Sunday, 5 October 2025

Keening And Chanting

"Star of the Sea," 1.

Poul Anderson lets us escape from time travel paradoxes into historical fiction within a single narrative. When Germanic barbarians besiege Old Camp, their women keen rhythmically:

"...ha-ba-da ha-ba, ha-ba-da-da." (p. 471)

Although Anderson spells it out for us, I cannot hear this beat in my head. However, it reminds me that I once saw a mass picket pushing policemen down a street as if in a big rugby scrum. The pickets were chanting something that I initially did not understand:

"Da - da-da-dadada!
"Da - da-da-dadada!
"Da - da-da-dadada!"

Then I discerned the words. It was an ironic reproach to the police:

"Job - only doin' it!
"Job - only doin' it!
"Job - only doin' it!"

Lupercus the Roman legate reminds (some of) us of Dominic Flandry involved in the suppression of the planet, Brae. Lupercus also has something in common with the viewpoint character of section 2, Manse Everard: two men doing a job. Both must respond to a threat to the Roman Empire albeit for different reasons. 

The Roman Empire exists in different timelines. In one, it is guarded by the Time Patrol. In another, it inspires the Terran Empire. The Romans know nothing of either.

The Patrol does recruit one Roman from Caesar's time who:

"'...never got it through his head that a machine can't be treated like a horse.'"
-Poul Anderson, "Time Patrol" IN Anderson, Time Patrol (Riverdale, NY, December 2010), pp. 1-53 AT 2, p. 14.

I did not expect to wind up with that when I began to write this post.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Paul!

And we see a very different Roman Empire in Stirling's TO TURN THE TIDE/THE WINDS OF FATE, because of the innovations introduced by those Americans stranded there in the reign of Marcus Aurelius.

Ad astra! Sean

S.M. Stirling said...

The upper limit of a society's morality is set by its technology. There is no lower limit...

Anonymous said...

Kaor, Mr. Stirling!

Too true, if you mean morality can be very low indeed. I think with disgust of things like "legalized" abortion.

Ad astra! Sean