If "The Chapter Ends" is to be believed, then the next level of thesis and antithesis is between human and Hulduvian ways of controlling cosmic energy and this conflict is resolved by agreeing to divide the galaxy between oxygen- and hydrogen-breathers.
Monday, 16 February 2026
An Existential Conflict And A Creative Tension
In the first part of Poul Anderson's Psychotechnic History, there is an existential conflict between the Un-Men and the "protean enemy" whereas, in the second half of this future history series, the conflict between the order-preserving Coordination Service and the unintegrated Nomads is more like a creative tension. Civilization has advanced to a stabler level. Coordinators and Nomads are a perfect thesis and antithesis and the perfect synthesis is provided when some Cordies join the Nomads, bringing with them knowledge and expertise that will survive through the Third Dark Ages and inform later civilizations.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Kaor, Paul!
That ineradicable, protean enemy is our flawed, imperfect, corruptible, strife prone, Fallen human nature. Being ineradicable it can only be managed, not cured. Also, readers need to pay attention to that Afterword wrote about the Psychotechnic stories, explaining why he eventually abandoned them.
I hope you and Mrs. Shackley have a great time in Wales!
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
Thank you.
Paul.
Post a Comment