However, memory also operates by entirely accidental associations or resemblances that cannot possibly be anticipated or intended. Rereading a book can remind any of us of where we were the first time that we read it which is unique to each reader. There was a time when the name of Selden, the escaped convict in The Hound Of The Baskervilles, automatically made me think of Seldon, the psychohistorian in Asimov's Foundation, although there is no possible connection between these two guys even if, just possibly, "Selden" was somewhere in Asimov's memory when he wrote "Seldon." Nowadays, Holmes texts recall the fruitful connections between that series and Poul Anderson's works and these connections, of course, were fully intended by Anderson although not necessarily recognized by all readers. Indeed, "Altamont" and The Origin Of Tree Worship are quite obscure.
Kaor,. Paul!
ReplyDeleteI'm reading some of the Holmes stories because of your blog comments.
Merry Christmas! Sean
Poul admired the artistry and 'atmosphere' of the Holmes stories. Oddly enough, Doyle had a love-hate relationship with them. They're among his best work, but he preferred to do his historical novels. Which are a rousing good read, but not as -subtle- as the Holmes stories.
ReplyDeleteAs a joke, I hijacked some of his historical-novel characters (or their descendants) for the Emberverse series.
ReplyDeleteKaor, Mr. Stirling!
ReplyDeleteI agree, Sir Arthur is always going to be best remembered for his Holmes stories, no matter how much that frustrated him during his own lifetime.
I remember that! You took Sir Nigel Loring, Bart., or his ancestors, from one of Doyle's historical novels. (Smiles)
Merry Christmas! Sean
Sean: and Sam Aylward and Little John Hordle, and Sir Nigel's son. I have an affection for my English ancestors... 8-).
ReplyDeleteKaor, Mr. Stirling!
ReplyDeleteI remember them as well! It's good to see a writer like you saying positive things about the British, after all the bashing and PC nonsense heaped on them for so many years.
Merry Christmas! Sean
I am catching up in the evening. I did not expect so much combox activity today.
ReplyDeleteAlso more pageviews so far today than for all of yesterday.
ReplyDeleteWell, Canada and the United States exist (and Australia and New Zealand) so I think the British Empire was a good thing. And 25% of the human race can speak some English...
ReplyDeleteKaor, Paul and Mr. Stirling!
ReplyDeletePaul: My recent retirement gives me more time for blog commenting. I hope some of these new blog readers will leave remarks of their own.
Mr. Stirling: I agree! But, just to play Devil's Advocates, Ireland was the biggest failure of the British. And I blame the tyrannical, bigoted, and iniquitous policies of Henry VIII, Elizabeth I, and Cromwell for that. With the clumsy mishandling of the Potato Blight Famine of the 1840's by the Liberal gov't being one of the last straws alienating the two peoples.
Happy New Year! Sean
Sean,
ReplyDeleteWelcome to the ranks of the retired.
Paul.
Sean: well, the Welsh and the Scots cooperated with the English, and did very well out of it.
ReplyDeleteKaor, Paul and Mr. Stirling!
ReplyDeletePaul: Thanks! It was time to go, after 34 years.
Mr. Stirling: Too true, such as those Scottish "plantations" set up in Ulster, with all their baleful consequences.
Happy New Year! Sean