Friday, 1 August 2025

Lucas And God

(Something wrong with this cover?)

Rogue Sword, CHAPTER II.

"On [Lucas Greco], whose childhood had been marred by the clash between the Catholicism of his father's people and the Orthodoxy of his mother's, the Cathayan belief that there were many ways to God, or else none at all, had fastened powerfully. Only in the last few years, as he approached an age where the meaning of things overshadowed the things themselves, had he wondered - more and more often - what God truly wanted of men. Nowhere had he found a reasonable answer." (p. 49)

"...ways to God..." could mean just ways to oneness with the transcendent or eternal, whatever that is, whereas "what God wants of men" implies a transcendent person in the Biblical/Koranic sense.

Do "things" have a meaning? They are not nouns referring to entities other than themselves. In this context, I prefer "value" to "meaning." Life is its own value.

People live by many ways. Some ways lead to greater understanding. I like the Hindu approach which recognizes that many people personify reality whereas others do not. 

How can reality in its primary state be a self-conscious being, a person? Reality has developed and evolved and thus has become conscious of itself through many psychophysical organisms. We are it.

Wanting to understand why people believe differently, I will reread Surprised By Joy, CS Lewis' account of his conversion first to Theism, then to Christianity. I already know first that his approach to Theism involved philosophical reasoning that I disagree with and secondly that his account of his acceptance of Christianity is anything but complete. I have read the Gospels and Gospel commentaries and do not share Lewis' view of them. However, we seek mutual understanding.

(I met an Evangelical who, having read Surprised By Joy, remembered only the account of the moment when Lewis first believed that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and had forgotten everything else. Let us contemplate the whole story.)

Lucas clearly benefited from his time in Cathay.

Lucas Back In Constantinople In April, 1306

Rogue Sword, CHAPTER I.

Surging humanity:

citizens, self-styled Romans
a noble in a palanquin carried by slaves
an Orthodox priest
English
Flemish
Germans
French
Iberians
Italians
Turks
Arabs
Russians
Mongols
"...half the world poured down the throat of New Rome." (p. 26)

"...ocean-like roar..." (ibid.) from:

voices
shuffling, clattering feet
ringing hoofs
rumbling wagon wheels
grumbling, grinding city

Thick, rolling smells from:

dust
smoke
cooking oil
sweat
sewage
horse droppings

Colour:

sun lighting white seagull wings (more hovering scavengers)

Three senses.

Introducing Lucas Greco

Poul Anderson, Rogue Sword (New York, 1960), PROLOGUE.

Lucas Greco demonstrates his survival skills and entrepreneurship. Obliged to flee for his life from Venice, he hogties a Spanish knight's hired servant, takes the servant's place on board the ship that is just about to depart to Constantinople and cheerfully persuades the knight to accept him as a better servant than the man that he has replaced.

Lucas' Arguments
(i) Our Lord told us to forgive wrongdoers.

(ii) Lucas has not harmed the knight but has rid him of a stupid and lazy servant.

(iii) If the knight has Lucas arrested, then he will be without a servant which will be beneath his dignity.

(iv) Lucas is "'...a most excellent servant...,'" (p. 20) able to read, write, calculate, speak fluent Greek and bits of other languages, sing, play a whistle or cither, compose poetry, sail, fight, spy, advise on matters of the heart and learn.

He has Nicholas van Rijn's ability to argue that what is in his interests is in the other person's interests.

See earlier posts on this Prologue here.

Picking Up The Threads Of ROGUE SWORD

See Some More Terminology.

On 21 November 2019, I had read to the end of Poul Anderson's Rogue Sword, CHAPTER VIII, publishing detailed blog posts. There are eighteen chapters. Thus, if I now reread the first eight chapters, I should be able to pick up the thread and resume posting from the ninth chapter. Maybe.

This should run concurrently with reading for the first time SM Stirling's ConanBlood Of The Serpent.

Thus, two swordsmen, one in history, the other in a fantasy past.