Friday 24 November 2017

A Conceptual Chasm

There is a conceptual chasm between works of fantasy about mythological beings like Lilith and hard sf in which a moonship returns to Ganymede. Poul Anderson wrote on both sides of that chasm - not specifically about Lilith but certainly about gods, elves etc. There is also a spectrum of imaginative fiction that partially bridges the chasm:

hard sf (Heinlein, Anderson, Niven etc);
soft sf (Bradbury, Simak, Lewis);
Lewis' combination of interplanetary travel and supernatural beings in a single narrative;
Anderson's Old Phoenix Inn where van Rijn from a hard sf series can meet fantasy characters;
fantasy.

Thus, maybe three intermediate categories. Poul Anderson wrote hard sf, the Old Phoenix and fantasy and, in some of his hard sf works, addressed the same theological issues as Lewis. Anderson did not touch soft sf - except maybe in some early pulp mag stories, e.g., "Witch of the Demon Seas." See here.

3 comments:

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

I wonder how WE would do if ever met a REAL Nicholas van Rijn or Dominic Flandry in some interuniversal nexus point like the Old Phoenix? (Smiles)

I looked up the link to your comments about Anderson's "Witch Of The Demon Seas." I get the impression that you thought it only a so so story by PA. What do you think of the dozen or so stories he wrote for PLANET STORIES? Too purple and action adventure oriented for your taste?

And I did like those of Anderson's PS stories I managed to read, such as "Lord Of A Thousand Suns."

Sean

paulshackley2017@gmail.com said...

Sean,
They were well-written early stories.
Paul.

Sean M. Brooks said...

Kaor, Paul!

Good, I agree. Well written, entertaining stories. And I don't object to Anderson saying that at the time he was writing those stories he needed the money PS paid to do some traveling.

Sean