Sunday, 16 August 2026
Interplanetary Periods
Saturday, 15 August 2026
Comparisons And Future Histories
first, with Poul Anderson's "Call Me Joe" because both are about exploration of Jupiter remotely controlled from Jupiter V;
secondly, with "Nothing Succeeds Like Failure," the first story collected in Anderson's Tales Of The Flying Mountains, because both are about the discovery of antigravity despite resistance from political bureaucracy.
See also:
"Bridge" is part of Blish's major future history series whereas Tales Of The Flying Mountains is in itself one of Anderson's eight future histories, which in turn reminds us of their diversity, e.g.:
the Maurai History, set almost entirely on Earth and linked to past history by time travel;
the Kith History, two versions, the second version a single long novel showing millennia of societal and civilizational change on Earth;
the Rustum History, eight stories focused on a single extrasolar colony planet although one other story about one other such planet is also set in this timeline.
This has given me an idea for a post on James Blish Appreciation. I will link to it from here when it is published.
Later: See Sweeney On Ganymede.
Friday, 14 August 2026
Future Freedoms
Robert Heinlein's Howard Families escape persecution by hijacking a generation ship;
when SM Stirling's Draka conquer the Solar System, some Americans escape to found an extra-solar colony;
Poul Anderson's Technic History features the "Breakup" and, in another series, his extrasolar planet, Rustum, is colonized by ideological refugees;
the opening instalments of both of James Blish's future history series, Okies and pantropy, end with political refugees fleeing from the Solar System.
Six examples from four major sf authors. But this is wishful thinking. The bulk of humanity has to resist encroachments on its freedom here on Earth.
In a future history series, the opening instalment is a story complete in itself and the second story begins in a different time and place:
in the Technic History, the action moves from a Saturnian moon to an extrasolar planet;
Volume I of Blish's Cities In Flight ends with Senator Wagoner in his cell on the last day whereas Volume II opens centuries later with Crispin deFord waiting to watch the city of Scranton leave Earth (and, if we have read this series in publication order, then we already know deFord's fate);
Book One of Blish's The Seedling Stars ends with Sweeney on Ganymede whereas Book Two opens in a completely different milieu with Honath the Purse-Maker...
As James Blish once said, we grew up with science fiction...
Thursday, 13 August 2026
Some Relevant Passages In Works By James Blish
On Ganymede, an Adapted Man thinks:
Friday, 27 February 2026
"History of the Future" - Poul Anderson
The Snows of Ganymede by Poul Anderson is on pp. 10-57.
p. 28 is interrupted by an editorial note entitled Poul Anderson's Future History. This note explains that Robert Heinlein wrote a "future history" and so also does Anderson.
p. 29 is a chart of "...the first 250 years of Anderson's history..."
The chart shows:
Sunday, 11 January 2026
Various Editions And Titles
The Man Who Counts also exists, although not in my possession, as a single volume with its correct title - Anderson neither chose nor liked War Of The Wing-Men - and as The Earth Book Of Stormgate-2 in a three-volume paperback edition of this collection.
We also find the two future histories in a single Ace Double as follows. One half is The Makeshift Rocket, a non-series story. The other half, Un-Man and other novellas collects:
Friday, 18 April 2025
No Space Travel To Start With
The first four stories in Robert Heinlein's Future History describe technological advances with orbital space travel anticipated at the end of the fourth story and a first Moon landing in the fifth.
The three Maurai stories in Poul Anderson's Maurai And Kith are a future history about post-nuclear war recovery without space travel although Anderson's sequel, Orion Shall Rise, features a space launch. Further, Anderson's There Will Be Time, places the Maurai period in a longer past and future history with later interstellar travel.
The first story in Anderson's Psychotechnic History is set during recovery from World War III although Mars has been colonized by the time of the second story.
Apart from that, future histories begin with people already in space, I think:
James Blish's Cities In Flight begins with remote control exploration of Jupiter from Jupiter V;
Blish's The Seedling Stars begins with Adapted Men on Ganymede;
Blish's Haertel Scholium begins when Adolph Haertel flies to Mars;
Larry Niven's Known Space future history series begins with the exploration of Mercury, Venus, Pluto and Mars before proceeding to technological advances and social problems on Earth;
Anderson's Technic History begins with the exploration of the Saturnian System and specifically of Iapetus in the first story, then proceeds to interstellar exploration in the second and third stories and to extra-solar influences on Earth in the fourth and fifth.
This all sounds like a single body of work.
Sunday, 3 November 2024
History And Yarns
in "The Snows of Ganymede," Callisto and Ganymede are going to be terraformed;
in "Brake," Europa is going to be terraformed;
in "The Acolytes," Wilson Pete's father, an engineer, has:
"'...been assigned to a project on Sol VIII.'" (p. 6)
- i.e., on Neptune.
Thus, human activity expands out through the Solar System.
By the same token:
in "The Big Rain," Venus is being terraformed;
in "Cold Victory," Venus has been terraformed;
in "The Acolytes," Stellamont, the only city on Nerthus, is a few buildings on a broad plain;
in The Peregrine, Stellamont has grown much bigger and has even acquired a native section. See here.
History happens.
Wilson Pete is ten. His uncle, Thorleifsson Gunnar, has a blue, bald Javartenanian servant, Tobur, who tells Pete fine stories. Tobur has been with Gunnar since leaving Javartenan yet has been on many planets that Gunnar never mentions:
"...and he wouldn't lie to a fellow." (p. 11)
We return to the ambiguity of the yarn.
Thursday, 24 October 2024
The THUNDERBOLT And Her Passengers
On p. 219, the Planetary Engineer, Luke Devon, quotes Hamlet.
On p. 220, Banning deduces that Devon is a Rostomily Brother although we have to have read the earlier story, "Un-Man," to make much sense of Banning's reflections on that earlier period when the embattled UN world government had been defended by Un-men including Rostomily clones.
Engineers began to terraform Ganymede and Callisto in "The Snows of Ganymede." Now, Devon takes terraforming equipment to Europa.
In conversation with Serge Andreyev, Devon summarizes much information for the readers' benefit:
the Thunderbolt is a large spaceship;
she is beyond Mars en route to Jupiter;
there are fifteen people, crew or passengers, on board.
Banning lists the passengers:
Cleonie Rogers, tourist;
Devon, the Engineer;
Andreyev, Solar Union bureaucrat sent to negotiate a trade agreement;
Robert Falken, nucleonic technician accepting a job offer on Callisto;
Morgan Gentry, astronaut, hired to pilot inter-satellite shuttles in the Jovian Republic;
Gomez, professor of advanced symbolics, starting a position at the new University of X.
There was an X on Ganymede before but not a University: the familiar combination of history and change.
After Andreyev has pulled a gun on Devon, Banning regards the other passengers with suspicion.
Wednesday, 23 October 2024
Avalon
A Ganymedean Outlaw assesses a Planetary Engineer's spacesuit:
"'Not Ganny make,' he said. 'Mebbe they be really from Earth.' He spoke as a man at home might have spoken of Avalon." (VIII, p. 198)
In 2024, we reread a story published in 1955. This generates two chronological perspectives. First, a story published in any given year obviously might refer to works published earlier than that year. Secondly, we now regard 1955 as a long way in the past and therefore can reflect, e.g., on what that same author wrote after that.
Avalon is part of our history whether we are in 1955 or in 2024. For an incursion of Arthurian myth into modern sf, read CS Lewis' The Hideous Strength, where Avalon becomes Abhalljin or Aphalljin in Perelandra, i.e., on Venus.
Secondly, everyone here knows that Avalon is the name of a major planet in Poul Anderson's second future history series, the Technic History. This "Avalon," written in 1973, exists not only in a later period but also in a different timeline than "The Snows of Ganymede." Rereading "The Snows...," we automatically think of the Technic History Avalon although obviously Anderson cannot possibly have intended that back then. Some connotations are retro-.
Power-Beaming And John Milton
Each future history instalment builds on the foundations of earlier instalments. Thus, power-beaming technology is developed in "Holmgang" and crucially contributes to the climax of "The Snows of Ganymede."
Sometimes Biblical quotations are supplemented by other literary quotations. Thus:
"'They also serve who only stand and wait...'" (IX, p. 206)
I think that we all know it but where is it from?
When I consider how my light is spent, Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide, And that one Talent which is death to hide Lodged with me useless, though my Soul more bentTo serve therewith my Maker, and present My true account, lest he returning chide; “Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?” I fondly ask. But patience, to preventThat murmur, soon replies, “God doth not need Either man’s work or his own gifts; who best Bear his mild yoke, they serve him best. His stateIs Kingly. Thousands at his bidding speed And post o’er Land and Ocean without rest: They also serve who only stand and wait.”
-John Milton, "On His Blindness."
The Planetary Engineers speed and post o'er the Solar System without rest.
Tuesday, 22 October 2024
The Subconscious Mind Collaborates
"The Snows of Ganymede."
Although the Psychotechnic Institute has been outlawed, psychodynanics has benefitted the Order of Planetary Engineers:
Social Eating
"It was a shaking effort to nibble sedately at the food instead of wolfing it." (VIII, p. 199)
The dignity of the Planetary Engineers must be preserved even when they are guests of barbarian Ganymedean Outlaws. This is another sentence on which I will hang some remarks that are more about life than about Poul Anderson's text. But fiction is about life. In fact, I can make a comparison between the Order of Planetary Engineers and the Order of Buddhist Contemplatives.
Brother Wilfrid told us that he refrained from eating sandwiches in front of other rail passengers because, being hungry, he might have eaten them hungrily. He was conscious of his public image. A monk should not seem to act from greed, hate or delusion - in this case, greed.
Also, once again on the train, Wilfrid experienced hostility from a drunken football supporter whose team had lost a match. Wilfrid's monastic garb and appearance antagonized the drunk. Wilfrid decided, while travelling, to conceal his habit under an overcoat and his shaven head under a woolen cap because a drunken football supporter whose team has lost a match has a right not to be abruptly confronted with the fact of organized religion if he doesn't want to be.
On Ganymede
Snow on the ground is ammonia crystals. Shadows are hard and sharp. Amber Jupiter light sparkles on solid ammonia fields, flashes off ice glaciers and drowns out any stars in that part of the sky. When Jupiter is full, it allows full colour vision. Walking is a long glide. Thin air makes objects seem close but the near horizon makes them seem far. Spacesuit failure causes choking, exploding or rapid freezing. Most of the city, seen in earlier chapters, is underground. Outlaws live behind airlocks in natural caves and tunnels, lit, heated and ventilated, and range far because they cache oxygen bottles.
The information in the text is succinct but conveys a sense of what it must be like to be there.
Monday, 21 October 2024
Half An Hour
The two surviving Engineers, Davenant and Kruse, are in spacesuits on Ganymede with only half an hour of oxygen left:
"They could stretch out their lives by sitting still, but there was no point to that." (VII, p. 190)
There would be a point if it were known for sure that there was nowhere for them to walk to and therefore that all that remained to them was to spend their remaining short span of consciousness in recollection, reflection or contemplation. However, if there is the remotest possibility of walking to a source of oxygen, then they need to keep moving while maybe, if they want to and are able to, remaining recollected, reflective etc. I do not know how I would respond. I do know that I have thought that I would respond in one particular way to an upcoming situation and have then been surprised by my spontaneous response in that situation when it arrived. Decades of meditation practice help. That is all that can be said for now. If I have some meditation realizations, then I might know more. If I survive a close shave with death, then I will definitely know a lot more. Like the Planetary Engineers, all of us face the democracy of death.
Escape And Survival
After the recent action scene: the captured rocket, also described as a boat, has wheels. It moves down a corridor and up an airlock ramp, then takes off. Again, the escape goes more smoothly than it might have done. We are told that:
"It was useful, having enemies indoctrinated out of all initiative." (VI, p. 189)
Why is this? It turns out that:
"No one had thought to cut off the automatically opening valves." (ibid.)
Poul Anderson's narrative imperative is to get the Engineers out of the city as quickly as possible so there is a plausible explanation for each comparatively easy stage in their escape. His next imperative is to have the rocket shot down and most of the Engineers killed. Thus, we return to the opening scene where three, then only two, survivors trekked across Ganymede. Everything since the end of Chapter I has been a flashback. Now, at the beginning of VII, we have returned to our starting point. So what happens next? We read on but I take another break from rereading. Anderson's heroes endure - those of them that survive, of course. I think that human resilience is his most consistent message.
News And Fiction
An Obligatory Andersonian Action Scene
The Engineers are under guard but are armed and break out. Kruse, the good shot from Venus, downs the three "Hounds"/guards outside the door of their apartment with one shot each. As the escapers run down the corridor, another corps approaches and fires:
"It seemed a miracle that there were no hits,..." (VI, p. 188)
It does. But:
"...but they were distant, moving targets." (ibid.)
OK.
Davenant has no time to be afraid. That sounds real. He punches and kicks a guy. We recognize this amount of physical detail in a fight from previous Anderson texts. Davenant does not see what is happening behind him as Kruse and the other two gunners shoot back. Since Davenant is our viewpoint character, we do not know what is happening in the rear either. One Engineer, Falkenhorst, takes a bullet in a shoulder but Devanant helps him along. More plausible now that there is one hit.
The garage entrance is unguarded. Why?
"In the confusion, it was unwatched." (p. 188)
OK. But, if the Hounds had better military organization, then they would be less confused. The Engineers are able to bar the door through which they would be pursued. This garage contains not land vehicles but small planetary rockets!
Protesting mechanics are told to stay back. We are not told what happens to them but then Kruse hopes that they:
"'...stay buffaloed.'" (ibid.)
What is "buffaloed"? Is there some discontinuity here?
That was an action scene, appreciated more for being analyzed.
Addendum: "Buffaloed" just means intimidated. OK.
Sunday, 20 October 2024
Behind The Scenes
Planetary Engineers investigating the possibility of terraforming Ganymede have discovered that the outlawed psychotechnicians are clandestinely controlling the Jovian system:
"'Our trying and failing might be what [the psychotechs] really have in mind. It could have a psychological impact, a disappointment and bitterness, which they could very well exploit.'" (VI, p. 184)
To address and try to end the causes of an already existing bitterness is good. To exploit bitterness is bad. To create it in order to exploit it is worse! Psychotechnic science has been thoroughly perverted if this is what its practitioners are doing on Ganymede.
We are able to read more details about the real world that about any fictional world because we are living in the former. People living in the Solar System at the time of the events of "The Snows of Ganymede" must have access to a range of high tech media and will form opinions about, e.g., the role of the Planetary Engineers or whether the Humanists will make a comeback. If you find an alternative news source that you trust, then you might entertain a minority opinion about the probable outcome of a current conflict but the test is always practice and experience. Decades ago, when I knew a lot less, I heard predictions that have proved to be rubbish.
A newspaper editorial anticipates the outcome of the upcoming election. An sf writer anticipates centuries and millennia.
A Corruption That Empowers
A Planetary Engineer comments:
"'The psychodynamic techniques are only methods for attaining given ends. They say nothing about the desirability of any aim. If the Institute people have acquired an old-fashioned power hunger, they'll rationalize it to themselves, but they'll be as dangerous as any would-be conqueror.'" (VI, p. 184)
Slow down. Psychodynamic science applies to society and to individuals. When applied to individuals, it involves understanding and enhancing the self psychophysically, as shown in "The Sensitive Man." Psychodynamics has to start with both the why and the how of the most basic aims of human existence. There is no reason to exist but, since we do exist, and if we want to continue to exist, then what is the most effective way to do this? Psychodynamicists are bound to understand that a rationalized power-drive is a hindrance. But maybe any mere techniques can be corrupted? That was the point of the earlier comparison of the Institute with the Church.