who, when exploring their past, are surprised to learn that their ancestors had migrated from Venus and, before that, from Earth. Comparisons of alternative speculations generate a sense of comprehensiveness.

Googling for images of Last And First Men, I was surprised to learn that this novel has recently been filmed.

7 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

A problem, however, is how different are the descriptions we get of the only times in the Time Patrol stories of the Danellians in "Time Patrol" and THE SHIELD OF TIME. The first encounter was terrifying to Manse Everard while the latter occasion shows a Danellian looking like a normal human.

These differences can be rationalized, as they have to be, but they still present a difficulty.

Ad astra! Sean











S.M. Stirling said...

I'd say the second time the Danellian was deliberately 'toning down' their presence.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

I agree. Altho I have my doubts on how much human beings can or will change in a million years.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Sean: well, our line has changed rather considerably in the -last- million years. And genetic technology could speed that up rather considerably.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

That might be possible, I agree. And some of your stories have characters like the Draka using genetic technology.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

Sean: a subtle point is that only certain types of person will approach human relations from a biological point of view.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

That is subtle and one I'm not sure I've properly grasped.

I also had in mind an article allegedly written by Poul Anderson that I might have quoted--except I'm not sure of its origins. I printed it our years ago, but the site I found it at gave no sources or dating for that article. So I've been reluctant to cite it--despite it making points relevant to this discussion.

Ad astra! Sean