Sunday 1 December 2013

A Mosaic World

We have seen Wild West, Operatic, Space Opera, Victorian and Pirate Hokas each in their own story so it makes sense that Poul Anderson's and Gordon R Dickson's collection, Earthman's Burden (New York, 1979) ends with a story showing diverse Hoka cultures coexisting and interacting:

the United States Cavalry and the Varangian Guard nearly fought as to which of them should provide an honor guard for a very important visitor but were overawed when King Arthur allied with the Black Watch;

the Secret Service escorts the very important visitor to the League Office which is guarded by a Samurai.

Thus already, we have briefly referred to six distinct sub-cultures. However, since this story is entitled "The Tiddlywink Warriors," I have yet to learn what its prevailing theme is to be.

So far also, we do not see any new marks of the passage of time. The Jones' offspring are still young enough to be referred to as "...the children..." (p. 161) and there is as yet no mention of a fourth. Alex has been married to Tanni long enough not to admit something to her but we are not told how long that is.

A convenient break from child care is provided by sending:

"...the children to the Hoka London to watch Parliament; he had hopes of government careers for them, and this was an unparalleled education in how not to conduct such business." (p. 161)

An excellent observation. Of course, Anderson and Dickson are merely treating their fictitious Hoka as objects of humor but many of my countrymen would make the same remark about the original London Parliament.

I do not think that the Jones' children will grow up and have children before the end of the third volume. Thus, I do not think that the Hoka series approaches future history status but, even if it did, I would qualify that classification. In Classical literature, an epic is a long heroic poem whereas a mock epic, like Metamorphoses, is epic in form though not in content. Since the Hoka series is not serious speculative fiction, to extend it to further generations would be to transform it only into a mock future history.

Addendum: OK, we do have a mark of the passage of time:

"Alex was hardened, after a dozen years on Toka." (p. 162)

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Hi, Paul!

Ha! I'm reminded of how many Britons grumble that maybe Guy Fawkes had the right idea when he wanted to blow up Parliament when pondering the folies of their politicians and Parliament. I assure you, Americans have had similiar ideas. The late Tom Clancy had a Japanese pilot crashing his plane into the Capitol and wiping out the President and Congress in one of his novels!

So, Alexander Jones sending his children to watch how a Hoka parliament functions so they will have some idea of how a gov't should NOT work strikes a chord with me!

Sean

Paul Shackley said...

Sean,
King James commanded that the gunpowder plot be remembered as an infamous event but it is sometimes celebrated with almost the opposite intent.
I have just added an addendum to this post since I am commenting on the texts as I read them which gives the comments a sort of immediacy but means that I sometimes turn over the page to see something that modifies what I have just said.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Hi, Paul!

I knew Guy Fawkes day is a kind of holiday in the UK, albeit anarchic minded Britons might remember "Gunpowder" day in ways James I might not approve of! (Smiles)

Yes, I noticed how you sometimes insert "addendums" to your pieces with second thoughts or corrections.

Sean