Thursday 21 March 2024

Reason?

Question And Answer, CHAPTER IX.

Thornton the Martian Dissenter offers to discuss religion on reasonable terms like any other subject but the viewpoint character, Lorenzen, declines on the ground that they would never agree which Thornton interprets as:

"'You mean you would never listen.'" (p. 73)

I would give Thornton his chance to speak reasonably and hopefully he would not be like street Evangelicals who:

are unable speak except on the assumption that their belief is true, thus are unable to engage in dialogue with anyone else;

ask us to change our belief by an act of will, which is impossible;

expect us to accept an absurd and grotesque belief.

Meanwhile, like Cavor and Bedford in The First Men In The Moon, these human explorers are surrounded by aliens with whom they can barely communicate and whose thoughts and intentions are completely unknown, a potentially nightmarish situation.

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I believe it can be possible to believe in X and still be able to talk reasonably about it with those who don't. Not always easily, but at least possible.

You have mentioned meeting evangelical Protestants and Mormon missionaries, but have ever come across Catholic street evangelists?

Ad astra! Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,

Years ago in Dublin. And there was a Catholic preacher at Hyde Park Speakers' Corner in London.

Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Good. Catholics need to keep in mind Christ's command in Matthew 28 to proclaim the Gospel to all nations.

Ad astra! Sean