The Merman's Children, Book Two.
The Mediterranean is:
"...a narrow sea divided between Christian and Mussulman with naught of Faerie surviving." (IV, p. 94)
Islam is:
"...a faith which kindled still more zeal against Faerie than Christendom generally did." (I, p. 75)
Again, this narrative is much closer to that end of Faerie that Poul Anderson had predicted at the end of his FOREWORD to The Broken Sword.
I read, and might still have somewhere upstairs after a house move (in fact, it is here), a nineteenth century work of Roman Catholic apologetics by an American clergyman who:
described the Paris Commune as a "many-headed monster";
said that the Holy Land was "profaned by the foot of the Mussulman";
accused Protestants of "monstrous ingratitude" because they accept the Bible but not the early Church that formulated the Christian canon of scripture;
accepted a literal Adam and Eve and Annunciation by Gabriel to the Virgin Mary.
This demonstrates what I was told as a trainee Religious Education teacher in Manchester, that there is no unchanging religious tradition. A city centre Church incorporated a Centre for the Study of Religion in the Urban Environment which printed documents for different religious communities. We, a group of students, were taken on a tour which included a synagogue. We had access to nineteenth century Christian missionary material which, however, was not on public display because some of it was regarded as offensive. Nowadays, where they exist, Pagans are just another religious group.
Traditions will have changed again in the kinds of futures projected by sf writers.
Kaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteTHE MERMAN'S CHILDREN mentioned a group who were even more harshly opposed to Faerie than the Muslims, the Bogomils. A sect descended, I think, from the Manicheans.
I think you are using the word "tradition" too loosely. There is a difference between the opinions of the author of this book and the way Catholic theologians define that word.
Ad astra! Sean
Kaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteIt is a matter of defined doctrine in the Catholic Church that angels, non-corporeal beings, exist. And that, for special reasons, the good angels can appear to men and women. Thus I see nothing implausible in the Archangel Raphael appearing to the BVM.
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
ReplyDeleteAnd I see it as entirely an apologetic tale, a hero myth, created by Luke.
Paul.
Kaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteAnd I disagree. The apparitions of the BVM at Lourdes and Fatima challenges anti-supernaturalism.
Ad astra! Sean
And I disagree. Apparitions are culturally conditioned projections. Hindus see Krishna and Kali.
ReplyDeleteKaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteI disagree, because St. Paul warned his converts Satan could pretend to be a good spirit, to deceive some. The apparitions at Lourdes and Fatima were real and authorized by God. And the miracles recorded at Lourdes are also challenges to anti-supernaturalism.
Ad astra! Sean
Ad astra! Sean
Sean,
ReplyDeleteThe apparitions were real? Who says? We have discussed miracles several times.
Paul.